David Wolf

Beijing's Hybrid Hypocrisy

Rlirph:

I absolutely agree that any US citizen traveling or living abroad needs to be tactful, thoughtful, and considerate.

I absolutely disagree, however, that this means we have no right to critique policies or practices that run counter to China's best interests. I believe it is my obligation - and that of all of us who love China, live here, invest our sweat-earned dollars here, respect her people, and deeply appreciate what she has accomplished in a very short time - to serve as a "loyal opposition," to point out areas where China can improve its policies if those policies will improve the lives of all Chinese and improve China's standing in the world, this making this a better place for everyone.

We are doubly obliged given that Chinese themselves lack the political mechanisms do do so themselves. Given that foreigners who have spent their lives here, contribute positively to society, speak the language, and understand the culture are regularly consulted on issues like this by Chinese, it is a role we are expected to play.

To do otherwise (under the guise of "good manners"), to see no evil, hear no evil, and keep our mouths shut about the problems we see is to give lie to the idea that our presence here can help improve things. In that case, we all might as well pack up and leave.

To tell China to change "just to be like us" is wrong. You and I agree on that.

But if those of us who know a little something about this place don't say anything when we see something wrong, we condemn China to remaining a third world country. Or worse.

Join the loyal opposition. By doing so you will join a long line of foreigners who have helped China overcome its challenges.