Seeking Alpha
About this author:

As many know, Sirius XM Radio’s (SIRI) CEO Mel Karmazin spoke at the Merrill Lunch Media Conference on Tuesday. As anticipated, some additional information was provided to the street regarding expectations, the “Best Of” roll-out, as well as some product information. The reaction by the street was not good, and the stock now trades under $1.00.

One analyst report that I have been eager to see was that of Merrill Lynch’s Jessica Reif Cohen. As a media analyst, Cohen has followed the the career of Mel Karmazin for quite some time, and in my opinion she has had realistic expectations of many media companies. Wednesday Cohen issued her report on Sirius XM Radio.

While many on the street seemed to pick up various negative aspects of Karmazin’s speech, others seemed to pick up the positives. Cohen seems to have taken a realistic look at the equity, not from a short term perspective or a long term perspective, but rather a business perspective.

Cohen noted that Karmazin did point out several areas where merger synergies would be achieved. The $425 million in synergies falls in line with previous company estimates of $400 million. The additional detail and flavor of these estimates should allow for analysts to better model the company.

Cohen notes that company guidance for 21.5 million subs by YE09 is 6% below their prior forecast of 22.9 million, and she attributes the drop to a more conservative outlook on a weakening OEM market. She trimmed her own estimates from the 22.9 million figure to 21.9 million, which is above the number offered by Mel Karmazin at the conference. Karmazin maintained his $300 million in Pro-forma EBITDA, but the adjustments made by Cohen in her model have brought her from a figure of $347 million to a new figure of $287 million. The Merill target moved due to their newly updated model on the business.

Cohen outlined that the biggest hurdle for the company, and perhaps investors, is the near term liquidity. With a challenging credit market, the refinancing of debt is a major concern to the street, and is an overhang on the stock. No matter how rosy someone feels the future of satellite radio is, the company needs to clear this hurdle. The financing issue is like a wall that blocks any view of what is ahead, and because the company, and by extension the investors, are standing so close to the wall it becomes difficult to see anything beyond it.

Merrill Lynch lowered their price target to $3.40. Despite what they consider long term positive aspects to the company, the equity is being weighed on by weaker OEM and retail channels, as well as the refinancing of about $1 billion in the near term.

For investors, the current situation for satellite radio is frustrating. Clearly, satellite radio remains a speculative play, and investors, who have been battle fatigued for quite some time, are not seeing a light at the end of the tunnel. The economy will at some point change. The hurdle that remains the biggest detractor to the stock is the debt issue. Sirius XM has expressed desires to obtain financing without issuing converts or causing dilution. The longer this issue remains on the table, the more concentrated the uncertainty will bring. Even if the financing is completed, the street may be so jaded that it will take a while for the potential of the business model to be considered.

Position: Long SIRI

Print this article with comments

This article has 20 comments:

  •  
    to me it doesn't matter anymore.
    i don't have a lot of my money in this stock.so long term position is fine with me.

