A Mess Of Mario Draghi's Own Making

by: Markos Kaminis

European Central Bank (ECB) Chairman Mario Draghi pulled out of his planned appearance at the Kansas City Fed's Jackson Hole Symposium this weekend. The ECB chief has been under the spotlight since declaring that the euro would not fail and the ECB would not fail it. His appearances since have been highly heralded, as markets wait for follow through. I warned about his scheduled appearance just yesterday, saying, "The euro is likely to face a test after its recent rally, especially if Mario Draghi can only offer more talk without follow through, as I expect this weekend." So it would appear that Draghi has taken some age old wisdom to heart, and that would be, "If you don't have something nice to say, don't say anything at all."

Federal Reserve Chairman Bernanke will address the Jackson Hole crowd, and the world, this Friday morning at 10:00 AM EDT. Seeing as the Fed boss typically plays by the book, he really should not usher in any new Fed policy this week. Rather, he and the rest of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), to which he is bound, will issue policy as prescribed in September following much deliberation and process.

Considering Draghi was scheduled to partake in a panel discussion on Saturday, it would appear that he would likewise not offer much new news. Draghi, like Bernanke, also has a prescribed process to follow and all sorts of other red tape to work through before issuing policy, and especially before launching any new initiative. This makes it highly unlikely that he could do anything more than disappoint the high expectations of the market this weekend. But, he only has himself to blame for the predicament he finds himself in today.

Shaky markets were reassured by his July 26 statement to a London investment conference marking the start of the Olympics. Draghi's now infamous declaration read, "Within our mandate, the ECB is ready to do whatever it takes to preserve the euro. And believe me, it will be enough." Markets mostly focused on the "it will be enough" part, and unfortunately tossed the "within our mandate" portion aside for later chewing. Continuing on an upward trajectory begun in early June, the SPDR S&P 500 (NYSEARCA:SPY) climbed another 3.8% from July 26 through August 28. The SPDR Dow Jones Industrials Average (NYSEARCA:DIA) gained 2.0% and the PowerShares QQQ (NASDAQ:QQQ) has risen 7.9%. Obviously, Draghi has had more influence on the direction of the euro and European shares. You can see the stabilizing impact of Draghi's statement clearly in the chart of the euro/dollar comparison.

Chart forEUR/USD (EURUSD=X)Draghi's impact is also prominently behind the more significant gains of European stocks, in comparison to U.S. shares since July 26. The iShares S&P Europe 350 (NYSEARCA:IEV) has gained 7.0% through August 28. ETFs of the hardest hit nations of Europe have done even better; those are the nations that would benefit from ECB purchases of their debt.



iShares MSCI Spain Index (NYSEARCA:EWP)


iShares MSCI Italy Index (NYSEARCA:EWI)


Global X FTSE Greece 20 (NYSEARCA:GREK)


iShares MSCI France Index (NYSEARCA:EWQ)


iShares MSCI Germany Index (NYSEARCA:EWG)


Click to enlarge

But since Draghi's statement, he's found himself backtracking and qualifying comments. His announcement about missing Jackson Hole to focus on an otherwise busy work schedule was clearly carefully constructed to manage expectations. Spanish yields have expanded since the news broke that he would not appear at the central bank event. However, his reason for not making it because of workload implies he's possibly working on something that might support the euro and the region generally. It's quite a mess he's found himself in, and one our own Fed chief does his best to avoid. It is not central bank concern to manage equity market expectations, but stock investors follow closely the words of those who impact the cost of corporate funding. So, wise bankers carefully word every statement so as to keep speculators from reading into anything.

Draghi's infamous words did exactly the opposite. I suppose the leaders of Europe are happy about that today, since the euro has stabilized, yields have eased, and European equity portfolios have fattened. However, the devils in the game at play will eventually take the candy away and replace it with nails. It's a game best not entered, and one I'm sure Mario Draghi wishes he did not step into. If this is not yet so, I'm certain that someday he will regret it.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.