Seeking Alpha

Michael Panzner


About this author:

Slowly but surely, a growing number of people - except equity investors and Wall Street "strategists," many of whom seem to lack the brainpower necessary to figure such things out -- are coming around to the idea that there is something highly unusual about what is happening on Wall Street and Main Street.

Instead of another brief crisis that quickly blows over - aided, perhaps, by the supposedly all-powerful Federal Reserve - and a garden-variety downturn that rumbles by without causing too much damage, we have a lingering and contagious disaster in the financial sector that is wreaking widespread havoc in an already unraveling economy.

Such circumstances bring to mind an earlier, more dangerous time. In fact, according to a report in the Scotsman, "Slowdown Echoes Great Depression, Says Bank's Deputy Chief," even central bankers are beginning to acknowledge that the once unimaginable is now a very realistic possibility.

Print this article with comments

This article has 18 comments:

  •  
    Job losses and reduced output have not yet begun to impact house prices.
    This means another dog-leg down, and tock prices do not reflect that, or the losses that banks will have to bear.
    Add to that the fact that we have discovered more oil at a rate which is a fraction of consumption for decades, which means that over the medium term oil prices have nowhere to go but up, and it is clear to anyone who chooses to look that we are in depression territory, not recession.
    2008 Aug 27 08:41 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The Depression had many quantitative aspects. The use of the word is a bit over the top unless the user expects impacts that are of the same magnitude. 25% unemployment. 25% GDP contraction. nickgogerty.typepad.co...
    2008 Aug 27 09:31 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    nobody knows anything.its a new world order in finance,wall st & vegas.its all the same game.sadly
    2008 Aug 27 09:57 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Paul* "first time I read a full article on SA" smacks of someone not willing to read any article except those that agree with his current opinion ... which is cemented in concrete. I'm not saying you are not right, I'm saying you just TOLD us "I have my blinders on". Why should anyone agree except through means other than yourself. Make sure your eyes are open.
    2008 Aug 27 10:17 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    You get paid to write three paragraphs and link to someone elses work? What lazy BS, you must be a democrat
    2008 Aug 27 10:42 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    This depression has been in the making for some time now. It's characteristics will be a sort of Chinese water torture of drip, drip, drip as everything goes down, down, and down.

    The American family's wealth is built upon inflated home values going back to the 70s. These values were intoxicating to the point where the national mantra and cocktail chatter turned to how real estate can't fail!!! This, of course, led to greater borrowing, extended credit card commitments, and a tendency to eschew savings entirely. Real estate turned into a casino , a roulette wheel, and a Ponzi scheme at the same time.

    The crash is inevitable, inexorable, and ineluctable, but don't look for a "black Friday" event to kick it off. The same old groups will be blamed for it as those blamed in the last depression. You can see it now in the chat rooms.

    Until the crash blows over, I'm out of stocks and in cash, treasuries and gold.
    2008 Aug 27 10:53 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Econ 101... so sad that you and your fellow repukelicans have one weapon, and one weapon only - go on the attack to trash the Democrats - because when you look to the pathetic record of your own despicable party you can't find a single thing on the face of the earth to compliment yourselves on.

    So attack away, the vast majority of the country is discovering the truth behind the republican lies... tick tick tick
    2008 Aug 27 12:17 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    How did politics get into this discussion? There's lots of blame to go around for the state of our economy. Whether or not the market crashes, the economy is being pushed along by easy money polices that weren't employed by Hoover and the Fed to avoid the depression. Of course, we may get hyper inflation instead but at least Ron Paul will be able to say "I told you so". I prefer to think about the short term what to do....for example, if McCain wins, the likelihood of a renewed Cold War with Russia would be wonderful for defense stocks.
    2008 Aug 27 12:30 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    A depression is in effect a recession that repeats with 1) bruised balance sheets, 2) decreased consumption, 3) decreased production and back to 1). Here we're looking at asset deflation through virtually all classes; equity, real estate & vehicles. The great and powerful wizard can only destroy the country by trying to offset the 6 trillion in deflation with more fiat. This is a modern depression seekingalpha.com/artic.... Assets will descend to a reasonable level that is in line with our productivity in a vastly more competitive global market.

