Seeking Alpha
About this author:

I’m making a bold statement here: We’ve turned a corner. The Worst is over. Our evidence?

1. The Fannie (FNM) and Freddie (FRE) issue was always odd because, for as long as I can remember, there was an implicit guarantee that was unquestioned in all ways. It was a bullet point on every presentation about agency debt. It was a sub–bullet point on every presentation about agency M.B.S. Well, if Fannie and Freddie were always meant to be supported by the government, then why would people doubt that was the case? If the government guarntee was always presupposed, why doubt it? Well, finally, the common sense statement that everyone doubted has been made explicit–which shouldn’t have needed to happen. However, I would claim, when you start doubting the obvious it’s a sign of a bottom. Especially now that the doubt has been quashed and the market is back to “pricing to reality.”

2. Lehman is resolved. As the rumors and estimates piled up, Lehman has gotten crushed. Clearly this firm was the last big unknown as it dominated the news constantly. We knew every gyration and hiccup of the Korean Development Bank and their flirting and courtship with Lehman. Amazing. Well, with their announcement today, we know their losses, their plans for selling stakes in their businesses, and the extent of their real estate woes. Coupled with the mortgage market recovering slightly and stabilizing (see #1 above) the losses from mark to market aren’t likely to spiral far from here.

So, with these two very recent events, it seems reasonable to assume we’re out of the woods… I’ll be bold and predict, then, that the reasonable assumption matches reality.

Print this article with comments

This article has 43 comments:

  •  
    I disagree and I don't understand your logic. Housing has not bottomed = No bottom in credit crunch, it is that simple. Don't get excited about noise.
    2008 Sep 10 04:10 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I am afraid that we won't see a bottom until the markets experience capitulation and there are still too many optomists like you out there for that to happen...yet.
    2008 Sep 10 04:12 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Tom Brown of Second Curve Capital called the bottom July 15, 2008. So far he is right.
    2008 Sep 10 04:30 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Not over till the fat lady sings, and I mean AIG and friends sing.
    2008 Sep 10 04:30 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    No, we have not reached the bottom and we all know it and you know it too. Saying otherwise is a bit misleading....
    2008 Sep 10 04:31 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Just what we need, more sarcasm...
    2008 Sep 10 04:32 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Just words, Just speeches...What part of tanking do you not understand? Lehman out of the woods, where is the name of all that is sound do you support that statement! I have personally listened to guys like you spend me into bankruptcy...and I for one am sick and tired of it and I aint gonna take it anymore...Your gonna have to prove your points from here on out...and not with Just Words, and Just Speeches.
    2008 Sep 10 04:34 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Tom Brown called a bottom on July 15th? Tell that to FNM, FRE, LEH, WM, WB, MER. Even GS fell below it's July 15th low today.
    2008 Sep 10 04:44 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Hahahahahahahahaha.

    MER, WB, WM, C, and that's just for starters.
    2008 Sep 10 04:45 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Ha ha ha ha! Best laugh I have had all day.
    2008 Sep 10 04:46 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    This writer can't even sign his own name. Maybe he is in the federal witness protection program.
    2008 Sep 10 04:47 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    AND HERES MY PROOF...3:27PM Lehman Brothers: Moody's places Lehman's A2 rating on review with direction uncertain (LEH) 7.84 +0.05 : Moody's has placed on review with direction uncertain the long-term ratings of Lehman Brothers Holdings (senior at A2), as well as the long-term ratings of the principal rated operating and guaranteed subsidiaries. Lehman's Prime-1 short-term ratings were placed on review for possible downgrade. Moody's said that the review with direction uncertain reflects the high degree of fluidity in Lehman's current situation. Moody's believes that Lehman's financial flexibility has become more limited as its stock price has fallen to near all-time lows and the firm is experiencing a crisis of confidence. Although Moody's believes liquidity remains firm and has not shown signs of material erosion, the potential for rapid franchise impairment in this environment remains a significant rating concern for Moody's... Moody's believes that Lehman's liquidity pool and its access to the Primary Dealer Credit Facility provide the firm with time to address these challenges. The rating agency believes that Lehman's liquidity management and stand-alone liquidity position remain acceptable... "A strategic transaction with a stronger financial partner would likely add support to the ratings and result in a positive rating action." Conversely, should a strategic arrangement fail to materialize in the near term, Moody's said that the ratings would be downgraded, likely into the Baa category, with the ratings continuing on review for possible downgrade. The rating agency also expects that, should this occur, the rating differential between Lehman's preferred stock ratings and senior ratings would be widened. Moody's said that the wider differential would reflect the increased risk of a suspension of dividend payments in such a scenario.
    2008 Sep 10 04:51 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Your comment I AM Dlogan speaks volumes. Credibility of management is shot and the global investor understands that. Housing will bottom to current household income ratios (which in real terms is declining).
    2008 Sep 10 04:52 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Economy stinks.

