Seeking Alpha
About this author:

In a Wall Street Journal Interview, Mel Karmazin states that he would love to take the company private. The title of the article alone, indicating that Sirius XM (SIRI) is sending signals, suggests that Mel is seeking bids on the company.

“…Given Sirius XM’s low stock price, Mr. Karmazin said he would love to take the company private. But given the state of the credit markets, “How do you find [the money] today?” If the company were generating positive cash flow, which he expects it to do for the full year in 2009, privatization would become much more feasible, he says…”

There may be several positives to this article. To begin with, a company like Microsoft (MSFT), Apple (AAPL) or Google (GOOG) which has the cash to make an offer right now might be more quick to act as they would have no idea if the opportunity would pass them by in the way of a private offering. Mel has opened the negotiating door to any and all private equity firms.

My feeling is that no matter whether the company is taken private, or taken over, shareholders can expect a minimum bid of 4.00 per share. I base that number on the fact that Mel himself is averaged in the high 3.00 range. To make himself whole, he would seek at least that number.

With the stock trading below a dollar, that would be a 400% premium over the current price. That in itself should be an attractive proposition to Wall Street, and a recovery of the stock price may begin on this news.

Disclosure: Long SIRI.

Print this article with comments

This article has 32 comments:

  •  
    One would think, so down the stock goes today, lol lol. Please no more good news, this stock cant handle it. Kidding. Of course 10000 shares this morning determined the new range for today, .88 cents. Nice of the market to trust that first inital 10000 share sell off today, and go with that. Anyone still dont want to scream manipulation? Go ahead, its ok. Mel's got your back.
    2008 Sep 15 08:40 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Would this mean we would receive check for the # of shares X the buy out price, or equal amount of shares of the purchasing company or a choice. Never been through this.... TIA
    2008 Sep 15 08:43 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Is it true if you are a current SiriusXM stockholder would you keep your shares if the company goes private or is bought out?
    2008 Sep 15 08:44 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Lets try that with Citibank tomorrow. Lets buy the first 10000 shares and drive it down 10 percent. See if it holds. LOL LOL LOL. The market accepts every stock price at every moment in time. Apparently.
    2008 Sep 15 08:45 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    O. if someone wants to watch how a computer program runs to keep a stock down, watch Merril Lynch right now, its hilarious. They managed to keep a 25 dollar value comparison with Citi stock at 21 right now. Funny to watch. What Sirius is up against.
    2008 Sep 15 08:46 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I meant Bank Of America. $29 stock value as of Fridays close.
    2008 Sep 15 08:47 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Will someone pay $12 billion for XM/Sirius though?
    2008 Sep 15 09:23 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Clear Channel just might.
    2008 Sep 15 09:35 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I am humbled by both the narrow win for the Dawgs over the Gamecocks this weekend as well as by Relmor's insight. I will be more of a reader/listener than poster at this time. I would like to commend the letter to Mel article though. I do think that to get the premium bid, there needs to be some innovation in the works.
    2008 Sep 15 10:07 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Sirius XM is now on the verge of making money. I have read that Mel K. looks out for the stock holders, that is the way he runs companies. Well, in the short-term $4.00 per share would be nice, but what about the long-term gains? Now that some of us have been around for the many many ups and downs of satellite radio, mostly down, so now we just sell out to someone so that they (and Mel K., because I would assume he would still be part of Sirius) would benefit over the long-term. I think that whether people accept an offer, even if it comes, they should think hard about why a company would swoop in and pay for this company. I say it is because they would gain a lot more than the present holders of the stock.
    2008 Sep 15 10:09 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Seems like we have a back up money maker. I need some advise. I know that you need to look to the future when assessing a stock, but can the chart history be followed on this stock this year. This stock for the past five years has received a Christmas pop from Sept - Nov/Dec time frame. Thoughts?
    2008 Sep 15 10:31 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Clear Channel wont have to pay that much, you dippy does are forgetting that 3 billion shares are not all legitamite. They "printed" 250 million of them to give to GS.
    2008 Sep 15 10:33 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    And add that to the 250 million longs they opened, which I think were also "printed".
    2008 Sep 15 10:34 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Oh Jessica Reif Cohen we hardly knew yee . . .

    but I hear Wienkes is looking for a good administrative assistant. Hey, don't knock it Jessie; it's a great ground-floor opportunity to learn from a master how to set proper price targets!

