Seeking Alpha
Seeking Alpha Portfolio App for iPad
Finance
(1)

While markets seemed to take comfort from last week's moves by Citigroup (C), Merrill Lynch (MER) and UBS (UBS) to buy back about $30B of illiquid auction-rate securities [ARS] from clients at face value, Barron's Jacqueline Doherty says the mess is still far fom a happy ending. Here's why:

  • With about $220B in ARS still outstanding, look for regulators - bolstered by their initial successes - to go after more issuers, such as Credit Suisse (CS), Wachovia (WB) and Bank of America (BAC).
  • Aside from potential losses arising from the buybacks (Citi estimates a $500M loss, UBS is looking at $900M, while Merrill says the impact won't be material), the banks and brokers need to come up with the cash to finance the purchases. Most will likely have to sell debt.
  • The deals do more for retail clients than institutional investors (Citi offered its 'best efforts' to help corporate clients with $12B in ARS, and UBS says it will buy back $10.3B by June 2010). Some large investors are already suing banks that sold them ARS, while others have thrown their weight around - and procured 'sweetheart deals' of $0.90 on the dollar, vs. a street value of about $0.70.

Municipal ARS issuers have successfully exited and/or restructured more than half their $175B in ARS debt, and the trend should continue. Same for closed-end funds. Student lenders ($85B) and CDOs ($20B) that sold auction-rate debt have made little if any progress; the former, because it can't sell new debt at low-enough rates to make it plausible, and the latter because of the deteriorating credit quality of the underlying.