    Jobs situation dismal.

    Housing continues to decay.

    Credit crunch = less to spending consumer.

    And you say that we have reached the bottom now that Lehman's got crushed?

    Think again.
    2008 Sep 10 05:08 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Dear John,

    Is this post subtle satire? If you seriously believe that the bottom has been reached, the real John Thain must have put you back on his payroll.
    2008 Sep 10 05:14 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Dear John

    If this is as good as your more recent forecasts, at your new job, we can safely assume someone has left the door unlocked at the home. Be good and go back before someone mistakes you for a real person.
    2008 Sep 10 05:20 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    No one has been successful raising capital lately, so as the financial report next week and admit they are forced to admit they are still in the 3rd inning, timber.
    2008 Sep 10 05:48 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    C'mon, you guys... what he means is that THIS bottom (is it the 19th or 20th one we've seen called?) is the REAL bottom.
    Honest....

    Let's party... just like back in 1999..... Geez.... not again...
    2008 Sep 10 06:13 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Its interesting to note the bearish tone of the replies. As a contraian, I'd say the July 15th bottom might just hold knowing that so many people continue to be this negative. Id' say in a normal market, the bulls would be as much as 80%, but now its less then 20% of the responses. Stay away from the toxic stocks like WM and AIG and you'll probably do well now. Every sector has no been crushed which is a sign of capitulation to me.
    2008 Sep 10 06:28 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Dear Stone Fox Capital
    What do you base your reply on? Show me something, anything that will support your stand...Just stay away from TWO VERY LARGE Financial companies who are on the brink of oblivion...when will the dominos stop falling, if you have a insite into the future that is not full of BOBBLE HEADED YADA YADA...Please enlighten me...Thanks iamdlogan...
    2008 Sep 10 07:28 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    There is no bottom. Analysts estimates are still too high. Eat off of dividends and interest right now...
    2008 Sep 10 08:18 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    He should call himself Dear John Pain..
    2008 Sep 10 08:38 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    hahahahahaha, I've been a long time reader of SA and have never commented before.
    hahahahahahaha Have you been watching Cramer?
    and again. HA
    2008 Sep 10 10:09 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Woohoo! Maybe this bottom will play out better than the last fifty...!!!
    2008 Sep 11 01:26 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Speaking about 'bottoms', I'd rather stair at the bottom on tubgirl.com than read this article again... nuff 'seen'
    2008 Sep 11 03:29 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Puh-leeze, enough with the "I wanna be the next to call the bottom", especially with a pseudonym.

    I predict that Canada will invade Russia and start NOPEC.

    Any other anonymous ridiculous guesses out there?

    2008 Sep 11 09:32 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    the only bottom you can be sure of is the one you sit on.however this site is very entertaining during this stressful period.i lol a lot while reading the agenda motivated authors.luckily,i dont believe a word.
    2008 Sep 11 11:22 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Of course the worst is behind us, the bank balance sheets are strong, the mortgages are paid, the credit cards are paid, everyone has jobs and US manufacturing is again second to none. Or not.

    This far, we haven't yet heard anything about how FNM&FRE situation raped bank balance sheets...or the bond insurers. Just wait.
    2008 Sep 11 11:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Well, now it's time for WaMu and AIG... What you think a bottom might be just a layer of silt (or mud, or muddle...).
    2008 Sep 11 12:35 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    well the bottom has a lot of paper to wipe it.
    2008 Sep 11 01:41 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Post American World... Canada is not going to invade Russia. The exact opposite MAY be true!
    What I'm afraid of is that the contagion will reach us too.
    But of course, all of our experts say, "NO WAY...WE'RE NOT THE USA!"
    Any opinions out there for me??
    2008 Sep 11 02:07 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Good one, lol.


