Good day, everyone and welcome to today’s program. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later, you will have the opportunity to ask questions during the Q&A session. (Operator Instructions)
It is now my pleasure to turn the program over to Cindy McCann.
Good afternoon and thank you for joining us. On today's call are John Mackey and Walter Robb, Co-Chief Executive Officers, A.C. Gallo, President, Glenda Flanagan, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Jim Sud, Executive Vice President of Growth and Development and David Lannon and Ken Meyer, Executive Vice Presidents of Operations.
As a reminder, all forward-looking statements on this call are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from the expectations and assumptions discussed today. This may be due to a variety of factors, including the risks outlined in our company's most recently filed Form 10-Q and 10-K. Please note, our press release and scripted remarks are available on our website. We assume you have read our press release, so we will use this time to focus on highlights from the quarter and year as well as out future outlook.
Please note fiscal year 2012 was 53-weeks, with the extra week falling in Q4, making it a 13-week quarter. I will now turn the call over to John Mackey.
Thank you, Cindy. Good afternoon, everyone. I would like to begin by expressing sympathy for the many people including our team members, customers, suppliers and investors impacted by Hurricane Sandy. On behalf of our leadership team, I would also like to thank our team members for their exceptional efforts in the wake of the storm. We are proud to have been among the last to close and the first to re-open up doors in so many communities impacted by this powerful and destructive storm.
Turning now to our financial results. Our Q4 performance reflected another quarter of strong sales momentum and earnings growth. On a 12-week to 12-week basis, we produced 33% earnings per share growth on 14% sales growth. We delivered significant year-over-year improvement and record Q4 results including a 76 basis point increase in gross margin to 35.3%, a 40 basis point decrease in direct store expenses to 25.5% of sales, a 117 basis point improvement in store contribution to 9.8% of sales, a 105 basis point increase in operating margin to 6%, marking our third consecutive quarter of over 100 basis points of improvement, 79 basis point improvement of EBITDA margin to 8.7% and 157 basis point improvement in return on invested capital to 12.7%.
Our comparable store sales increased 8.5%, and our identical store sales increased 8.3%. Given the continued moderation and inflation and sluggish economic data points, we were very pleased to produce an acceleration in our two and three year stacked idents. Our three year stacked ident increased 25.4% reflecting three years of 8% plus increases.
In line with the trends we have seen all year, transaction count increased seven percent, with broad-based sales momentum across regions, departments, and store age classes. Year over year, our customers continued to shift their purchases toward organic products and discretionary categories. We also continued to see meaningful increases in $50 plus sized baskets.
Our robust sales and focused operating disciplines along with moderating inflation helped generate another quarter of healthy margin performance. Our 54 basis point increase in gross margin, ex-LIFO, was driven by improvements in both occupancy costs and cost of goods sold.
Sequentially from Q3, we saw an approximate 70 basis point decrease in total gross margin. This decrease is in line with our three-year average sequential drop and is due primarily to seasonality, as well as some impact from our price investment strategy to improve our relative value positioning.
The success of this ongoing strategy is reflected in our continued sales momentum and the results from our most recent competitive survey. The survey indicates we meaningfully improved our pricing position versus our competitors during the quarter, resulting in our most competitive position in more than three years.
An important element to our value strategy is to continue to expand our private label offering. We are very excited about our recent launch of 70 new 365 and Whole Foods Market exclusive brand frozen items. These high-quality dishes are at a value price point and cover key categories such as skillet meals, pizzas, appetizers, desserts and ice creams. The products just started hitting our stores in late September and initial sales results are very positive.
During the quarter, we opened seven stores in West Des Moines, Iowa, Basalt, Colorado, New York City, Charlotte, North Carolina, San Francisco, San Antonio, and Newport Beach, California. West Des Moines, Basalt and Charlotte are all new markets for us.
These seven stores vary in size from 27,000 to 51,000 square feet and encompass trade areas with a broad range in the percentage of college grads, population density and median household income levels. We believe the diversity of these locations speaks to the breadth and variety of market opportunities available to us in new and existing markets as well as both urban and suburban locations.
