Seeking Alpha
View as an RSS Feed

Robert Weinstein  

View Robert Weinstein's Comments BY TICKER:
Latest  |  Highest rated
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    darekz, Right, I guess you know better with the non retina screens and memory etc...

    GooApple V5 Specification

    - Same retina screen like iPhone 4S, 960*640 pixel
    - Support GSM network, quad-band
    - Support WiFi, Bluetooth, GPS
    - Android 2.3 OS, iPhone interface
    - Support multi-language and a lot more of them. Not sure what part you guys are missing, but ok. no worries. Thanks for taking the other side of my trades.

    Its good to hear Chinese don't confuse real products for fake or subpar products. This would be news to me.

    I don't have the time to educate each one of the "experts" on Chinese business.
    Anyway, the article is about China not selling 70 million phones, but you go ahead and believe it if you want.

    For those that took something of value from the article, Thanks for reading and best to you. For those that didn't, thanks for reading and best to you as well.
    Apr 24, 2012. 08:46 AM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    Hey Gary,

    Glad to see you're still following me. It's been a while since you criticized one of my articles. I started to think you stopped stalking me.

    Well maybe you are correct. Maybe Apple will sell 70 million, who knows. After all you lived there so you should know, right?

    Best of luck to you Gary and thanks for reading my article.
    Apr 24, 2012. 12:23 AM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    darekz, Really? I guess someone forgot to tell these guys.
    Apr 23, 2012. 11:39 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    right, just like counterfeit items will not make it through the app process and be sold in the app store. "it can't happen".

    Seriously, this conversation is degrading beyond understanding. My point is your estimations are way too high. If anything "can't happen" it is 70 million iphones getting sold in China this year or next at anywhere near the margins currently enjoyed by Apple.You can believe all you want about fakes either way, its' only part of the issue. what matters is the actual sales
    Apr 23, 2012. 11:27 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Between Nokia And Research In Motion, RIM Is The Safer Play [View article]
    Luke you bring up some very valid points.

    Your statement "Nokia has a turnaround plan - a very aggressive go-for-broke plan..." Kinda makes my point for me about relative risk. Is Nokia going to go under? I don't know and I doubt anyone who does is talking, but relative risk I lean towards RIMM as safer money.

    NOK may very well make more sense for capital allocated in riskier and maybe higher return stocks.
    Apr 23, 2012. 10:54 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    Hi Jeb, Thanks for the kind words. It's ok that you disagree and I thought the same of Weezy's name.

    Anyway, I added that I lived in Japan for a couple of years and I understand the culture differences. it's not about that though and that is why I didn't bring the issue up. The point was that it's not realistic to believe 70 million sales are going to happen this or next year. "Miyagi san" is over estimating.

    I know a lot of people don't like it when the punch bowl gets taken away and I have written enough to be ok with it. Not reflective of you, but just because more comments disagree than agree don't make them correct. I stand on my record of calling the "China situation" as I see it and my record speaks for itself for those who will actually take the time to figure out if I know what I am talking about or not.
    Apr 23, 2012. 09:55 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    Weezy, I am surprised to see this comment.

    Ok, I guess "it can't happen" good luck with that.
    Apr 23, 2012. 09:35 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]

    Thank you. You obviously get it. I don't dispute the culture part of Miyagi's article at all, only how much potential can be expected right now.
    Apr 23, 2012. 07:50 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    I can't recall ever asking someone what their gender is or even thinking about it. It doesn't make any difference to me in the slightest and now that you bring it up it still doesn't.

    Perhaps it's my computer, but I don't see a bio for Weezy and as stated its the first article. If a history was not important enough for someone to post it's not important enough for me to "investigate" it.

    All of this is nothing more than a distraction anyway. My opinion is based on my understanding. Weezy could be a native business owner in China and I would listen, but I would not change my position. I also work with numbers all day in odds calculations so I am extreme about not having "sample bias".

    Also I don't have an axe to grind with China. In fact my office walls are filled with Chinese related items including many pictures.

    I just would not count on 70 million iphones being sold this year or next or anywhere near that number relative. As we all seem to agree, China is not the same as the US. In the end expect Chinese brands to make significant inroads into the upper end of smartphones cutting into Apples ability to monetize like they have elsewhere.
    Apr 23, 2012. 07:47 PM | 3 Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    This is not an all or nothing sort of thing, but yes on a relative basis this is part of the problem.

    Just because a store is a "Apple store" doesn't mean there won't be knock-offs sold. It appears naive to believe an "apple" store will never be found to be selling fakes. I don't "know" it will happen, but given my understanding I would be surprised to read about it at some point.
    Apr 23, 2012. 07:36 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    Hi Weezy,

    Firstly let me say thank you for reading my article and for taking the time to comment. I respect and appreciate your thoughts as well as the dignified manner in which you present them here.

    We don't share the same opinion on what the Chinese people will or will not "settle for", but that is ok. As you put it so well "It is important to understand opposing views".

    What appears to get lost in some of the discussion by some is that it is not an all or nothing type of thing. Apple in China is not binary and we will all likely agree Apple will have a large relative success. Where you and I start to part in our analysis of China is how much success Apple will have and for how long. Many successful world stage companies have come into China with guns a-blasting only to find it's a lot tougher than it first appears to compete.

    I am not bearish on Apple either and this is not meant to be an Apple bashing article.

    Yes Rolex and Ferrari among other brands have found success, but iPhones may be hot at the moment but there are closer alternative brands in China than many of the luxury brands cited (not that they have had a totally easy ride either).

    Again, thank you
    Apr 23, 2012. 07:30 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    Hello Mimi,

    Thanks for reading my article and taking the time to comment.

    I do not know what percentage of product that is fake is sold to citizens vs. visitors, but I am pretty sure in places where I am the only non Asian for 50 miles it is NOT Americans buying the products at the local stores.

    I will agree there is going to be plenty of vendors looking to sell all sorts of products to "white devils" but my article is beyond that. Try going into a music store and buying a Fender or Gibson guitar in China and see how easy it is to buy a real one.

    As far as iPhones go, you can't tell a real one from a fake one without opening it up. So how do you know the display models are not real and the one they give the customer is not fake? For having traveled 53 times I get the impression you have not gone far from the Intercontinental or Hyatt in Shanghai. Even my eight year old son can count to 100 in Chinese (something he has been able to do for about three years now). Can you?
    Apr 23, 2012. 05:39 PM | 1 Like Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    I am not sure how Weezy's gender has to do with anything other than a reach on your part to find something wrong.
    Apr 23, 2012. 05:26 PM | 2 Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Why Apple May Not Dominate China [View article]
    Thanks for your comment and kind words. You can add me to the list of people who have spent a significant time in the orient. I have lived in Japan and I have been to just about every major city in China many times.

    Many stores will not carry American products because customers will not buy them fearing it could be a fake. I will agree that many can discern from fakes, especially if "really bad", but most are not very bad and often their simply isn't a choice (take the DVDs for example).

    I have done business for years in China and have an understanding of the environment better than probably most. Even so, the history of "fakes" in China is so well documented and so much has been written about it that a trip there is not needed to know what the playing field is like.
    Apr 23, 2012. 05:25 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Big Technology Reporting Earnings Tuesday [View article]

    I like your comment and agree
    Apr 22, 2012. 11:04 AM | 1 Like Like |Link to Comment