    good luck to everyone .this i hope one day will be a winner.
    2008 Sep 11 07:48 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    It seems like the mood has changed from accepting plans/potential to demanding results just like what is happening with Lehman. Having never turned a profit, no working capital, massive debt and a net deficiency in tangible assets in this credit environment, any financings will have to come at a great cost as they have no favorable alternatives available.
    2008 Sep 11 09:13 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    If Mel would count XM subs the same way he has counted Sirius subs in the past, the combined company would instantly have a million more "subs" (cars sitting on dealer lots). Seems like that would have a better way to go than lowering the subscriber target.
    2008 Sep 11 09:20 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    If all they need is $1B I wonder have they considered a Bond issue to shareholders? If you own 10,000 shares you get to buy a $10.000 bond converable into another 10,000 shares in a short term like 5 yrs anf the financing problems would go away. Shareholders know the value of this company. I for one would buy.
    2008 Sep 11 09:28 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    well if they cannot pay their debts by due date creditors will take over period, and get their money somehow, so the trick is to come up with a plan to refinance that debt cause they dont have cash to pay it off by that date.
    2008 Sep 11 09:31 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    $3.40???????? That would be a 350% to 400% increase over today's price. What time frame is that? lol
    2008 Sep 11 09:45 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The 3.40 should be soon but after the reverse split to stay listed.
    2008 Sep 11 10:08 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    A reverse split would not help it any. It just shows how much trouble the company is in. If a split happens, you know investors will sell after it spikes.
    2008 Sep 11 11:11 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I have 15,000 shares. It has been a roller coaster ride thus far, but we all know that this company will not fail!
    2008 Sep 11 11:33 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Murph, the company doesn't have to fail, for the common to go belly up. Witness KMart which is still in business but the common all went to zero. I think this board over the past month is a testimoney to the fact that we teach almost zero about business in American public school. good thing we learned all about biology and cutting up frogs instead.
    2008 Sep 11 12:02 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Exactly Tyler. A shred of real information here. The analyist were forced to lower guidance, because Sirius did. But you almost missed an important part of here report. She isnt trusting Sirius on their own numbers. She maintains them higher cause she knows better. Probably the more honest of the analyists.
    2008 Sep 11 12:32 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    3.2 billion shares outstanding for a company with a current market cap of $2.9 billion. I've been saying for months that a reverse split is inevitable. A 1:3 split would bring the sheer number of shares down to just over 1 billion. It might (just maybe) level the playing field a bit between the longs and the shorts.
    2008 Sep 11 01:52 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Adding 2M subscribers in '09 is ludicrously low. A 50% penetration rate in new autos with a very low churn rate means they're forecasting a 4-4.5 million new car market in 2009? The car market will very conservatively be 14 million units next year. Buy deep. Also....Sirius is adding ESPN and CNN to their TV lineup......in 2009 vehicles.
    2008 Sep 12 11:37 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    All, remember that the two democrats voted against the merger in the end. If Obama wins, the FCC board will be 3 democrats and 2 republicans. If that happens we can expect them to throw everything they have at SIRI to either kill it or bust it up. VOTE REPUBLICAN!!
    2008 Sep 12 08:48 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Stan Muse, I will now disput your trollish comments.
    Give me examples of a presidence to reopen cases that are closed? Any of this magnitude? Obama is black. Jessie Jackson is black. Minority owned stations on satellite. I dont think so, its a move forward for minorities. Obama will have enough on his hands to worry about Sirius, but your funny for giving Sirius that much importance, just proves the longs right that you would even suggest that. Thanks for the positive comments that they president of the free world would care. Trust me, he doesnt give a rats ass about satellite radio, other than to throw props to fellow democrat Jessie Jackson for railroading in minority owned stations who can cater to their democraphic. Wont undue all the work he did so they can bring back terrestrial radio, which is dead, and even they know it. They no longer trade on the open exchange(CCC), because they dont want the embarrassement of having their stock drop below Sirius's(plus the huge hit to their bank accounts of course, ;-) )
    Lie disputed with facts. Now you counter with facts.
    2008 Sep 12 11:13 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    If they reverse split, I would jump up and down for joy!!!!
    Id have my margin back I lost when it went under $1. Of course I didnt have anything on margin at the time that Sirius was backing up, because I know in the spec game, you dont use margin for those purchases. I would kiss Mels happy as if it reversed split.
    I would buy 3000 shares of Yamana gold that INSTANT!!!
    2008 Sep 12 11:15 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    No, i would not buy Sirius. I spent all my money on spec stocks already. I apologize for saying Yamana gold, this is a Sirius forum, if i could edit my comments I would. I am NOT recommending that stock, it was a random commodity stock just in my head at the time. DYODD.
    2008 Sep 12 11:17 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    A reverse split minimizes the shorters abilities to control the price(increase in demand is harder to abade with less stock available(floating).
    Simple math. If you have 1 billion floating shares, and you get a desire in the market for those shares, you now have less control over keeping it down. Less stock in the float to use to control those purchases(shorts lose big time in a reverse split). Shorters LOVE HIGH FLOAT. Cause if they need to cover, there are simply more shares available to cover with. 2 billion other peoples shares available to cover. To speak about a reverse split, people worry there would be more room to tank it again(true in pure numbers) but not in reality. Call your broker and ask him. If a shorter wanted to control a stock down, that can at any moment experience high deman(and we all know Sirius is one deal away from blowing the roof of this stock) would they shorters rather have more float available, or less float available?) Dont take my word for it, ask "professionals" this very easy question. Ok, Trolls, give me more lies. I WANT MORE LIES!!
    2008 Sep 13 03:13 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Sirius needs to tap into its dedicated fans and shareholders who want this company go long and be successful. Lets please et this message to Mel and the decision makers at Sirius to tap into this fan bas to handle the $300 mil debt that needs to be refinanced in Feb 2009. I have about 6000 shares and I would be glad to invest in a bond for a very long term payback or even make a small donation toward the debt. Our shares could go back to $3 quickly if this debt can be knocked off Sirius back quickly. With all the loyal fans and shareholders who loyally follow this stock and cheer it on, it shouldn't be hard to round up $300 mil in a long bond or donations that would preserve our investment. Please if anyone has connections please get this idea to them, its a risk I know due to the image it would send but a risk we need to take. Sirius will be a long term winner I'm confident!
    2008 Sep 13 09:18 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    It wont come to that. You already donated when it dropped from 2.75 to .80 cents. Those that sold donated. Thats how it works when your working in conjunction with your investors. They want lower buy ins to average down dumb buys of over 4 dollars or more, etc....
    2008 Sep 14 01:57 AM | Link | Reply