We continue to be very pleased with the performance of our new stores. For the last six quarters, on average, our new store class has consisted of 22 stores open for approximately six months. At 38,000 square feet in size, they have produced average weekly sales of $564,000 translating to sales per square foot of $780, and have generated a contribution margin of approximately six percent.
Our outstanding results in new stores combined with lower average capital investment and pre-opening expenses per store are driving strong returns. For the quarter, our 19 comparable stores less than two years old produced a return on invested capital of 16%, the strongest Q4 result we have produced in eight years. Check out the Beyond the Numbers section of our Investor Relations webpage for additional information about our new stores, expanded private label offering and more.
Since our third quarter earnings release, we have signed 11 new leases averaging 37,500 square feet in size in Altamonte Springs, Clearwater, Florida, Hyannis, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Morristown, New Jersey, two stores in New York City, Philadelphia and South Hills, Pennsylvania, Dallas, and Seattle. We are pleased to have finally secured a location on the Upper East Side of New York City and to be expanding into Harlem as well.
We have signed 45 new leases over the last 12 months and expect to open a record 32 to 34 new stores this fiscal year. This includes the recently announced acquisition of six leases from Johnnie’s Foodmaster, which is scheduled to close on November 30. The leases for stores averaging 31,000 square feet in size include South Weymouth, Arlington, Charlestown, Brookline, Melrose and Somerville, Massachusetts and will expand our presence in the Greater Boston area to 26 stores.
In summary, fiscal 2012 was a record-breaking year on so many levels. Our sales approached $12 billion, translating to sales per gross square foot of $950. We reported three consecutive quarters of three-year identical store sales growth of over 24%. We improved operating margin 94 basis points to 6.4 percent, generated over $1 billion in EBITDA, and substantially exceeded our initial 53-week EPS guidance of $2.21 to $2.26, by actually growing EPS 31% year over year to $2.52.
We opened 25 new stores, increasing our ending square footage 7.6% to over 12.7 million, and we created over 8,500 new jobs. We narrowed the pricing gap versus our competitors on known value items to its narrowest margin yet, while continuing to raise the bar on our standards by eliminating all red-rated species in our seafood departments last March.
Our solid performance, capital discipline and increasing stock price generated $1.3 billion of cash during the year through a combination of $920 million in cash flow from operations and $370 million in proceeds from team member stock option exercises. We invested $456 million in new and existing stores, returned $95 million in quarterly dividends to our shareholders and repurchased $29 million of common stock. For the year, our total cash and investments increased $745 million to $1.5 billion.
We are well positioned to internally fund our accelerated new store growth while maintaining a healthy cash balance and today announced a 43% increase on our quarterly dividend to $0.20 per share. In addition, we plan to create additional value for our shareholders through selective utilization of our remaining $170 million in stock repurchase authority.
Turning to fiscal year 2013, for the first five weeks of Q1, we reported comparable stores sales of 7.3%. During this short period, we were impacted by last year’s Living Social deal and had 91 stores and four facilities in four regions impacted by Hurricane Sandy. While most stores and facilities were only closed temporarily, many stores in the northeast region were closed for several days, with several New York City stores just becoming fully operational last Friday.
Given many customers were without power and thus their shopping patterns were disrupted we have not yet seen a full return to normal in these regions. Our comps company-wide for the past two days were over 11 percent, with the Northeast region comping over 20 percent, clearly indicating customers are continuing to restock.
We are maintaining our guidance for fiscal year 2013 and expect another year of healthy comparable store sales growth, continued operating margin improvement, and record new store openings. Our guidance includes the Johnnie’s lease acquisitions but does not include a charge related to Hurricane Sandy that we expect we will take in the first quarter once our estimated uninsured losses are determined.
We have opened 13 stores since our last earnings release. We currently have 79 stores in development totaling 2.9 million square feet and representing about 22% of our operating store base. Our new stores are performing extremely well. With our pipeline and infrastructure in place, ending square footage growth is expected to continue to accelerate through 2014. We are well-positioned to internally fund our growth and believe we will continue to gain market share through further differentiating our shopping experience, improving our relative value proposition, and reinforcing our standing as America's healthiest grocery store.