    On Sep 11 01:41 PM notsosmart wrote:

    > well the bottom has a lot of paper to wipe it.
    2008 Sep 11 03:49 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Washington Mutual is next I'm afraid...largest Savings and Loan...300 billion of deposits and bankrupt.
    That will be the next leg down. AIG will take longer.
    2008 Sep 11 09:35 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    what is all this about capitulation? i heard the fear in the NPR newscasters' voices on July 14. if that wasn't capitulation, i don't know what is. it is taking longer to recover than expected because each bank that is going to fail has to do so on its own terms.
    2008 Sep 12 12:32 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Bull markets are
    born on pessimism,
    grow on scepticism,
    mature on optimism,
    and die on euphoria"
    Sir John Templeton
    2008 Sep 12 03:53 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Bull markets are
    born on pessimism,
    grow on scepticism,
    mature on optimism,
    and die on euphoria"
    Sir John Templeton
    2008 Sep 12 03:56 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    All,

    Everyone should calm down and realize that I haven't called a bottom. Go to my original post, the title was: "Bold Statement: Time to Start Partying" ... Meant to be a bit sarcastic. SeekingAlpha re-wrote the headline, as they usually do. I'm just saying that we've turned a corner, most of the uncertainty and irrationality in the markets has been taken out. So, if it gets *much* worse, then I'm wrong. If another firm blows up, sending the market into a tizzy, I'm wrong. Otherwise, if volatility comes down, investor confidence returns, etc. then I'm not totally wrong. Low bar, eh? Wish I would have seen this sooner to set the record straight.

    -DJT
    2008 Sep 12 04:05 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Stocks are seen opening sharply lower at the start of the week after last ditch efforts to save investment bank Lehman Brothers appeared to have failed late Sunday.

    Are You WRONG YET!
    2008 Sep 15 12:39 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    We'll see at the opening bell
    2008 Sep 15 12:45 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    504 points... is this a tizzy or is it a turn around?

    Just talk, just speeches...Just more BS some someone who looks into the center of a storm and sees pretty clouds...this is insane...guys like you are the ones who have extended this bubble of BS. This is my last post on this column, I'll go where the reasoning is... instead of the *$^@)#%)&@%)@)&...
    2008 Sep 15 06:11 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    July 15th bottom did not hold. This "bottom" will turn out to be supported by the same quality financial engineering as the entire off-books accounting that Enron used.

    Until American public company execs can no longer walk away with a fortune as the companies die in their wake, our bubbles will continue to increase exponentially until the entire market collapses under the weight of fraud, deceit, and greed.

    I have a mental picture of what's happening for each of these financial companies. Bruce Willis is the exec walking away, grimy with the filth of greed and fraud, smirking as the company's assets blow up behind him. He kisses his new trophy wife, boards the plush Leer jet, and flies off to his new tropical island bought with stock options worth paper millions from off-book accounting techniques.

    Until the penalties are a deterrent, the Enron's, FNM, FRE, LEH's, WAMU's, etc. of the public company world will continue.

    I say if an exec is in charge within 5 years of a company's implosion, regardless of proven fault, hang 'em at the closing bell on MSNBC. Only take a couple to eliminate the fraud for a long, long time.
    2008 Sep 18 05:53 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    THE GUY WHO THINKS WE HAVE HIT A BOTTOM IS RETARDED OR INSANE.GEORGE SOROS , BOB CHAPMAN, PETER SCHIFF, RON PAUL ETC ETC. ALL THE GUYS WHO GOT IT RIGHT SAY IT HAS ONLY BEGUN. THE BANKS WHO'S SHARES HAVE BEEN ALMOST DESTROYED WANT TO GET THE SUCKERS BACK IN. I KNOW WHO'S ADVICE IM GOING TO TAKE
    BUY GOLD AND SILVER AND THEIR RELATED ASSETS YOU WILL MAKE A FORTUNE
    Mar 28 06:48 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    MADOF WAS THE FOUNDER OF THE NASDQ NUFF SAID THE AMERICAN STOCK MARKETS ARE RUN BY SCAM ARTISTS WHO WANT TO GET YOU (THE SUCKERS MONEY) GET OUT OF THE STOCK MARKET EXCEPT GOLD AND SILVER SHARES GOLD AND SILVER BULLION BEFORE THEY DECIDE TO STOP MANIPULATING THE PRICE AND IT WILL BE TO LATE
    Mar 28 06:50 PM | Link | Reply