    The precipice upon which we are perched will determine whether American Capitalism will continue. Freddie & Fannie won't go under simply because that would salt the fertile playground we call financial markets with a dose of socialism. The real masters of the universe won't allow that as there are so many suckers lining the tables and no eye in the sky.


    2008 Aug 27 01:19 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The Great Depression was unique in several ways.

    First, it came in between the two European civil wars that destroyed the European hegemony over the world and left the economic field open for the United States after 1945.

    Second, it saw the rise of Adolf Hitler's closed economy which contributed to America's defensive decision to close our own economic borders. France also existed as a closed economy in the 1930's. Both the French and German economies prospered under the protectionist doctrine of the 1930's but the American economy obviously suffered.

    It came at a time when France and England still controlled most of the third word's resources but Japan and Germany were challenging them. America could only look to South America, the Philippines, Hawaii, Alaska and other territories for commodities. Fortunately, we found most of the commodities we needed on our own continent.

    Third, the Great Depression came after a twenty year economic revolution where 80% of the people lived on farms in 1900 but only 20% in 1935. This produced a socio-economic dislocation which contributed to the economic chaos.

    The post 1900 economy was the first American economy which looked much like the present economy and was based on mass consumption and advertising and a fast developing technology.

    We have a similar economy today but the world economic situation is completely different.

    In the present situation, America seems to be in the process of destroying itself, the same way Europe did from 1914 to 1945.

    History repeats itself but with variations.

    There is still hope if we come to our senses. History doesn't provide very many examples of good sense, however.
    2008 Aug 27 03:35 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    User 8240: You must have a lot of money tied up in the defense industries. Why else would you want more wars? The two we are fighting have cost the United States dearly in people killed and crippled for the rest of their lives, not to mention the money that we could have used to rebuild our infrastructure, improving science and math education, and stimulating innovation that will create new industries and jobs. The new wars that you and perhaps others may get us in will lead to a reinstitution of the draft (because our military is already strained) which will involve many of our children and perhaps grandchildren losing their lives and further bankrupt us as a nation. Not a nice future, but some people will continue to make a lot of money. I believe that it was a Republican president, Dwight D. Eisenhower that warned us about the military-industrial complex. Too bad current Republicans have not heeded his warning.
    2008 Aug 27 04:11 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    •  • Website: http://tickerspy.com
    Cary_Jim: Good observation. We still have all the resources we need right in our back yard we just need the gumption to go after them. That is really the only saving grace. Watch as SEP 30 aproaches and the blind mice begin to run in circles becaus they are sure the sky is falling. There is an anceint Chinese curse "May you live in interesting times." I think that the times are getting very interesting.
    2008 Aug 27 04:27 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I think the "target" for our decline has been described over and over....."We want a "soft-landing". This soft landing is still a crash....but slow, calm and in many ways controlled.

    So if all goes to plan, we will see a slow eroding of standard of living and wealth in the USA. If things go odd track, well....a violent nose-first decent might give us much different results. (I'm not sure the Lobster ends up any less dead after the slow-rising temperature boil as opposed to the plunge into the boiling pot.....but perhaps one is more tasty than the other...no?)
    2008 Aug 27 06:57 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I am an optomist for the future of mankind. Ready for the heavy lifting required. No more fear of the uknown. It is known, it is a deflation from August 2007 GDP to 80% of it's former glory. That's still a $10 T economy. And to be frank, I hate suffering but I can't stand the self-absorbed, narcassistic assholes being cranked out of colleges these days and into government and central banking. Think of the coming crash as a dark black pool. When you dump several bags of shock into it and flick the filter switch on the water becomes clear in a couple of days. When the crash does come, a portion of our government will be impeached and some true public servants will take over. Some of us here will step up, although it will not be a fun job. Many politicians I know that people think are brilliant are the dimmest bulbs on the planet. These types just happen to be good sales people :)

