Demand for Gas: You Can't Have It Both Ways 19 comments
-
Font Size:
-
Print
- TweetThis
Do a Google news search for "gas stations" and "running out of gas" and you'll find more than 400 news reports like this one:
NASHVILLE, Tenn.- Hurricane Ike's presence near refineries in the Gulf of Mexico, drove many drivers in the midstate rushing out to get gas and leaving many gas stations tapped out.
Along Stewart's Ferry Pike gas seekers saw one of three things at gas stations: long lines, gas pumps covered, or no gas at the station at all. Some of those gas stations with no gas have been placed on a waiting list by distributors because of the high demand.
Do a Google news search for "price gouging" and you'll find more than 2,000 stories like this one, also from Tennessee:
The state of Tennessee has seen a significant spike in the number of calls reporting price gouging over the past 24 hours. Tennessee state law prohibits businesses from unreasonably raising prices on essential goods, commodities, or services in direct response to a natural disaster, whether the natural disaster happened in Tennessee or not.
Observation #1: Demand for gasoline has gone up due to panic buying by consumers "rushing out to get gas" at the same time as gasoline supplies are falling, or expected to fall. It's simple economics that when demand for a product rises at the same time that the supply of that product falls, prices naturally rise to reflect the change in market conditions. Market prices always transmit accurate information about "relative scarcity," and act as a truthful "scarcity-meter." Since gasoline has become relatively more scarce in the last few days, the price naturally rises.
Observation #2: There's the joke about the son who says to his father, "Dad, I want to grow up, and be a musician." The father says "Well son, you're going to have to make a choice, you can't have it both ways."
In the case of gasoline, you can't have it both ways: If you don't want gasoline shortages, and you don't want gas stations running out of gas, you have to let the price rise to ration the scare supply. If you don't allow prices to rise and prohibit "price gouging," you'll have guaranteed shortages and stations running out of gas. But you can NOT have low gas prices and high gas supplies (inventories at stations) at the same time, in the face of rising demand and falling supply.
Observation #3: Buyers complain about high gas prices, but it is largely their fault that gas prices rise, due to panic buying and "rushing out to get gas." Without panic buying, the prices wouldn't have risen as much.
Observation #4: Remember also that gas stations make most of their profits not on gas, but on the other items they sell inside (milk, cigarettes, groceries, etc.). When a station sells out of gas, they lose out on sales of items with the highest profits, so it would be natural for them to raise prices so that they can ration their current supply of gas until the next delivery, which might be days away.
Related Articles
|
Find People on SA
-
The Seeking Alpha 100
See allThe top 100 stock
market authors
selected for publication
Seeking Alpha 100 » -
Fastest Climbers
Authors with the largest
increase in followers
in the last 7 days-
1
David Fry
-
2
Philip Davis
-
3
Tyler Durden
-
4
Bill Gross
-
5
Peter Schiff
Fastest Climbers » -
1
-
Top Commenters
Top commenters,See all
as ranked by their peers
Top Commenters » -
Top Instabloggers
The 100 most activeSee all
Instabloggers.
Top Instabloggers » -
Top StockTalkers
TopSee all
StockTalkers.
Top StockTalkers »
This article has 19 comments:
> jack
I live some 3 thousand miles away from said Hurricane. My gas prices went up. No line ups, nobody closed down. It was gouging pure and simple.
I've missed your incisive and pithy posts here on SA. Good to have you back, Mark.
Milton Friedman won a Nobel prize for his work with prices. His later works taught us laymen to understand the vital importance of pricing in our economy, why capitalism and free markets work best, and how government intervention and high taxes distort our economy. He discredited much of Keynesian economics, and laid the groundwork for what became known as the Reagan revolution. Bless him!
Too many people are ignorant of economics. When prices are high, they call it gouging. When prices are the same, it's collusion. When prices are low, it's predatory pricing.
Don't be silly. Crude oil and gasoline are worldwide markets, not just national or local ones. When oil platforms and refineries go off line, available supplies are curtailed to some extent everywhere. If you don't believe me, just ask the Saudis.
That's also why we need to explore for more oil domestically in the OCS and ANWR. It's too bad Dr. Friedman isn't still around to explain how this works to the Democrats in Congress.
> jack
The alternatives you're suggesting all involve governmental takeover and operation of markets. Be careful what you wish for!
This is the flip side of housing prices escalating at 5% per month. And I don't recall homeowners crying over that. No, they monetized their debt and maxed out their credit cards on new SUV's, boats, jet skis, jacuzzis, cruises and God knows what. So don't tell me you're surprised at the aftermath now when the time has come to pay the tab!
Damn Weather service - never said a word - Oh wait a minute - that's ALL they been saying for a week.
On Sep 15 01:51 PM paulk8756 wrote:
> Big,
>
> This is the flip side of housing prices escalating at 5% per month.
> And I don't recall homeowners crying over that. No, they monetized
> their debt and maxed out their credit cards on new SUV's, boats,
> jet skis, jacuzzis, cruises and God knows what. So don't tell me
> you're surprised at the aftermath now when the time has come to pay
> the tab!