Seeking Alpha

Nathaniel Crawford's  Instablog

Nathaniel Crawford
Send Message
View Nathaniel Crawford's Instablogs on:
  • Lessons from Jesse Livermore

    I have read pretty much every book on Jesse Livermore. He really was one of the great traders who correctly called the 1907 panic and 1929 crash. Not only did he predict these crises, he profited handsomely and by 1930 was worth $100 million in cash. If you want a simple bio check out wikipedia. What I am going to discuss are the lessons I have learned from him and his trading strategy.

    1. Never be Bullish or Bearish---Livermore hated these emotional terms. Instead he was interested in the line of least resistance (trend). You make money by following the trend (up or down).

    2. Forget ideology---Some people will only buys stocks and some people will only sell stocks short. Livermore knew that to make money in the stock market you have to be flexible. He did not care whether he was 100% long the market or 100% short.

    3. Trade for the Big Money---Livermore was not interested in scalping 2-5% on some quick trade. He had made this mistake when he was young. By the time he matured he knew that it was simply not worth trading for small wins. He wanted to make alot of money and the only way you can do this is to take a large position and ride the line of least resistance. He played big trends for 30%-200%. That is how you make a fortune in the stock market.

    4. Playing the Big Trend Requires Patience---Livermore used to say that he did not make his money trading but instead sitting and waiting. This has to be one of the hardest lessons for traders who feel they have to be trading every day. Livermore would sometimes hold his positions for over a year as long as the stock acted right.

    5. Cut Your losses and let your winners run---This is probably the most important lesson. When Livermore purchased a stock or commodity he would set a stop loss of 8%. This was to protect his portfolio from dramatic losses. When you have gains do not be in a hurry to book them. You will often hear investment advisers tell you that you can never go broke taking a profit. Livermore's response was that you don't make very much either. This is a hard concept for traders, especially if the stock they bought at 50 goes to 58, but then starts to fall back to 53. They fear that they will end up taking a loss. Livermore would remain firm and hold the position as long as he did not get stopped out and he still liked the stock.

    6. Never establish a full position immediately---If Livermore wanted to establish a $100,000 position in a stock he would not do so all at once. He would first commit 25% or 25,000 at say $40 a share. If the stock rose to $41 he would commit another 25%. If the stock initially fell to $39 he would sit tight without adding to his position. The key here is that he would never average down which he though was suicide. If you by a stock because you think it is going up and it goes down, why would you add to a losing position. Instead Livermore would only average up. This kept him on the right side of the market.

    7. Never listen to stock tips or watch CNBC---Livermore never took stock tips or listened to what he read in the media. He knew that the media was used by stock speculators to manipulate prices and he did want to get screwed. Today that means avoiding CNBC and other media outlets who offer financial advice. Do your own homework because your are responsible for your trading performance. Livermore used to say that he did not need any help losing money because he could do that on his own.

    8. You cannot beat the market all the time---Livermore only traded a few times a year. He would wait for the perfect set up either long or short. He did this because he knew that it was impossible to beat the market on a consistent basis day after day. There are only a few times a year where the odds on your side.

    9. You will violate your own rules--Livermore had this problem throughout his career and it cost him dearly. He was once convinced by a expert cotton trader to go long cotton even though he was currently short cotton. Livermore for some reason broke his own rules by taking a tip and continuing to buy cotton even as it declined. He eventually sold out after losing millions. Livermore often questioned why he would consciously violate his own rules but could not explain it.

    10. The Market is never wrong--Many traders blame their losses on irrational market movements. This is a puerile mental attempt to shift blame from yourself to others. It is also asinine and a waste of your time. Livermore never did this--he took responsibility for his losses.

    If you are interested in reading more about Livermore there are two books I would recommend 1) Reminiscences of a Stock Operator by Edwin Lefèvre 2) How To Trade In Stocks by Jesse Livermore.


    Disclosure: No positions
    Tags: stock market
    Mar 24 7:14 PM | Link | 1 Comment
  • Market Summary 3.24.2010

    All of the media outlets will tell you that markets declined on "debt woes" out of Euopre and Fitch's downgrade of Portugal. In reality the markets declined because there were more sellers than buyers. You never really know why the markets go up or down on any particular day but the media feels compelled to give you are reason. Anyway the S&P 500 closed down 6.38 to 1,167.75.  

    Economic numbers out today were mixed with new home sales falling to a new record low (actually good for the housing market) and Feb. durable goods rising 0.5%.

    Gold, oil, copper, and most commodities were lower with the Dollar Index climbing to 81.83. EIA oil inventories (+7.4 million barrels) confirmed our suspicion that we now have a huge oil glut yet the price of oil remains above $80. Gotta love the speculators who keep pushing the price higher thanks to Ben Bernanke's cheap money. If fundamentals meant anything, oil would be around $50. Gold was a major disappointment today as it broke through the key support level of $1100.

    Tomorrow we will get initial and continuing jobless claims with consensus estimates of 450,0000 and 4,562,000. The markets will largely ignore these numbers as they seem to do every week. After all you can apparently have a V-shape recovery with millions jobless. Its called the "Goldilocks economy."

    Mar 24 4:02 PM | Link | Comment!
  • Euro Plunges on Portugal Debt Downgrade--Should you be short

    Well it was only a matter of time and today was the day. Fitch downgraded the debt of Portugal from AA to AA-. Fitch cited the usual generic boilerplate reasons such as weak fiscal position blah blah blah (they could say this about every G-8 country). Apparently this took the markets by shock which sent the Euro below 1.35 against the dollar. The reason for this movement in EUR/USD is the anticipation that Moody's and S&P will also issue downgrades. Fitch is usually the first one, which then puts peer pressure on the other two. I am still surprised the ratings agencies have such power after their previous failures in the US housing market.

    Right now the EURO looks like an easy short because these fiscal problems in Europe will continue for the next few years. But take a look at the most recent COT report.


    You will see that the big speculators are heavily short. It has been at extreme levels for the last few weeks. This is obviously a crowded trade which could precipitate a large short squeeze on any good news out of Europe. Believe or not the idea that Greece could get assistance from the IMF (as has been reported) would actually be good for the Euro. They would be able to successfully externalize the costs to an outside party. The commericals are now long the euro. This sets up a potentially dangerous position where one side is going to be wrong and get taken to the cleaners. This will result in high volatility in the pair. While I do not know which way it is going, I am thinking about going into the FX options market and buying a straddle position to bet on the volatility.

    One last thought to consider. The EU leaders love a weak currency and have a strong incentive to make sure the EURO stays low against the dollar. This will benefit their exports (mainly Germany) in world markets. Trichet will help this process along by not raising rates at least through 2010.

    Be careful trading.


    Disclosure: No position yet
    Mar 24 3:29 PM | Link | Comment!
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • buying kewl as an cheap play on the housing market. it is a undervalued timber company
    Feb 1, 2013
  • buying more KEwl as a bet on rising timber prices
    Nov 30, 2012
  • finally KEWL is starting to move up
    Nov 8, 2012
More »

Latest Comments

Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.