    Email your resume over to Dr. Mark Wienkes, C/O Goldman Sachs . . . he'll get back to ya . . . .
    2008 Sep 15 10:36 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    There, right now, 7:35 am Mountain time. Arca has 45000 shares available to purchase, against 6000 bids. Ask is 45000 and the bid offers 6000. Those 45000 shares(whoever that is is the manipulator.) Those shares will reappear everytime it hits .91 cents. That imbalance is unheard of. If it were true, stock should hit .75 cents in about 30 seconds.
    Bid support is in the 10000 thousand range.
    OOO, they got pissed, They brought in the ARCA 30k and now the CINN 30 k to back it up. Those are the manipulated shares. Not 100 percent of them, but those are the trading windows being used to manipulate this stock. They will drop or increase to match volume.
    2008 Sep 15 10:37 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Signs they are desperate. They will do the 100 share trick(this throws a bunch of 100 share buys at you, on the down tick only, to show a bunch of red and flow to the downside. No one is buying 100 shares at a time, 10-50 times in a row, at this price thats the matching cost to buy them, lol lol lol lol lol.
    Another trick is the sell at 1, .99. .98, .97 real quick, overriding previous bid points quickly to throw market orders lower. This works very well, been using that trick to keep LEH at 20 dollars till it tanked in 5 seconds. See, they show you LEH at above 12 dollars for months, we all knew it was doomed, but they will only give the shorting window at about 5 seconds. Another nice trick. Look for these.
    2008 Sep 15 10:43 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    No manipulation in the markets. They already oked one of the largest mergers in histoy in the financial sector. They took 1 and a half years to merge two struggling media companies, that dont affect rate mortgage rates one bit.
    2008 Sep 15 11:05 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Relmor, you are the man. In your opinion, when do you think they'll quit keeping the stock down and start pushing it the other way? Do you think we'll have to wait until February?

