Seeking Alpha

Patent Plays'  Instablog

Patent Plays
Send Message
We are a group of sophisticated investors with experience in patent litigation, experimental economics, corporate finance and responsible corporate governance. Our member’s comments are carried online by publications such as The Wallstreet Journal, Reuters, CNN, Seeking Alpha and Motley Fool.... More
My company:
My blog:
Patent Plays
View Patent Plays' Instablogs on:
  • Worlds Set Up To Bounce Bungie; Activision Blizzard "Proxy" PTAB Challenge

    As we all know the Software Developer Bungie, an Activision Blizzard(NASDAQ:ATVI) software developer partner and owner of the Destiny Franchise has an active case at the Patent And Trial Board to invalidate Worlds (OTCQB:WDDD) Patent 8082501. The purpose here is to stop the IPR case from being played out in Federal District Court, Worlds v. Activision Blizzard. Well its seems World's has won the 1st round in the Bungie case by referencing a public contract that requires Bungie to Indemnify Activision against patent violations as Activision pays Bungie expenses to do so.

    This throws a massive wrench into Bungies complaint to invalidate Worlds patents. There exists in Patent Law a rule that requires a Defendant in an IPR case to file for a PTAB review no later than 1 year after the original IPR complaint (Worlds v. Activision). Worlds filed against Activision Blizzard in 2012. It appears that Worlds can prove that Bungie is Activision Blizzards defacto Proxy the PTAB case is subsequently OVER before it begins. The Judge hearing the PTAB case appears to be buying it, as he has allowed one motion for discovery to pass and Worlds is asking for more. On 8/16/2015 Worlds filed a request for what amounts to opening up Bungies Checkbook to see what Activision Blizzard bought, their contracts and agreements. Places I'm sure Activision does not want Worlds probing. Understanding the financial relationship of its partners can pay huge dividends on the IPR case.

    Bungie has alternatives, other than proceeding on. They could just walk away from the matter all together, and some think they may just do that, rather than risk intrusive Discovery for themselves or their partner Activision Blizzard.

    Stay tuned….

    Tags: WDDD, ATVI
    Sep 03 6:37 PM | Link | 3 Comments
  • Vringo Investors Rely On VRNG24's Federal Court Room Public Disclosures

    In Patent Infringement Stocks it goes without saying that knowledge is power, getting it is always the challenge. Many of us rely on our Brokers, Investment Journals, Seeking Alpha, or the Company itself to aid our investment decisions. In the case of Vringo(NASDAQ:VRNG) and its Global infringement lawsuits, the challenge is even greater. Many investors lack the resources to track litigation in the US much less around the world.

    To that end I am gratified and pleased that there are devoted shareholders like Joe Katz, commonly known as VRNG24 on Stocktwits. Mr. Katz has for the last 6 months ran a small blog website, in which he's fairly presented Vringo's worldwide litigation. This blog is small but powerful, accompanied by up-to-date downloadable pdf's of the latest court orders from around the Globe. Interestingly Mr. Katz has done this free of charge, working late into the evenings to keep his site always on target, always up to date, and always relevant.

    Many have followed Vringo's fight with ZTE Corp of China; know that ZTE has hired Global stock promoters to attack stockholder perception, that Vringo's opportunity for winning against ZTE is forlorn. This much is known because VRNG24 presented the Court Room Docs that disclosed this action. While many would laud and respect this behavior as a public service, some public boards have taken issue with the release of public Court Documents. The idea of squelching and silencing free voice is not Democratic, much less one like VRNG24 that goes out of his way to provide public Federal Court Documents for free.

    We need more people like Joe Katz, aka VRNG24, if the small investor is going to be able to play the patent game. Hopefully those Message Boards, and public blog sites that claim objectivity, will re-invite Mr. Katz and his VRNG24 back onto their sites and show the World that they truly are Democratic, and without a private agenda. Free speech counts on it, as well as the small investor hoping to invest in patent plays.

    Tags: VRNG
    Aug 09 5:14 PM | Link | 64 Comments
  • ZTE Fails To Break Vringo's Injunction In Romania; Key Assembly Plants Effected

    Vringo(NASDAQ:VRNG) continues winning key victories in its Global Patent Infringement lawsuit against ZTE(ZTECOF) Corp. Vringo holds several 3G and 4G wireless infrastructure patents that have been deemed essential in global communications. ZTE has consistently maintained the position of being unwilling to license the patents globally and has opted to litigate the infringement on a country by country process. ZTE has been unsuccessful at displacing Vringo's core wireless patents, acquired from Nokia, and has sustained harmful injunctions and legal losses around the world. Today's victory for Vringo effectively upholds a previous Romanian Injunction stopping ZTE from importing 3G and 4G wireless equipment. This serves to uphold the production stop of infrastructure assembled at their key plant in Romania. ZTE has already admitted contracts totaling $40 million have been put on hold, pending release of the injunction.

    By today's action (listed below and translated for convenience), it appears this release now is predicated on a Trial to be scheduled in the future.

    "Information file

    General information



    Paths attack

    Quote by advertising

    General information

    Nr. unique (no. old format): 11790/3/2015

    Registration date 06.02.2015

    Last updated: 10.07.2015

    Sector: Sector Civil IV

    Subject matter: Intellectual Property

    Subject: interim

    Procedural stage: Call


    Name Position part

    ZTE ROMANIA SRL, Appellant Applicant

    VRINGO INFRASTRUCTURE, INC intimate Defendant



    Estimated Time: 9:00

    Complete: S4-A PI C1V

    Solution Type: unfounded

    Solution Brief: dismissed the appeal as unfounded. Final. Delivered in open session today, 07.10.2015.

    Document: Judgment 360/2015 10.07.2015


    Estimated Time: 9:00

    Complete: S4-A PI CC1V

    Solution Type: Reserves

    Solution Brief: Reserves on 07/10/2015. MDO / VS

    Document: End - Defer initial delivery 07/07/2015


    Estimated Time: 9:00

    Complete: S4-R PI CC1V

    Solution Type: Postpone cause

    Solution Brief: Qualify as call appeal

    Document: End of session 07.07.2015


    Estimated Time: 09:00

    Complete: S4-council chamber

    Type Solution: End

    Solution Brief: Dismisses abstentions of Mrs. County. Maria Dalina Oancea, as unfounded. Without appeal. Delivered in open session today, 07.02.2015.

    Document: End - 07/02/2015 abstention

    Paths attack

    Given declaration declaring Party of appeal

    ZTE ROMANIA SRL ,, Appeal 05/28/2015"

    Tags: VRNG, ZTCOF
    Jul 10 10:04 AM | Link | 6 Comments
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • $WDDD $VRNG Looking forward to todays hearing. IMO Worlds will successfully defeat this Motion for Summary Judgement by $ATVI
    Nov 10, 2015
  • $VRNG $WDDD Correct year 2015
    Oct 29, 2015
  • $WDDD $VRNG action is 1:12-CV-10576 Select "Motion" Case is Worlds Inc. v Activision Blizzard November 10, 2105
    Oct 29, 2015
More »

Latest Comments

Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.