To screen ETFs by asset class, performance, yield and more, check out the
Author Following Options:
Follow this author
See their articles on your Seeking Alpha homepage and in your feed.
Real-time alerts on this author
Get their new articles emailed to you as they are published.
Daily digest on all my authors
Get all your favorite authors’ new articles emailed to you in one daily digest.
View Even Walser's Comments
$800 Billion: Too Much? Too Little? Yes.
Caveat: This is analysis I performed when the stimulus package was roughly $888 billion. The numbers may not be 100% but the multiplier insight and returns should not change.
According to CBO, individual category projections, averaged, the multiplier effect would be between 0.66% and 1.86% for each dollar of the federal stimulus. According to this analysis, the federal stimulus would stimulate economic growth equaling between $561 billion and $1,581 billion. Estimating that the multiplier effect is the average of these two numbers, than the stimulus would promote $1,071 billion of new growth. This represents a 26% return overall and an annualized return from the years of 2009 through 2011 of 9.34%. Based upon these numbers the federal stimulus appears to be a good investment, but is it?
The federal stimulus will add an additional $888 billion dollars to the federal budget. The federal government currently runs a deficit, so in effect; the federal stimulus will add an additional $888 billion to the debt. The federal stimulus is not all appropriated in a single year. As such, the increase in deficit spending will occur over several years. In year 2009, the cost of the federal stimulus, will add $233 billion dollars to the deficit, bringing total deficit spending for 2009 to $1,573 billion dollars. This represents a total deficit of over 10% of GDP. The federal stimulus will add an addition $460 billion to the deficit bring the combined total to $1,303 billion dollars or slightly more than 9% of GDP, in year 2010. Things get better in 2011, but only slightly, as the federal stimulus adds an additional $141 billion in spending, bring the total budget deficit to an estimated $782 billion dollars or 5.3% of GDP. The years 2012 through 2019 see an additional $48.3 billion in federal stimulus related deficit spending. Even with record low interest rates on federal borrowing, the net interest on the $888 billion dollar stimulus is projected to cost $347 billion dollars by 2019. This brings the total real cost of the stimulus of $1,235 billion dollars. Taking my analysis assuming the average multiplier effect, into consideration, the net return on the stimulus is a negative 13.27% or an annualized loss of 1.32% from years 2009 through 2019. Based upon these narrow calculations, it appears that the federal stimulus will have a net negative effect on the long term economic health of the US.
Feb 13, 2009. 08:51 PM
All Comments by Even Walser »
Xignite quote data
© 2014 Seeking Alpha