Seeking Alpha
About this author:

If the first 2 weeks of trading are any indication, these next 6 rounds (two quarters) will be a very bruising indeed, with steeper drops to come. Using other analogies, the ping pong ball still has not reached the bottom of the stairwell. And though she is now on stage, the fat lady has not yet sung.

Back in October, we cautioned about 4 Horsemen of the Apocalypse appearing on the horizon, posing a threat to our stock market. They were Fed Policy, Economic Data, Corporate Quarterly & Annual Reports, and Political Events. Well, they each have arrived - - - and from all appearances, they will not soon depart. In general, stock markets are fed by 4 forces: economic growth - profit growth - interest rates - inflation.

Regardless of whether these market factors are viewed in the lens of a past, present, or future tense, we here in the U.S. are facing the worst of all scenarios - - - the economy and profits are slowing, not growing, while inflation is rising, and interest rates are soon to follow. (There is little room for Mr. Bernanke to do any cutting, and sooner or later the dollar does have to be defended.)

Recent statistics have been miserable to read: Dow and S&P now in bear territory;

Fannie Mae (FNM) and Freddie Mac (FRE) at their lowest prices since 1992; weekly jobless claims topping 400,000 (another sign of economic weakness); Wachovia (WB), second-largest chain of U.S. banks, expecting a second quarter loss of $2.6 to $2.8 billion; General Motors (GM) fighting bankruptcy rumors.

We could fill more paragraphs with similar notes, but by now you have the picture.

Our economy is in deep doo-doo, is not likely to emerge soon, and there is more bad news to come. Continuing to cloud the future is the fact that our U.S. economic problems are now affecting other major world economies. This bout of global flu will have to run its course, and that means our trading partners in Europe and Asia will have to suffer. And much like the U.S., there will be no quick fixes for them either. As a famous econ professor put it, “economies are like ocean liners; their momentum prevents any quick change of course”.

We expect that before things turn around the Dow will have reached the 10,200 area.

A similar drop for the S&P would take that index down to the 1,100 range. Given no exogenous events like earthquakes, terror strikes, or missile launches to create a sudden drop, the best analogy remains the ping pong ball, bouncing down the stairwell.

Such an up and down scenario will present many opportunities for traders, and also for investors looking to average down on their holdings. Income seekers should investigate Canroys like Harvest Energy Trust (HTE) and Penn West (PWE). Value seekers should be looking at stocks like MV Oil Trust (MVO), Continental Resources (CLR) and Mariner Energy (ME).

More cautious investors should consider adding some UltraShort S&P500 ProShares ETF (SDS) on its drops. Obviously, you should do your own due diligence, and then consider using some technical indicators like Bollinger bands or the E-Zone System to find your best entry points - - - and especially those exit points if you are trading.

Disclosure: Author holds long positions in HTE, PWE, SDS, MVO.

Print this article with comments

This article has 25 comments:

  •  
    Excellent column. I hope you won't mind a tangential question. HTE is a Canadian trust and that nation collects taxes on the dividends. Can Americans file a tax return in Canada to have those taxes refunded? (Assuming the amounts are relatively small.) If not, then the yields shown on the stock charts are not true (too high) for American investors.
    2008 Jul 13 08:01 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    NO, can't file in Canada...however, you can claim them as foreign taxes on US taxes.
    2008 Jul 13 08:13 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Subtract the 15 percent they take off the top and they still are great. You can declare foreign taxes paid on your US tax return.
    2008 Jul 13 08:13 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Excellent article. I totality agree that we are going to get worse yet. Now that it is a world market, the U.S. market may not recover from this, especially if there is a middle east problem. We should the market alone and it will take care of it's self. To many tv and radio and internet talking heads.
    2008 Jul 13 08:15 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Waiting for hell seems OK as long as the bill is paid.

    Remember to take your gold along.
    2008 Jul 13 08:37 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Wouldn't the stairway ping pong ball move sideways with lots of violent bear rallies along the way? I would say that's when you get in the SDS or press up short positions. We bears want to test the next set of lows.
    2008 Jul 13 09:10 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I am not sure I would agree that SDS is for the "conservative" investor, since it is a DOUBLE inverse ETF. Entry and stop loss points are very important with this ETF, as it can be quite easy to get burned with any sort of rally.
    2008 Jul 13 09:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Down is the direction. How far and fast will be determined by how the quickly the stream of bad news pours out.
    2008 Jul 13 10:04 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    There are a few unmentioned factors that could make the downflip even larger:

    For the first time in history (of this fiat money system) total bank credit in the USA is declining, link:

    research.stlouisfed.or...

    Actually this decline is more than it shows in the graph, I have seen a more recent version that shows a clear tipping point.

    In the graph from the link you see total debt of the US commercial banks is about nine trillion, the US financial sector as a whole has over on gross domestic product of debt on herself. Link (see the one last column):

    www.federalreserve.gov...

    Actually it says 15945.7 billion US$ or 16 trillion and thus more than one GDP. When people start thinking about how this mountain of debt is going to be paid for, there is plenty of room for the stock indices to decline much further.

    Just a little experiment of thought: Suppose there is a 5% interest level on this 16 trillion, that means yearly interest paid is 800 billion US$.