    My advice I tell all - Buy 60 days supply of food, I prefer wheat pasta and butter flavored Crisco. Have a bottle of chlorine bleach to add one drop to purify two gallons of water, making almost any water supply drinkable. Stick it in a couple of plastic bins and hope you never need it. However, as Ben Franklin once said 'Its better to have it and not need it then need it and not have it'. Besides that, we'll get through a depression and then square off against our enemies. Jim Carey has some good historical points and contexts. America still has a very formidable military to seal it's borders, enough innovators to tap our own energy, America has six times the food supply of the Great Depression era with only twice the population. The comforts and luxuries are what will kill of many in our nation and that is a shame. War will kill those not prepared in mind and spirit, but as a nation we will survive, just as the USSR is now Russian Federation, we will be called something else besides the USA by the time it is all over.

    Specific forecast: Bull market in 2013. North Korean conflict and true flash point of WWIII by 2015. WWIII would last about five years and go nuclear. 1/3 world population of casualties. 1,000 years of peace afterwards and amazing technology innovation including fixing our broken genetics and the ability to accelerate particles of energy many times the speed of light, insert AI into them and explore the entire universe in a second. Good things coming friends, just take care of your famalies and neighbors. The American population will get it's grit back, but pain is the catalyst that spurs necessary innovation. Necessity is the mother of all invention. God bless and see you on the battle lines gentlemen (and ladies).
    2008 Aug 27 07:03 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Michael in this article made a good point that equity investors and Wall Street strategists have too much vested interest to see clearly what is happening ie the danger of another sharp downturn of Depression proportions; they are talking about buying this and that, ever hopeful of a V shape upturn round the corner. It is fair enough to hope for the best but it may be prudent to prepare for the worst, as in all honesty no one can predict the future. The fact is however that on all the available evidence the probability of a severe downturn is now almost [again can never be sure?] the basecase scenario rather a hairy-fairy far off event.
    2008 Aug 28 12:29 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Everyone is forgetting that the central bankers are not looking to become part of the unemployment statistics any time soon.

    Yes, we are in debt up to our eyeballs and that debt requires most of the planet's savings to keep it afloat. Yes, we do not have a lot of headroom to borrow more. Yes, the central bankers are aware of this.

    Why do you think the dollar rallied the last couple of weeks? Foreign dollar reserves at the Fed rose 100 billion in a couple of weeks. Why? The reason is twofold. One, to put downward pressure on commodity prices which were crippling economies worldwide because most of the commodities are priced in dollars. And two, to keep the US market from going further in the tank which will prompt further US borrowing to head off a collapse and put us closer to the day we cannot service the debt we owe them.

    It does not matter who gets elected in November. We are too far past the point of no return to fix what the village idiots in DC have done to us. We are now "The Economy too big to fail" and central bankers around the world are loosing sleep trying to come up with a way to keep us afloat.

    The choices are now either inflate globally to stave off depression, or depression itself. Or, as happened with the invention of the Credit Default Swap, hope some Cambridge graduate can come up with a brilliant idea which will hold off the inevitable for another 8-10 years and leave us in even worse shape. As a cynic, I am betting on option 3.
    2008 Aug 28 03:54 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Michael and all you commentators do not connect the high prices of oil products to some of our problems.

    And, you do nothing about it. Go To

    www.stopoilspeculation.../

    And do something.

    Also, the two writers who want another war are jerks. Just like the bomber McCain....remember bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb IRAN???

    Senator OBAMA and Senator BIDEN will get us out of Iraq and they will not go to war against Iran.

    OBAMA /BIDEN 08

    2008 Aug 28 02:53 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    This article is right on... Americans will be forced to lower expectations big time... until we are competitive with the rest of the world in labor rates and productive capacity and can produce goods approximately as cheaply as China or Indonesia can... We can live off of our tech superiority for a year or two, but that will only slow our descent into the major depression that it will take to reform our base platform as a world power..
    2008 Sep 06 09:48 PM | Link | Reply