Seeking Alpha

Michael Dever's  Instablog

Michael Dever
Send Message
Founder, CEO & Director of Research for Brandywine Asset Management and author of "Jackass Investing: Don't do it. Profit from it." I have been a professional investor/trader since 1979 and have experience in stocks, managed futures, commodities, mutual fund arbitrage, market... More
My company:
Brandywine Asset Management
My blog:
Mike Dever
My book:
Jackass Investing: Don't do it. Profit from it.
View Michael Dever's Instablogs on:
  • Performance And Correlation

    Originally published in the Brandywine Asset Management Monthly Report.

    After a solid start in October, Brandywine's Symphony Program sold off to a slight loss at month-end. This performance continues the difficult period for the Program that began last fall. But consistent with the pattern established three months ago, gains and losses have been spread across the portfolio, as our various trading strategies continue to offset each other. This differs from the drawdown period, during which many previously uncorrelated strategies lined up to produce losses.

    One thing that has been consistent throughout the drawdown and recent three months is the non-correlation of Brandywine's returns with those of other investment managers. For example, the correlation of monthly returns of Brandywine's Symphony Program with the BTOP 50 CTA (managed futures) index is a negative -0.04.

    Brandywine is unaware of any other futures manager that has such a low correlation to other CTAs and also trades a portfolio that is broadly diversified across both markets and strategies. Usually, low correlation is achieved by trading pursuant to specialized strategies (such as short-term) or concentrating portfolios in sector-focused positions. To accomplish low correlation within a broadly diversified portfolio is unique. It is also a fundamental basis for incorporating Brandywine as a core portfolio holding. As we pointed out in our August report, despite being in our largest drawdown since inception, including Brandywine's Symphony Program in a portfolio of CTAs both increases returns and decreases risk. The report showed the same positive benefits are also exhibited when including Brandywine in a portfolio of stocks.

    But Brandywine did not launch our Symphony Program with the sole intent of providing investors with uncorrelated returns. We also, based on past performance and ongoing research, expected to earn substantial positive returns. While we were successful in accomplishing both goals over our first three years of trading, the past year - as we have pointed out in these reports - has proven to be an especially difficult period. While we can never say with certainty that a drawdown period is preparing to end (just as we were unable to foresee the drawdown beginning), we are encouraged by the more stable performance we've witnessed over the past few months. We encourage investors with a long-term perspective to call us to discuss how Brandywine's unique approach can add value to your investment portfolio.

    Nov 12 12:48 PM | Link | Comment!
  • The Psychology Of Investing

    Over the last week of September, Brandywine's slight monthly profit reversed to a moderate loss, with Brandywine's Symphony Program closing the month down -1.48% and the aggressively-traded Brandywine Symphony Preferred Fund closing down -5.47%. In contrast to July's large sell-off, over the past two months Brandywine Symphony's performance has fluctuated in its tightest range of the past year, as shifting sentiment and other conditions have resulted in the various strategies within the Program partially offsetting each other's positions. Interestingly (and illustrative of Brandywine's non-correlation to other investments), over that period the S&P 500 posted its largest trading range in more than three years.

    "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times…" is not just the opening line to Charles Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities, it is also an apt description of the emotions facing investors and their investment managers.

    When Brandywine's Symphony Program was hitting new performance highs in August 2014, it was the "best of times." Over its first 38 months of trading, Brandywine's Symphony Program had posted a Sharpe ratio of more than 1.0, in line with our high expectations. This resulted in our aggressively-traded Brandywine Symphony Preferred Fund being awarded the top Macro Fund by HFM Week (in the under $1 billion category).

    But paradoxically, it was also the "worst of times" from the standpoint of what was to come. Over the ensuing 13 months (thorough September 2015) the Program and Fund suffered through their longest and deepest performance drawdowns.

    This stark comparison illustrates why successful investing is such a difficult pursuit. Just as the best of times emotionally do not ensure future profits, it is often the worst of times that are the best time to invest. Take for example, March of 2009. Global stock markets had suffered through one of their most difficult periods since the Great Depression of the 1930s. Stocks had lost half or more of their value in the preceding 18 months. The news programs were filled with reasons why things would get worse before they got better. Very few people were comfortable putting money into stocks at those lows. Yet as we all know that was precisely the best of times to put money into stocks.

    While individuals and even many institutional investors often succumb to these emotional swings, the most successful investment professionals have processes in place to counter, and even exploit, the negative effect of potentially damaging emotions. This is exemplified in Warren Buffett's oft-quoted comment to "be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful."

    Brandywine's Approach to Controlling and Exploiting Emotions

    Brandywine was founded in 1982. Over the past 33 years we have become quite familiar with the emotional swings that come with trading. Brandywine's Symphony Program is built on that experience and the result is that our approach is designed to both manage and exploit emotions.

    Our primary approach to managing emotions is to trade pursuant to a systematic trading model. Although discretion is used during the research and development of our trading model, its daily application is 100% systematic. The result is that there is no urgent impulse for Brandywine to "do something" when we're suffering losses. We will certainly use the experience to guide us in our future research, as we want to learn from our difficulties in order to continually improve our potential future performance. But we won't make changes on the fly, as the effectiveness of our trading model is based on its consistent application over time.

    We exploit emotions by employing, as a portion of our portfolio, trading strategies designed to capture the emotional swings of market participants. This includes both periods when emotions are building and contributing to market trends, in which case some of our strategies attempt to profit from those trends; and times when market sentiment in specific markets hits what is historically an unsustainable extreme, at which time we enter into (generally shorter-term) counter-trend positions.

    Of course, as we've seen over the past year, there will be periods where despite the positive expected returns from our strategies a majority of them will 'get it wrong' at the same time. That's essentially the cause of any drawdown. However, the past two months have started to exhibit a different behavior. There has been much better balance between strategies that have performed well and those that have not. Our tight performance range is one result of this. Our currently moderate margin-to-equity ratio is another. But regardless of the short-term performance, we are confident that the best way to recover from a drawdown and to profit over the longer-term is to continue with the consistent application of our trading model.

    Oct 06 10:17 AM | Link | Comment!
  • The Benefits Of Brandywine's Non-Correlation

    August was another differentiating month for Brandywine. Our positive performance was in sharp contrast to the substantial volatility and negative returns suffered by investors in the world's stock markets.

    The benefit of this non-correlation is starkly evident in the following statistics:

    As can be seen, adding 20% Brandywine to an investment in the S&P 500 both increases returns and decreases risk. This is despite the fact that the S&P 500 total return index is just one month past its highest-ever monthly close and Brandywine is in our largest drawdown to date. In other words, because of our non-correlation with stocks, Brandywine adds value to stock portfolios not only when we're outperforming stocks, but even when we underperform. If Brandywine can add this much value when we're down, think of the value we add when we're performing strongly.

    In addition, Brandywine provides the same diversification value to a portfolio of CTAs, as the major CTA indexes all dropped during August while Brandywine gained.

    And the longer-term benefits of including Brandywine are just as positive:

    Allocating 20% of a CTA portfolio (also referred to as managed futures) to Brandywine also both increases returns and decreases risk. And for long-term investors our current drawdown may present an excellent entry opportunity for a new investment.

    As a bonus, Brandywine can be added to your portfolio without requiring any reallocation of existing assets. We can be purely additive. Call or email us to find out how.

    Sep 03 1:32 PM | Link | Comment!
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »
Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.