We will now take questions. Please limit yourself to one question at a time so that everyone has an opportunity to participate. Our call will end at 4:30 Central time. Thank you.
(Operator Instructions) We will take our first question from the site of Edward Kelly of Credit Suisse. Your line is open.
Edward Kelly - Credit Suisse
I was hoping that you could maybe give us some, I know it's difficult, but there has been a lot of moving parts over the last quarter with July 4 shift and then current quarter with Sandy. If you could give us some sense as to how you really think the underlying trend in the comp is progressing and, I guess, why is it so hard to, maybe, us an impact on your year-to-date number? So if you could give us some color on that that would be great.
It is messy because we had the Living Social deal last year and now we have Hurricane Sandy this year. If it were a few more weeks down the road, then we could see what the post-storm normal looks like and that would help us to quantify the impact of Sandy for the two-weeks and now continuing that it is there. So, we do think that the guidance for the year is still a good guidance and we are comfortable with that and we feel like that that’s the best information we can give you along with just the facts of what the comps are so far this week. We are helping you to see that we are not through the impact yet.
Yes. Plus, New York is getting hit again today. So it is hard to quantify. I know you want that information. We would like to have it too but we don’t have it. I will just say that if you look at our track record, historically, our comps, 7%, 8%, 8.5%, that’s been our trend line not just this year or last year but pretty much for 30 years. So I would think our guidance is good and for now, we will stick with that.
Edward Kelly - Credit Suisse
Okay and just one follow-up question for you. Your older stores have been comping very well. Surprisingly strong, I guess, given that the stores are obviously busy, parking lots are full, that incremental traffic probably meets more friction there. How do you think about capacity at your older class of stores and your ability to sustain the current level of comp and what do you do to enable that to happen?
Good question. This is David Lannon. Our old stores, we are in the constant process of renovating, updating and with all our account in our stores. So you look at small stores, as examples where we assume they are going to cap out but they don’t. The basket size continues to increase as the stores mature. Our teams continue to renovate and keep them exciting. So I think if you go into any of our 10-year old stores versus another conventional 10-year old stores, you can see that our stores are in a state of improvement.
I think that’s the secret. We continue to upgrade and improve our stores. So they don’t stand still and if you keep making them fresh and you continue to put new innovations in them, successful ideas and one of the things, hopefully, it is very good at is collaboration. So when we do successful renovations in one store or one region, it tends to spread around the company pretty rapidly.
A good example. We have an older store in Northern California in Campbell in San Jose and they just put in a nail salon, organic nail salon. First one ever. Kind of an expansion of a category that holds foods into and its essentially sold out everyday since we did it. So those are the kind of things that stores are innovating with.
This is Walter here. But I think you are asking about capacity. We just don’t really see that very often where there is a store because our real estate team is so active right now and because we are so early on in our potential for the United States of 1,000 stares that they just become the next step is to go find an additional store in that market. You have seen us do that, time and time again, quarter after quarter where we go find and expand our market presence. If we started to approach that situation, the store is very successful, we are able to go out there and find an additional store in that particular market.
Or relocate it to a bigger.
We are constrained by that if anything.
I mean the truth is that we have some stores that, smaller older stores that you would think they are reached their capacity. Just couldn’t get any more volume out of them but they still manage to do it. The sales per square foot are phenomenal from those stores. Theoretically, there has got to be some limit. Only, we have really never seen that. So it's only theoretical, not in reality.
We will move next to the site of Ken Goldman of JPMorgan.
Priscilla Tsai- JPMorgan
Hi, this is actually Priscilla Tsai, in for Ken today. So you mentioned that the survey you conducted indicated that you improved your pricing position and that you are at the narrowest margin yet to competitors and I don’t think you have talked about a specific price gap to competitors before but maybe you can help us quantify or understand a bit more of what you have done with the prices? Then, I might have missed this, but did you give out a traffic and ticket breakdown?
