Seeking Alpha
About this author:

In response to the largest de facto nationalization in US history, we have this example of Governor Palin's comprehension of this issue (ABC News):

Saturday in Colorado Springs, Colo., Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin said, "The fact is that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have gotten too big and too expensive to the taxpayers. The McCain-Palin administration will make them smaller and smarter and more effective for homeowners who need help."

I can't even start to dissect what's wrong with this statement, so I will let the reader assess Palin's understanding of the role of the GSEs in the financial system. From my perspective, I would have hoped to have more comprehension from a candidate at a time when the estimate of a resulting $300 billion taxpayer liability is viewed as plausible.

For some informed discussion, see Calculated Risk, as well as Nouriel Roubini.

Print this article with comments

This article has 25 comments:

  •  
    let us pray that McCain stays healthy.
    2008 Sep 09 04:49 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Yes, the comments by Palin, Obama and others in the Presidential race make you wonder...

    Here's my take on the candidates:

    Obama: Has no clue, but keeps his mouth shut most of the time.

    Bidden: Has a clue, but never got anywhere with it.

    McCain: See Bidden.

    Palin: Has no clue and can't keep her mouth shut.

    My choice for President? Shai Agassi of Project Better Place. He has a clue, is going to do something with it and when he speaks you feel inspired.
    2008 Sep 09 06:48 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Are we forgetting that as VP Palin would have access to a bevy of professional advisors? (Consider how informed Dick Cheney is about EVERYTHING)

    You all know that every reporter who can get her attention is going to ask a question they hope she answers poorly. If you polled the great American public on fannie and freddie you'd find that most of them are clueless. Not only about their being taken over, but why it was necessary and more importantly how it happened.

    The machinations of money escape most people who aren't involved with it on a daily basis. She didn't have a need to thoroughly understand the largest "de facto nationalization in US history" before Monday and I'd guess that none of the people involved in that decision bothered to brief either camp: Obama or McCain.

    She is bright and gutsy and, guys, SHE is going to help McCain win.

    Embrace her.
    2008 Sep 09 10:05 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    She's a total nitwit and a threat to world stability. There won't be a hole deep enough to hide in if that idiot gets in as veep... says a lot about the party who nominated her too.

    Here's a little piece about the hypocrisy running that party of fools:

    www.comedycentral.com/...

    Funny if it weren't so TERRIFYING.
    2008 Sep 09 10:31 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Within the context of what you quoted what is wrong with the statement? For years people have called for FNMA to be capped. While their quantitative matching capabilities were good ( after the early 1990's debacle) they clearly failed on their qualitative assessment of risk. In addition, given the use of lobbyists and their quasi-governmental backing more allowance was built in for failure. We created a monster out of the nation's desire to aid homeowners and years later we end up with a bureaucratized disaster that under any present value calculation can be said to be a net plus for the country, the investors or homeowners. Wait until Social Security gets tested.
    2008 Sep 09 10:31 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    sorry: next to last sentence should read "...CAN'T...be said to be a net plus..."
    2008 Sep 09 10:34 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Don't let one quick, throwaway comment by Gov. Palin set your tone. It's all political rhetoric at this stage, including the criticisms.

    As someone who has followed her career, my view is that Palin is focused on government spending public money is a way that at least has a semblance of wisdon and accountability. At root, she's a government "cutter" and not a government "grower."

    Yeah, she spent money as the Mayor of Wasilla... at a time when the town about doubled in population and grew out into the boondocks. A lot of the spending was during the boom-boom real estate mushroom, for which Fanie & Freddie take a good share of the blame.

    Alaskans talk about a place called "Los Anchorage," and I think you can figure out where that comment is coming from. Alaskans are torn over willy-nilly growth, especially in a climate where nature is a lot less forgiving than in SoCal. So deep down, you ought to know that Palin understands that Los Anchorage concept very well.

    And I have a hunch that if Gov.Palin has any input, Fannie & Frddie will get busted up and sold off in pieces to smaller, more nimble and far better-managed banking institutions. Really, Fannie & Freddie outlived their purpose many years ago. They were nothing but fiscal dinosaurs, waiting for the asteroid with their name on it.
    2008 Sep 09 10:39 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Sarah Palin should be congratulated for honestly representing the sum total of the GOP capacity to comprehend the issue and deal with it responsibly. I say, "more power to her," for bringing honesty to a GOP that, up to now, has been completely lacking in that respect. Hooray for Sarah!
    2008 Sep 09 10:45 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    She shud answer questions like that along the line of:

    "It just goes to show you whenever the government messes around in the free market it ends in disaster, with the taxpayer paying to clean up the mess. John McCain has a plan for minimising the cost, and making sure Congress doesn't replace this disaster with a "new/improved" disaster that will bite the next generation. Ask him about it sometime."

