Seeking Alpha
Full index of posts »
Posts by Ticker
Latest Comments
-
Bruce Pile on Is VIX 20 Important? I accidentally referred to the savings and loa...
-
Bruce Pile on AWACS Prep In Iran Theater? Taxi (one of my favorite TV shows of all time),...
-
roy piper on AWACS Prep In Iran Theater? I have been worried about the effects of an att...
-
Taxi on AWACS Prep In Iran Theater? Nice job Bruce. I've been asking technical anal...
-
Freddy Hutter, TrendLines Research on The Coming Mystery Of The Missing Barrels Of Oil We agree on your analysis of Regular Convention...
Posts by Themes
agriculture,
alternative energy,
Baltic Dry Index,
bear market,
bear market rally,
commodities,
consumer discretionary,
defense stocks,
dow theory,
Dow Theory,
gold,
gold miners,
head and shoulders,
inflation commodities,
internet networks,
Iran,
Israel,
margin debt,
market bottoms,
market direction,
Middle East,
money supply,
nuclear plants,
oil,
oil price,
options,
peak oil,
railroads,
Recession,
retail,
sugar,
Transportation Index,
VIX,
Warren Buffett
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.










Gold Fractal Update
There is a totally dispassionate way of analyzing gold that doesn't try to figure what bank may be selling or what government may want to buy or what the human psyche is on moving money into it. There is pure technical analysis that does all of that of course, but then there is the new dispassionate way - fractal analysis.
David Nichols is a pioneer in this developing science and has been incredibly accurate in calling the movement of gold. For an overview of fractal analysis, read the July 5 post at my blog Is Gold at a Fractal Moment? where I summarize his call that early July would see a major turn begin out of the consolidation since March '08 and into the next hypergrowth phase. Look at a chart and see if that isn't exactly when the present run began.
There are many things Nichols uses to form a projection, one of them being the fractal dimension. This is a measure of energy level. Fractal theory says that anything fractal moves in repeating patterns with an ebb and flow of energy. An energy dimension can be computed that shows where a move is. The current (as of Oct 28) fractal dimension of gold is:
Here we see the big picture (monthly chart) for gold's fractal dimensioning including the 1 1/2 year consolidation since last March, whose end was called to the week. The 30 and 55 levels for the fractal dimension are important because they indicate when a significant move begins full of energy (55) and when a move is nearing exhaustion (30). The big move up in late '05 through May '06 began with around a 58 as did the big climb starting late in '07. As you can see, our current climb starts at 63 and is only beginning on a monthly basis.
Gold Stocks - The Ultimate Options Strategy
Well, put on your thinking cap and try this on for size. Why not just buy and hold gold stocks? It sounds too simple, but look at what gold stocks have done over a large variety of strong market disturbances - from deflation to inflation, from vicious bear to vicious bull:
With gold either steady (as in the '30s) or rising (as in the '70s and now) gold stocks do well no matter what the market does - up, down, or flat. What complicated options strategy can average much better than that? It's a buy and hold stock strategy where you don't have to make a directional bet on the market, freeing you from a lot a dangerous and usually self defeating week to week trading. The investment jungle rarely offers this good of a deal. You just have to be right on gold being in a bear or bull market.
Since November '07, the start of our latest bear market, gold stocks as measured by the HUI Index are only about even, but that's a big outperformance of the Dow. And if you look at this chart: (click to enlarge)
you see that the systemic failure issues of late '08 were enough of an aberration to pull gold stocks below the trend over gold's current bull market. These credit and other problems are still a threat to gold miners as they are to any company. But if we can avoid the end of the world, a bull or bear market may allow gold stocks to be one of the best hedging policies.
Disclosure: Long BVN, EGO, AUY, AU, ABX, GFI, RIC,NGD, NG, HL, SA, NXG, GG, RGLD, DROOY, GSS, ANV, HMY, GOLD, CGR, XRA, NEM, GRS
Reading Between The Lines On Iran
If you look between the lines of the published comments of European and American foreign ministers and generals, people who know a lot more than they can explicitly say, you can do a little informal intelligence gathering. An article out today on European angst over Iran's usual stalling tactics quotes some of the FM comments as "Iran cannot play and play and play with us" and "dialogue cannot last forever". They seem to have had a vision of a scheduled light at the end of the "talk" tunnel. The French foreign minister said "Iran is wasting time because now is the time for talking. One day it will be too late."
As for more formal intelligence gathering, nobody does it better than STRATFOR. From their latest Iran report out today (Israel, U.S.: Negotiating Iran With Russia)
As for the published lines from the quiet Israelis to read between, well there are very few. But there is the considered view of Middle East experts, as noted in my previous posts over at my blog, that "when the Israelis go really quiet, that's when you have to start worrying" (about a military strike, that is). The empty space being published seems to have a lot to say.
Two Telling Charts
Looking first at this TRANQ: (click to enlarge charts)
Here we see what I regard as a ghastly chart. For one thing, it is down for the year. You could call that a loud Dow Theory non-confirmation of the S&P 500's lofty new high for the year. Another serious technical problem in this chart is the fairly well defined resistance level that was broken just briefly in September only to fade weakly back below it, breaking the 50 dma in the process.
Looking at the Baltic:
The BDI has been tracing out a pretty accurate roadmap for us so far over the last year giving us the forecast 3 months in advance. There's no guarantee it will continue to do this nice favor for us, but it does have a history of foreshadowing our stock market. It put in a top, a consolidation, and then a fairly meaningful decline about 3 months ago. So the two trusty charts, TRANQ and BDI, agree on the next phase of the market. It would appear to be a weak consolidation of several months at best or a smackdown to the economy of the TRANQ at worst.