Yes, this is Walter. We did give out the traffic and ticket. It's 7% transaction growth in the quarter which is fairly strong and in addition to that, a little bit of color for you is that our work with Nielsen on our new last routine survey we do quarter-to-quarter says that we made a 22% gain in new customers. That’s our highest gain in new customers in the last three years. So that’s pretty exciting. That’s an 80/20 sort of split and that is continuing.
To your question about the price survey, again, we have talked about this each quarter but we do check well over 600 items which is the core branded item community across all sorts of competitors and we are now looking at that, in terms of market specific and what we mean by meaningful movement is that we moved north of 100 basis points this last quarter relative positioning on those items.
So it's our biggest gain and our closest gap in terms of that pricing across the entire. We are looking at over 80 competitors across the United States. We are looking at them on a 30 day basis and we have been tracking this now for the last two and half, three years.
This was our biggest jump in that parity over that period of time. So that’s the only number. We are not going to give you the actual numbers but that’s the relative gain. I think if you are out there and if you look at some of the other reports that come through over the last three months, I think that improved positioning really reflective and I think we are really making tremendous steps forward on our price competitiveness. We really are, at the same time, working on our quality and our differentiation.
We will move next now to the side of Ed Aaron of RBC Capital Markets.
Edward Aaron - RBC Capital Markets
We have heard some indications recently of some supply tightness in the industry and I was just wondering if you have encountered any challenges thus in terms of your supply chain of late?
A. C. Gallo
Hi, Ed, this is A.C. Not in the packaged goods. We have been fine with that. We have been with organic milk, things like that. The one thing that’s been a little tighter this year is apples in general, organic apples and other apples. There have been a lot of freezes last spring during pollination time in the Midwest and in the Northeast, so that a lot of the local apples are not available this year, and that’s put extra pressure on Washington State.
There has also been extra demand for organic. So we have found that, for apples, in general, are tighter this year. Costs are up. Retail is up a little bit. It is probably the area that we are seeing the biggest issue. In general, for the most part, meat, milk, grocery items have been bought.
I think one thing we are doing is just doing a double check on the forecasting for inventories heading into the holidays. We learn that from a couple a years ago and getting out ahead of that is to make sure that’s not going to be a concern as we anticipate a nice holiday sale this year. Make sure we are in the right stock position for that.
A. C. Gallo
We also have developed a pretty good commodity buying team over the last few years here. So as we saw conditions tightening up with certain brands because of the Midwest drought, especially in areas that we pre-booked for pretty much of supply for this year for all of our bake houses and kitchens and things. So we are in good shape. We are protected on all those costs at reasonable prices. So we are not really seeing any shortages there that some other people maybe seeing.
We will move next to the site of Mark Miller of William Blair.
Mark Miller - William Blair
A long term question here on the competitive environment. Over time we are probably going to see a big expansion in the number of neighborhood markets from Wal-Mart. I was hoping you could share your perspective on how sales and margins change when the neighborhood market enters the trade area and how many markets has this happened for you? Just if you could comment on price sensitivity for your consumer overlapping items that you might need to address and then, I guess pick up of customers from conventionals that are impacted?
So, Mark, are you specifically talking about the neighborhood markets, the Wal-Mart's effort?
Mark Miller - William Blair
Yes, and implicit in my question is, are we going to see a lot more of these over time?
Yes. We have experienced that some, over the last year and a half, couple of years. There is not a significant overlap, in terms of mix or in terms of impact, on us. So, different than other competitors, it's a little less of an overlap. Is your question kind of how do we see that unfolding over the next couple of years?
Mark Miller - William Blair
Yes, I was wondering if you had specific market instances that you have looked at? You have obviously grown well with the expansion of Wal-Mart in food over time but I was wondering of your view whether it's a plus or a minus for you?
I guess, we are sitting around the table, we are sitting neutral. Wal-Mart waxes and wanes in terms of our product mix depending on how they are seeing it on any particular day and it's not as much of an overlap with some other competitors. So certainly it will affect the market and the movement of the market based on their entering but our experience thus far has not been particularly meaningful. We do have some individual markets, but I am not prepared to share that specific right now.