    Punt. Hey, she's only going to be the powerless VP... it's McCain we'll have to endure.

    2008 Sep 09 11:27 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    So, the folks in Washington are the brains of the country and anyone who cuts spending and returns money to its righful owner (in this case the taxpayer) is a rube. How are the books of the US government (now including the Fan/Fred guarantees) going to be balanced?

    McCanin/Palin should offer a simple solution at the town hall meetings: "Folks, what would you do if your expenses were more than your income?" The same thing Fan/Fred are telling homebuyers to do; cut your expenses and save up for a down payment.

    Why not just state that every government department (including all those off-balance sheet items) is going to freeze hiring and spending at the same level of inflation used to calculate Social Security payments. Ultimately, we might get the budget under control. At least the citizens of this count ry could understand the logic of it. If not, we don't stand much of a chance except with a revolution.
    2008 Sep 09 11:28 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    If McCain Palin get rid of 20% of the corruption in Washington it will be good. 20% of something is better than 100% of nothing.
    2008 Sep 09 11:36 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    What's your point other than to slam Palin? You're quick to criticize, but are apparently too weak to provide any analysis to support your comment, so you leave to posters.

    Fannie & Freddie have been way too expensive to the American taxpayer. You had execs reaping $15MM paycheck while being asleep at the wheel. Now you have the US Gov'ts bailout. How can you not agree Palin's statement on that point?

    Are they too big? Well, that comment may be interpreted in a number of ways. The mortgage market is huge, and FNA & FRE played an important function in providing low cost mortgage financing to US homebuyers. How big should FNA & FRE be? Dunno. But I think Palin's comment w/r/t size was more focused on cost than any other metric. JMO.
    2008 Sep 09 11:38 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I love you Palin lovers. It seems in your book that someone with less than 2yrs experience can qualify to run the most powerful nation on earth. I hope your logic doesn't apply to day to day things like healthcare. I am sure you don't line up to have surgery done by pre-med students that are softmores.
    2008 Sep 09 12:03 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I love you Palin lovers. Here is a lady with less than 2yrs experience as governor of a sparsely populated state that receives huge subsidies from big oil. So this qualifies her to run the most powerful nation on earth? I hope you don't apply this logic to everyday decision such as surgery. I guess it would be fine to have a sophomore pre-med. student to do your triple by-pass eh? And you wonder why the market and economy is down?
    2008 Sep 09 12:07 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Stockmeister - Please tell us Obama's great accomplishment as a legislator. What great piece of legislation did he write and get passed?
    2008 Sep 09 12:15 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Did I state that I liked Obama or believe in his experience oldfolkdance?
    I just don't get how you people can put any of these choices in power. Look at the last 8 yrs and what happened with Bush.
    So you want some non-qualified yahoo from the sticks with no real-world experience to be number 2 if old man McCain kicks the bucket? Are you posting from a cave in Afghanistan or Iran?
    2008 Sep 09 12:26 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Menses is a leftist who has no understanding of the history of corrupt Democratic politicians running Fannie and Freddie for personal gain at the risk of the taxpayer.
    2008 Sep 09 12:34 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    stockmiester

    Actually you did not say anything! Wonder why you post??
    2008 Sep 09 01:41 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    But the only thing I remember about what Bill Clinton did while in the white house is Monica...
    2008 Sep 09 01:43 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    To all those who think that incompetent leaders are no big deal since they have an army of "qualified" counselors; imagine yourself trying to land a Jumbo Jet with 5 qualified pilots shouting to you in panic about what you should do...
    Crash is guaranteed unless you have a very good idea of what's going on.
    2008 Sep 09 01:46 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The sad part is that Obama, Biden and McCain all basically agreed with her statement. We better hope for divided government....
    2008 Sep 09 02:49 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    MCCAIN'S ACTUAL POSITION ***WAS*** that he was going to make Fannie and Freddie "go away" because there were "other institutions" that could do the job.

    Where he thought these other institutions were, I don't know.

    Now, of course, he has backed off that "position" because he's an absolute fraud.
    2008 Sep 09 03:36 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Before Monica there was NAFTA
    2008 Sep 10 07:11 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I rebut thee.
    2008 Sep 10 08:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    wcvarones.blogspot.com...
    2008 Sep 10 08:26 AM | Link | Reply