    2008 Sep 15 11:09 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Mel has to cut the operating costs. The two companies are still spending money like a drunken sailor. This has *always* been their problem more than cash flow. Their cost of operations is WAY too high at the moment.
    2008 Sep 15 11:16 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The shorts will continue until they can no longer justify the price. Right now, thanks to Tyler and Gino, but Brandon is coming around, they will be at if for a while longer. If the pro Sirius people cant see it, complain about it, and demand action, then what hope does the rest of the investment community have. Since Sirius is working in cohoots with the banks, I would think it would be a group decision. News Sirius has that could send it up will be released as they release the short. When they have enough of your shares it will go up, and not till then.
    Best case senario: Any day
    Most probably senario:Before Q1 of 2009.
    Worst case senario: Before Q1 of 2010.
    2008 Sep 15 11:22 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    $4.0 per share - Brendon must be dreaming. Anything above $2 would be a very good offer. Sirius is still eating cash, and to get it to profitability and then some, will take some doing. They dont have a plan yet for what to do with the excess satellites they have orbiting up above. They have some serious amount of debt coming due next year, close to $1Billion. So even at $2 per share, someone would need to cough up over $4B to take the company private, a loss making one at that. Seems like a long shot to me.
    2008 Sep 15 11:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I will remind everyone once again, 500 million of those shares do no exist.
    When calculating what the cost to buy the company is, remove those shares. After bond debt would be paid, those shares would be returned, and the other half bought and then returned. Upon which they would be destroyed and disappear as fast as they were made.
    2008 Sep 15 11:33 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    relmor- thanks for your insight ....you are a cynical codger , and I think you are right !!!!!!! There is NO DOUBT in my mind that Wall Street is the mother of all scams , and manipulation is the norm .....I just don't have the financial savvy to prove it .....I just go on gut feelings ( risky , I know ) ........The only thing that scares me is that I know the scam of all scams , is to pull the rug out from common shareholders when things get sticky ........I am in deep @3.90 a share , and right now , break-even looks good to me , but after years of waiting , I would sure like to make a few bucks ........I feel things can get better , as long as the economy in general doesn't tank further ( a very real possibility ) ......and frankly , I am tempted to buy another 1000 or so @ 95 cents ................just wish THIS was my starting point !!!!!!!! @95 cents it's worth a 10,000 share risk ......but I am all out of cash now , can only buy 1000 or so .......This is either the end of the line , or the mother of all opportunities .....in 10 years this thing could be worth 75 bucks a share
    2008 Sep 15 12:09 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    There are 3 ways to invest on upticks.
    1. Speculation companies(People usually put aside fun money for these stocks(Sirius, etc..)
    2. Growth companies.(A little more)
    3 Proven winners, value.( Most of your money)
    If you already spent your spec money, sink not one more dollar into, at any price. Their are no guarantees, and their is potential for stockholder screwing here, but as Ive been saying if that were true, they would have allowed the post merger jump, let it run up, fill us full of hot air(main stream media would have been very positive post merger) and it would be at like 5-10 dollars right now, minimum. Then they would announce bankrupcy. How the game usually works. They would drive up the price so they could get out of their shares, but there going lower to buy in. Seems safe to me, based on those facts I would assume refinancing was already been approved.
    2008 Sep 15 02:28 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    whats with that quote in the beginning of this article???you dont quote and refer to someone in the past tense. show me the real quote of what he said -alpha!!
    this is a bunch of krapola!
    alpha omega your pulling my satellite leg somebaody call Branson
    wheres the beef!
    (that 46 y/0 shure guy needs some xanax)
    maybe goldman "sacks "will buy it or manybe neimans od macys or "sacs" fifth avenue.......now thers a quote .. dream on
    maybe its all the work of the geiko!
    2008 Sep 15 02:33 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    relmor, are there any books, articles, etc. that you would recommend to help better understand your opinions.
    2008 Sep 15 03:07 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Hmmm. With all this talk about someone manipulating the stock of SIRI...maybe it's Mel who is doing the manipulating. He sure would like to buy you out for 85 cents/share.
    2008 Sep 15 09:28 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    "starting to make money" "read to make money" "soon to make money", How can you predict when you'll make money if you don't know what the cost of your financing will be?
    2008 Sep 15 11:05 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I have no clue what books to read. I wouldnt read anythign on the best sellers lists, probably give back information. You dont need to read any books. You just have to understand that obvious directions in markets would make only the first few in money, etc... etc... The investment banks and the banks, and the hedge funds, etc.. try to move markets and perception. They would rather not worry about facts, and real markets, they will get there eventually, in the mean time they will make money jerking it up and down. Lehman Brothers is a great example of this. Read press statements from the company for the last 3 months, analysist opinions, articles in major publications...etc.. They use lies and bogus sentiment to drive the stock up over 20 dollars to get out, and sell you the shares. Then in ONE day it drops 50 percent. No warning, just gone. Poof. They knew it, you didn't.
    What is wall streets purpose? To make wall street money. Period. If you happen to make a bit, great, good for you, and if you do you probably will lose it all to inflation anyway later. You get money after its been "used". Banks get ultra low rates, while you get the shaft.
    Whoever gets the money first, makes the most on it. Common logic. You have to pay back the FED with interest on all money received from bank loans, etc... Its priced into the money.
    2008 Sep 16 01:02 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Basically, right now, for just the right to print money for our circulation, you have to pay back 2 percent to the FED, a privately owned institution who illegally orchestrated the greatest crime in history. The creation of the central bank system. Its design is to enslave people with high interest loans, gadgets, and bs they dont need, cant afford, and will never pay off. From houses, to cars, to diamond rings, the slaves will always be in debt to the elite.
    2008 Sep 16 01:05 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Regardless of my stake on SIRI XM stock (obviously I own some) I present to you this QUESTION.....did Mel make enough money in his "captain orders" in that his decision to buy the many recent shares of SIRI XM (post merger) were suppose to be portrayed as a vote of confidence on his part to the street e.g. 'public at large' so they (the street) would potentially buy more SIRI XM shares with the “””future””” in mind......did you buy more?....OR...were his – MEL’s - recent post merger purchases of shares MADE to appease his OWN conscience – in other words, he – MEL – would take a “loss” post merger so that he could go down on record as taking losses (yes, he did buy shares before the merger BUT how much money has MEL made overall since his inception into SIRI XM?.....MUCHO $$$$$???????? – who knows)

    You give me – or MEL (or anyone) - the option to grab ($$$) and dash….does one take it? How much money is enough…a little bit more (regardless of the ‘sucker’ that is affected by the decisions.) Kidding…or am I? Is this what happened – cash and dash?