    Of course a lot of that interest is from the fin sector to the fin sector, but in the end these interest payments work as a big tax on the entire sector.
    2008 Jul 13 11:06 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    For Wally Jr, the 15 % canadian withholding is not a deduction on your tax return, but a tax credit; that means for each dollar withheld by Canada, one dollar is subtracted from what you owe Uncle Sam. So it is just as valuable as getting the full amount of the dividend.
    2008 Jul 13 11:30 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I have HTE and as oil goes up it goes down.Also PGH which is considered the better oil trust has been going down. Canada may raise their taxes in the near future and this may be what is having a negative effect on them.
    2008 Jul 13 11:47 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    TERRIFIC piece! Buy GOLD and SILVER, take physical possession...and wait!
    2008 Jul 13 01:06 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Re: The 15% tax issue... Remember that you cannot take the credit if you hold these equities in your IRAs .. And do be aware of the Canadian tax issues on the horizon (2010 if I remember correctly ..)..

    Thx jegan ;-)
    2008 Jul 13 02:59 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Since the direction is Down, by buying an inverse ETF and holding it tru the normal Bear Market rallies you will not get burned. Its Insurance not a trade.

    The CanRoys are stocks trading on the Nyse, it doesn't matter whether they are over/under valued or the Country of Origin. As the Tide goes out only special situations have a chance of rising.

    With Financial Institutions facing the reality of their unmarketable assets, they will continue to dump. Some will hold out and pray, like Goldman, so later quarters will feel the pain again.

    For now, I would think a sustainable bear rally will be in the offing after the TooTs have their heads handed to them again.
    2008 Jul 13 04:34 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Is staying in global mutual funds a bad idea?
    2008 Jul 13 07:15 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    That fat lady is watching that ping pong ball herself. When that ball hits, she will start to sing. There will be a point when a mild panic will set in and the Dow will hit that 10,200 mark. Be ready because money will be made on the upswing. Any time frame you might want to add MR. Hottinger ? Great article.
    2008 Jul 13 08:38 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I'm not sure who seems to know less about Candian Trusts...the useless David Bui or paultaut in his comments above...Not everything will go down if the Dow goes down...Canadian Trusts like PWE will be able to increase dividends even if oil drops to $110 a barrel..very unlikely.
    Oil may be near a top at this point but natural gas certainly is far from one..and most CanRoys are largely gas oriented. It really pays to listen to someone who actually knows something in this area.
    2008 Jul 13 09:12 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The Canroys are wasting assets. The high payout is an illusion. The investors are simply being paid back with their own capital while the Canroy managers cut a fat hog.
    2008 Jul 13 09:41 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    For GeoRealist:

    Most of these canroys are hedged, some better than others.
    I do think that HTE and PWE hedges are some of the best, and this will protect their divvys.

    Just MVHO
    2008 Jul 13 09:45 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Wait for PWE to come up with another excuse not to raise its dividend, it is already down around 10% as are its bretheren in the past month in the face of ever rising oil prices.

    PWE around 28 would be a decent entry point.

    2008 Jul 14 12:41 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Someone tried to make a case that one of my favorite CanRoys had a PayOut last quarter that exceeded 100% of its earnings. This was true if you took into account Non-Cash write downs. On an Operational Basis, the payout was 73%. But Hey, do your own Homework.

    Most people here will push stocks they like and pan the ones they don't. It is human nature to do so.
    I will do the same, but I like to look not only at fundamentals but Insider Activity and Technical Analysis. And I have even cut off my nose to spite my face because I felt everyone else was wrong and I alone was right.

    As for PWE and all of its backers, I wish all of you to buy it and drive its price above $40 so I can get out at the level I was stupid enough to stay in.
    2008 Jul 14 12:53 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    rubbish article. Suggesting SDS now is a bad idea. all such articles will go away within a week after there is a 5% run on all indices. The best thing is to stay away from oil unless you are playing with other people's money. Buy some Tips, and slowly add equities to your portfolio, how is it possible for everyone to be able to buy at the bottom. No one knows the bottom, not even Goldman Sachs. Buying some Gold for a 5 year tenure is also an excellent idea. Stay away from other metals and commodities as well. Agriculture is also a good bet.
    2008 Jul 14 02:07 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Thanks, everyone. I really appreciate your comments. Very helpful.
    2008 Jul 14 09:15 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    “economies are like ocean liners, geez, anyone seen the Titanic lately?
    2008 Jul 14 11:33 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Those high dividend rates look tempting but there is also considerable danger. I have traded these things for years. First of all, the stock value WILL float up and down with the tide which is most certainly going out. There is little evidence that the dividend rate will positively affect the stock price.

    Second, in this extremely volatile and fickle commodities market, it is impossible to count on the dividend rate staying high. The dividends will fluctuate along with the price of crude. When dividend cuts occur, as they must, investors will run like lemmings off the cliff and drastically cut the share price.

    Third, no one knows what will happen as we get closer to the Can. tax gouge that is scheduled for 2011. It is impossible to tell when investors will start pulling out (if this is not already happening).

    There are many uncertainties and it makes no sense to get a hefty dividend if it is all lost in share prices. Maybe when this very erratic and confused market stabilizes it will be possible to trust the trusts will provide a decent overall return. There is an old and mostly forgotten investing principle which still holds true for high yields like these: RISK=REWARD.
    2008 Aug 01 03:15 PM | Link | Reply
More by Fritz Hottinger
Other articles by Fritz Hottinger »