It's sometimes hard for people to understand but Whole Foods has this very differentiated customer base. The 20/80 rule, 20% of our customers are about 75% to 80% of our sales and they tend to be very loyal to Whole Foods. They are really what drives our business model and they are not interested in shopping in the own neighborhood for the most part. They really want to shop with us.
Wal-Mart comes into a market like that, they are just taking a little bit from lots of other conventional players, but they are not really impacting us. We tend to get our share no matter who comes into our market place and that's one of our competitive advantages.
Don't hear that as we don't take it seriously. We certainly do, but in the lineup of competitors, I wouldn't put them as meaningful as some of the others.
We will move next to Kate Wendt of Wells Fargo.
Kate Wendt - Wells Fargo
I was just wondering if you could add a little color in terms of what you are seeing from your price investments in terms of basket size and frequency of shopping trends and then if you have any plans to get the message out to consumers in a broader way? Certainly it's a big step to lower prices and then the next step is letting people to know about it. So if you have any plans to increase advertising spend to reinforce your new value proposition?
Hey, Ken, you want to talk on that one?
Well, I think the thing with our market prices that are EDLP, that Walter talked about before, we merchandise them just like we merchandise specials. So we have aggressive promotions. We have one day sales, three day sales, one week sales, one month sales.
We are also super active in social media. So there are daily pings on both our Twitter and Facebook across all stores on all of these items. So there's definitely a consensus building with our customers that Whole Foods has good value and good prices and of course always great quality. So we are seeing our merchants, the folks that are running the stores they know how to merchandise these products and at these great prices we can't be beat.
We have a question from Karen Short of BMO Capital.
Karen Short - BMO Capital
Just curious, has there been any further discussion of some form of loyalty program for customers? I know your stance on promotions through a loyalty card but given what some of the more innovative retailers are doing, have you further evaluated whether not there's a way to introduce some type of program to reward your most loyal customers even if it isn’t cash or price reduction related?
The answer to that, Karen, is we are not going to do the kind of loyalty program that most conventional supermarkets do. We don't think that really rewards our shoppers so much as it punishes those who don't have cards. However, we are looking at this internally and we may do something that ties it together when we launch our version of Wellness Club in the next year or year and half.
So, it's something we are paying attention to and we will probably try to do some kind of integrated strategy with it. Don't think we are going to announce about it today and I don't think you'll see anything for more than 12 months, but it is something we are talking about. You will probably see some movement in that direction sometime within the next couple of years.
You have a question from Charles Grom of Deutsche Bank.
Charles Grom - Deutsche Bank
Just a follow-up on Ed's question and I hate to think so near term but I am just wondering if you guys could quantify maybe for us how your IDs were trending before we started to see the Sandy impact up here in the Northeast? Then just as a follow-up, historically, post other storms that you guys have seen throughout the country, hurricanes or what, do you typically see a large bounce back and so, is the net effect of the storm typically a net positive and net neutral? If you could help us out there, that would be great.
We are really not willing to give any more numbers than we have given already. The pre-storm there were just three weeks and it's hard to tell exactly when the pre-stocking started. So, we are probably not willing to do that and in answer to the second question, I will let the operators join in but, it depends on the severity of the storm.
Often times, it has been neutral because the pre-stocking has offset the impact during the storm itself, but in this case because we actually had such a severe impact and stores were closed for so long and it took so long for so many customers to get power restored and therefore they weren't able to shop for groceries during that time. It is a bigger impact than it would have been most typical storms we have seen over the last few years.
Honestly, it's just not something Whole Foods market cares much about, because we are managing out business for the long-term and we know what our underlying comp trends are and our ident trends are. Hurricanes came, hurricanes go. It might have a temporary short-term effect, but it doesn't change the fundamentals that are driving our business. That’s really what we are focused on.
This is David. I will just give a little color. At Whole Foods market, we really take pride from our experience in New Orleans and Florida. We were first to market back open than many of our competitors. In several occasions in Jersey, Christina Minardi and the New York team, we have stores open in New Jersey, and we were the only game in town, because others stores haven't opened.
So our team always band together. We have a very good process and if you really looked into it across the market in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, often times we were first to market before any of our competitors.
We will move next to Mark Wiltamuth of Morgan Stanley.
