Swiss And German Economic Indicators, October 2012

Oct.28.12 | About: CurrencyShares Swiss (FXF)

Euro Crisis Has Affected Germany, Switzerland Still Immune

Both Swiss and German economic indicators show continued signs of stability, but the German situation has become worse and might affect the Swiss.

Especially low unemployment, rising real wages, and strong trade balances are signs of robustness.

Despite that, Germany's industrial production is weaker than last year; the strong growth of 2011 has finished. Switzerland sees higher increases in real wages. Thanks to higher incomes and lower prices, Swiss retail sales rose by 5.9% on a yearly basis, but fell by 0.8% in Germany. Construction is now slowing in both Switzerland and Germany.

The Swiss "KOF leading indicators" have risen from 0.01 in Q4/2011 to 1.67 now, but are situated still under the value of 2.23 from June last year. The leading German indicator, the "IFO business expectations" stands at 93.2 and is clearly behind last year's June value of 106.3 and smaller than the October 2011 value of 97.0.

Possibly thanks to lower inflation and higher wages, the German GfK consumer climate is ticking higher than last year; maybe finally time for retail sales to edge up.

Purchasing manager indices (PMI) for the manufacturing industry in both Germany and Switzerland are far lower than in 2011, as the Southern European and Chinese demand for cars, machines and equipment has fallen. The latest Swiss industrial production (month of June) was up 8.9% against the previous year and contradicted the negative sentiment of the PMIs. Germany's industrial production, however, contracted by -1.3% YoY.

Some other divergences exist: The KOF leading indicators and the UBS consumption index are expanding, but the official SECO consumer climate is contracting.

After the franc had strongly revalued, the Swiss National Bank (SNB) stopped a deflationary environment in September 2011. This month, the Producer Price Index (PPI) has broken into inflationary territory with a rise of 0.3% on a yearly basis. Higher production costs were probably one reason for Swiss exporters to hike prices. We explained why the franc is now fairly valued on the basis of purchasing power parity. Higher export prices fit into this picture. The strong franc and higher prices do not represent an issue for their customers, because the Swiss trade balance is still strongly positive.

The consumer price index (NYSEARCA:CPI) is lagging, because transfer prices for imported goods adjust only gradually and multinational firms try to keep higher profits in Switzerland in order to pay lower taxes. Imported clothes and shoes were still expensive in 2011 despite the stronger franc. The importers were taking profit via the strong purchasing power of the Swiss consumer. Finally, clothes prices fell by nearly 6% this year; this was the main component that prevented higher CPI inflation.

Click to enlargeSwiss and German Economic Data Oct 2012

Sources: Most data on ForexPros, individual data on KOF, Swiss Statistics, SECO

New data source for industrial production, replaced Forexpros data: Switzerland, Germany (German Forexpros data contained both industrial production and construction, is therefore misleading).

New data source for construction, replaced Forexpros data: Switzerland, Germany

Wages: Economist, Swiss Statistics, real wages computed via CPI

Germany: ForexPros, Retail sales: Destatis, Labor costs: Destatis

Crawling peg on EUR/CHF from spring 2013?

Provided that no global depression takes place in 2013, it is quite probable that the SNB will move to a crawling peg in spring 2013. The month of May is the typical moment when strong inflows into the franc happen (see seasonal effects in detail). By then the PPI might have risen over 1%: quite a big figure for Switzerland. With the crawling peg, the central bank might lower the minimum rate for the EUR/CHF to 1.15 for 2013, and promise another decrease to 1.10 in 2014. A stronger franc will help the central bank to tame prices of imported goods, which make up 27% of the Swiss CPI.

Many like Jim Rogers or Marc Faber are expecting a global depression. In this case, the SNB will continue to enforce the peg with the risk that the central bank's later losses are even bigger.

Investment recommendation

In our latest recommendation on October 17, we suggested that long-term investors should reduce their gold share in favor of Swiss bonds. Both represent a good hedge for bad times. In the meantime gold has fallen from 1750 to 1710, but the franc appreciated a bit. We think that a quick end of the euro crisis can be excluded (we will offer reasons in a forthcoming article) and recommend long-term investors hold Swiss francs in form of ETFs (NYSEARCA:FXF) or Swiss government bonds with maturities over 20 years (e.g., CH0127181169, CH0127181193).

See more in-depth analyses by George Dorgan on Seeking Alpha:

Is the Swiss Franc Overvalued? Purchasing Power Parity.

Can the SNB makes profits on currency reserves ? (we think that the SNB will need to be bailed by tax payers once Swiss inflation picks up again).

Is Standard and Poor's a Rating or a Rumor Agency ? (part 2 of the S&P critique).

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.