Pfizer Stock: Value Trap?

Jul.21.08 | About: Pfizer Inc. (PFE)

Pfizer, Inc. (NYSE:PFE) engages in the discovery, development, manufacture, and marketing of prescription medicines for humans and animals worldwide.

The company is a dividend aristocrat as well as a component of the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrials indexes. It has been increasing its dividends for the past 41 consecutive years. From 1998 up until 2007 this dividend growth stock has delivered an annual average total return of 1.1 % to its shareholders. The stock has lost more than 63% from its all-time-high of $50 in 1999, however.

At the same time the company has managed to deliver a 3.60% average annual increase in its EPS since 1998. Pfizer faces many problems, including the fact that almost fifty percent of its US drug revenues will face patent expiration after 2011. The drug Lipitor for example, which accounted for more than a quarter of PFE’s sales in 2007 loses its patent in 2011. Although management spent $ 8.3 billion on R&D in 2007, there haven’t been any blockbuster drugs which will easily replace the ones that face generic competition after 2011-2013. Click to enlarge:


The ROE has decreased over the past ten years from a little over 49 % in 2002 to a little over 11% by 2007. Click to enlarge:


Annual dividend payments have increased over the past 10 years by an average of 17.70% annually, which is significantly above the growth in EPS. An 18 % growth in dividends translates into the dividend payment doubling almost every four years. If we look at historical data, going as far back as 1982, PFE has actually managed to double its dividend payment every five years on average.
Future dividend increases in dividends in the rate of 17% annually will be harder to obtain however, unless the company finds new drugs that it could use to generate more revenues. Click to enlarge:


If we invested $100,000 in PFE on December 31, 1997 we would have bought 4024 shares (Adjusted for a 3:1 stock split in July 1999). In February 1998 your quarterly dividend income would have been $ 255. If you kept reinvesting the dividends though instead of spending them, your quarterly dividend income would have risen to $1412 by November 2007. For a period of 10 years, your quarterly dividend income has increased by 358%. If you reinvested it though, your quarterly dividend income would have increased by 454%. Click to enlarge:


The dividend payout has fluctuated greatly between 20% and 110% over the past ten years. At the end of 2007 the payout stood at 99%, which is very high. Even if EPS for 2008 reaches $2.00 the DPR will still be high at 64%. A lower payout is always a plus, since it leaves room for consistent dividend growth minimizing the impact of short-term fluctuations in earnings. Click to enlarge:


PFE currently spots a P/E of 16.70, a high dividend payout ratio and a very high yield of over 7%. On the surface, PFE does appear cheap, but in my opinion it could be a value trap for investors. Until management starts producing new drugs either through acquisitions of competitors or by creating the drugs, PFE will continue to be a losing proposition. Even though management has tried to cut costs by closing several production facilities, the major problem that PFE faces is uncertainty about the source of future revenue streams for the company. Given the stagnant EPS and the expected major revenue decreases after 2011, I doubt the sustainability of PFE’s future dividend increases.

The company should continue as a going concern in the future however, given the fact that 50% of its sales come from abroad and its ability to cut costs.

In addition, because of PFE’s current strong cash flow position I believe that the company does have the ability to buy new drugs by acquiring other companies and grow its revenues. The fact that twelve out of eighteen analysts rate PFE as “hold”, which is Wall Street’s jargon for having a sell recommendation on the shares, could be a potential contrarian sentiment indicator.

In the end I would consider initiating a PFE long myself when the payout is less than 50%. Until then, this big pharma stock will only have place on my watch list.

Disclosure: I do not own shares of PFE