Mark Wiltamuth - Morgan Stanley
I wanted to ask about your cash balance. You added $745 million this year. You are up to $1.5 billion in cash and marketable securities. The dividend increase barely dents that number and you are going to see another free cash inflow this year. What's the long term look on what kind of cash balance you really need and from an EVA focus isn't this cash really a drag for you right now?
It’s a great problem to have.
It’s a great problem to have. You pointed out to Johnnie's. We just made an acquisition of leases hold. I mean we have already talked about what we are going to do about our cash but it's worth repeating.
One, we are accelerating our growth. We are opening more stores that we have ever opened before. We signed 45 stores in the last 12 months and we are growing faster. So that's our primary focus, is to accelerate our growth and to transfer some of that cash into stores that will increase value for our stakeholders.
Number two, we just increased our dividend 43% and that's a pretty good annual dividend increase.
Third, we are going to continue to be opportunistic in our stock buybacks.
Fourth, we are going to continue to pile up cash. Part of that is, you are right, it's not the best thing for EVA, but one of our valuable lessons from the great recession that occurred when we were caught with a lack of liquidity at a very bad time, maybe we are preparing for the last war, but seems to me that I am not sure the American economy is out of its problems.
So I am not sure what's going to happen here. We have got lots of money being pumped into the economy by the Fed. We got this so-called fiscal cliff about to hit. We have got tax rates going up. I think Whole Foods wants to keep a lot of powder dry. We are just not sure what's going to happen. So we like the position we are in.
We are accelerating our growth and we are increasing our dividend and we are buying back stock and we are piling up cash. Many years ago people asked us, when are you going to have some free cash flow? When are you going to have some free cash flow?
Now we are hearing, you got too much free cash flow. What are you going to do with all that extra money? So that's what we are going to do with it and we will see how this economy plays out and we may change our strategy but, for now, the strategy is just what I told you.
I just want to pile onto that, John. Just to highlight again the use of the cash to accelerate our growth at a time when many of the folks are flat. We opened seven stores in Q4, 11 more in Q1. When you look at the production of the real estate team, we are deploying more and more capital to open the stores and, we continue to move aggressively on that depending on how opportunities open up. So you may see us increase the spend there as we continue to go forward so successfully with real estate.
Our final question comes from Scott Mushkin of Jefferies and Company. Mr. Mushkin, your line is open. It appears that we have no further questions.
Okay. Thanks for listening in everybody. Please visit Whole Foods Market for everything you need to enjoy great meals over the holidays, and join us in February for our first quarter earnings call. A transcript of the scripted portion of this call along with a recording of the call is available on our website. We will talk to everybody next quarter. Have a great holiday. Bye.
This concludes our conference call for today. You may now disconnect your lines and everyone have a great day.
Copyright policy: All transcripts on this site are the copyright of Seeking Alpha. However, we view them as an important resource for bloggers and journalists, and are excited to contribute to the democratization of financial information on the Internet. (Until now investors have had to pay thousands of dollars in subscription fees for transcripts.) So our reproduction policy is as follows: You may quote up to 400 words of any transcript on the condition that you attribute the transcript to Seeking Alpha and either link to the original transcript or to www.SeekingAlpha.com. All other use is prohibited.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HERE IS A TEXTUAL REPRESENTATION OF THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S CONFERENCE CALL, CONFERENCE PRESENTATION OR OTHER AUDIO PRESENTATION, AND WHILE EFFORTS ARE MADE TO PROVIDE AN ACCURATE TRANSCRIPTION, THERE MAY BE MATERIAL ERRORS, OMISSIONS, OR INACCURACIES IN THE REPORTING OF THE SUBSTANCE OF THE AUDIO PRESENTATIONS. IN NO WAY DOES SEEKING ALPHA ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS MADE BASED UPON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THIS WEB SITE OR IN ANY TRANSCRIPT. USERS ARE ADVISED TO REVIEW THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S AUDIO PRESENTATION ITSELF AND THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S SEC FILINGS BEFORE MAKING ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS.
If you have any additional questions about our online transcripts, please contact us at: email@example.com. Thank you!