Disclosures: SH, TWM
Is VIX 20 Important?
The 20 level has served as a ceiling for improving emotions all during this debt-induced mess. In fact, you can look at a VIX chart covering the entire debt balloon era that got under way in the late 80s, and see the significance of this 20 level:
It is a line in the sand dividing the nice, stable bull move years, shown in green, and the nasty, gyrating topping actions and bear move years, shown in red. At the left, we had the '90 recession, then a quick and painless trip back into the green. As the debt balloon grew, we ran into the savings and loan crisis of the late 90s and the dot-com top and bear market and a much bigger sea of red. But we got back to the nice green for a little while. Then, the next debt complication, the housing bust, sends us hurdling back into the red. Now we are back at the dividing line. Are we going to emerge back into the calm green seas or see a spreading sea of red? There is a pattern in the progression of fear as our debt level goes parabolic - the fear spikes go higher and the seas of red grow bigger. Unless we can now break and hold the sub-20 territory and defeat this progressing pattern, we may be at a very dangerous turn point in the stock market.
There is a confluence of projections from very independent means of analysis (fundamental, technical, sentiment, fractal, web bot) that all agree on this impending turn point condition. From technical analysis, we have a rising wedge formation:
This is a strong bearish formation and is the inverse of a falling wedge that can be seen in this year's VIX chart above.
And from Planet Yelnick, an Elliott Wave site, we have:
A return of the credit crisis? Egad! Back into the sea of red we go. Loans are, in fact, hard to get. Farmers can't get loans, which is making things difficult for companies like Deere. This could aggravate food shortages and prices. But this may be the least of our problems if we don't see the bankers starting to help main street more.
The popular bears' argument about the huge debt overhang and dollar problem is well known. But did you know that two of the biggest table thumpers for a glorious new bull climb have recently moved to the edge of the bears' camp on this issue? On CNBC's Mad Money, Jim Cramer was confronted with a viewer's question asking him if the parabolic debt explosion worried him. His instant, impassioned response was yes, it worries him and, unless it is immediately dealt with successfully, it will cause a new bear market within 18 months. And Larry Kudlow has recently started to proclaim that he is a "short term" bull but he sees the dollar debasement changing things out about 3 months. That's probably the two head cheerleaders for team Dow going over to the other side, only disagreeing on when. I don't feel cheered.
Is there any hope? Yes. We can do what Ross Perot tried to explain to the American people back in 1992 in his presidential campaign. If we had reformed our government the way his Reform Party tried to, we would be living in a much different world today. It would have been relatively painless back then at the left end of the VIX chart above. But now it is a scary time indeed.
Disclosures: None
The Market's Current Psychological Map
It is the consumer's sentiment that I want to take a look at: (click to enlarge)
This chart tabulates, not the raw sentiment numbers, but preceding 6 month change in sentiment over the years. As you can see, we are now at a fast 6 month rate of improvement not seen for 15 years. And the only other two times in the past 20 years this was seen were both big turn points in sentiment back down.
An interesting comparison can be seen comparing our current recession to the previous one. The fast run-up to the turn level happens at the end of the recession, as you might expect. But then you had a debt hangover induced stock market and sentiment dive to the mid-to-late 2002 market lows after we had celebrated the end of the recession. We're seeing the same pattern played out with the latest recession, which most are saying ended mid-year. We have ballooned our debt to way higher, more unstable levels since the 2002 episode. If the pattern repeats, we are at a point where we soon have a psychology turn and some kind of debt hangover induced stock market trouble. This could be commercial real estate loans or the second wave of housing, a dollar debacle. It could be a variety of things.
I have been a market bull since April despite many bear signals, some of which I've summarized in my posts while concluding that I favor turns north from consolidations (based mostly on technicals). But now the technicals are starting to suggest a turn back down. Those who follow fibonacci curves point to the typical 50% retracement level that happens after big moves. That comes to 1100-1200 on the S&P 500. The ETF Profit Strategy Newsletter called the start of the rally with a March 2 alert for a move by the Dow to the 9000-10000 area. They are now seeing a big move down. Doug Kass started going long in February a few weeks early and called the tippy top bottom of the crazy gyrations on TV within a week of the event. He has been going short for weeks and is now reportedly at his highest net short position since February. I am going from bull to neutral until we sneak through this twilight zone. We should soon see how it plays out.
If we are to have some debt overhang induced market trouble, our emotional state would suggest it may start soon. The consumer confidence survey level is backing off unexpectedly from over that unstable 70 mark:
If we are considering our emotional state, we may even want to take a morbid glance at what the web bots are sensing. A misconception about bots is that they predict big events on particular dates. But with the markets, the software actually reads feeling changes and, I suppose, puts together some kind of centroid of all it reads for a time approximation. Last year, they certainly did just that very accurately in timing the market's behavior. George Ure and Clif High are the "two guys in a hole in the woods in Oregon" creating what they call "The Web Bot Project". In commenting on the bots' recent dire prediction about October 25 (see my blog post "Web Bot Weirdness") George Ure says this at his site urbansurvival.com
It will be interesting to see how our feelings might change going into November. If the seers who have been calling things to a tee lately are right again, we are all going to get a little cranky. Even Larry Kudlow, the irrepressible CNBC optimist and bull, has lately started sounding more like Peter Schiff, lashing out at those who are debasing the dollar and drowning our prosperity in a sea of debt and federal meddling. Lynch the banksters!
Disclosures: None