    No one knows who MEL is in “bed” with – even if he is sawing logs! The common share holder has purchased enough common shares because they are “buying a popular product” that they believe in AND USE – just like MEL buys talent and sells common shares to make up debt…..

    This is the potential bottom line in question for the common share holder….
    (Q) Do the upper crust in the SIRI chain of command give a FECES about the common share holders that have purchased SIRI XM shares because the technology ROCKS?
    (A) Yes they (SIRI XM upper crust) do…why…..because billions of dollars that have been invested mean CRAZY profits for the privileged (MEL and company)….not the common share person due to the decision that have been made!!!!

    This is a better question….does SIRI XM chain of command give a FECES about the investor that has invested into SIRI XM?

    If yes…….PROVE IT!!

    We could ask - Who makes decisions for SIRI XM? – MEL? Regardless of the shareholders that STILL exist at the expense of decisions made by MEL and the powers that be….where does the common shareholder find confidence in for the future?

    This means that those who have invested monetary amounts into what they believe would become the “NEXT BIG THING” are currently left empty with zero return because the “POWERS that be” (MEL and company) have made necessary decisions in which the current shareholders will be the seed bearers of tomorrow’s profiteers - which means the current shareholders will take it in the exit strategy.
    2008 Sep 16 01:52 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    scivolando....
    You make EXCELLENT points. I have made these points myself. I have gone with the yes, on the is he in bed with the banks, etc...
    Does upper management care about the stockholders? That is a good question, because of to this point, the answer is no, he does not.
    He talked down guidance, spoke dumb comments, launching aneedless satellite in the midst of coming debt refinancing, and is tight lipped on future strategies other than turning on old receivers and the new best of package, which might make more than you think.
    Maybe he doesnt know yet, if he will have to use us again, but let me tell you this.
    Tanking the stock, in a way, proves he wont be using us again. If he needed us, and the banks needed us, etc... then they would be pumping and dumping, not dumping and pumping. I believe, and have always thought that it was a transfer of wealth strategy, bullied on him by his large stockholders so they can average down, get new cheap shares, and allow the merger to be paid for by mostly XM stockholders, and anyone who sold stock to this point. The giving of shares so the shorts could continue might have been a desperate act, but it also took away the big jump, and gave Mel want he wanted for his investors(new ones) and handled what GS wanted at the present. GS might want the price to stay low, so they can reconverte the bonds for much lower, like .50 cents, and have a higher interest rate sighting weak consumer and investor confidence in the product(look how cheap your stock is trading at). But it is all very complicated what might be going on behind the scenes, and we will be witnesses and not active participants. We must just gather facts and insert them into the best reasoning/interpertati... of facts. We have some facts. Focus on what we know, and you might be less confused about what they intentions of the stockholders future might be. This is not a light decision, and should be thought over very carefully. You must weight current risk(forget what you have already lost in paper value, its gone, and consider it gone) vs. future reward. At .84 cents, what is the potential to drive is further down from here, vs. the potential for gains on the upside. When you have weighed all the evidence and facts, you might have your answer. Facts.
    1. 1st time refinancing came due, they used the stockholder value as leverage, but in using the value as leverage, gave the value a vote of confidence as well. This fact may work to both arguments. I say yes he used stockholder value, but it was mostly XM's, they got shafted ROYALLY. They have much more to complain about. They got no spread, and cheap stock that tanked right after they were forced to receive it.
    2. Needless satellite going up in 09. Why put up a satellite if your going bankrupt. Wow i just figured out this is too long. If you read old posts, you will find my views too. But study the facts for yourself. Look at their books. Talk to users of the product. Go to retail stores and see whats going on, talk to employees. Talk to a car dealer and see what he says about it, etc... Call Sirius and file a complaint. File a complaint with the FCC. File a complaint with the SEC, sighting obvious stock manipulation. Start a petition to remove the board, if you dont like them. So much float out their, it would work if properly funded.
    2008 Sep 17 02:01 AM | Link | Reply