Seeking Alpha

Shane Brett's  Instablog

Shane Brett
Send Message
Shane Brett is the author of the new book "The AIFMD Cheat Sheet" (August 2013) and also "The Future of Hedge Funds" (December 2012). Shane is on the Editorial Board of "All About Alpha" and is a Contributor Writer to "". He is the founder... More
My company:
Global Perspectives
My blog:
Shane Brett @ Global Perspectives
My book:
The Future of Hedge Funds
  • 5 Years On From Lehman's Collapse - What's Changed?

    5 years after Lehmans collapse, when the world came within a whisker of complete financial and economic meltdown its a good time to ask whats really changed in the world of finance since those dark days in September 2008?

    Over the next few of weeks I'll look at the main positive and negative changes since 2008, starting firstly with regulation.

    The last 5 years has seen lots of new financial regulation - some of it excellent and insightful, some of it awful and pointless. The time it has taken for large regulatory initiatives to take place is surprising but we have now seem wide-ranging requirements in relation to taxation (FATCA), consumer protection (Dodd Frank), banking (Basel & MIFiD) and hedge funds (AIFMD & Form PF).

    Whether all this makes much difference long term is a matter for debate. There will likely always be financial crashes as the economic cycle of boom & bust/greed & fear merely reflects the human psyche.

    The 30 period following WW2 was largely free of seismic economic shock. This period from the establishment of the Bretton Woods system till the US abandoned the Gold Standard in 1971 was remarkably stable by recent standards.

    Many would put this down to the Glass Steagall Act in the US. This bill passes in the teeth of the Great Depression (which Clinton repealed in 1999and has since regretted) forbade regular banks from becoming involved in investment banking. Banks lent far too much over the following decade and that house of cards came crashing down in a succession of the corporate, consumer and sovereign bailouts we have lives with ever since.

    John Mc Cain wants to reintroduce a new Glass Steagall bill for the 21st century. This is great idea - despite bank lobbyists probably driving it to extinct.

    Since 2008 banks aren't lending so naturally the shadow finance sector has become larger as companies seek new avenues to raise credit. This area needs proper regulation.

    The EU have done a pretty good job regulating Hedge Funds (with AIFMD - and which I spend my days implementing!) but the currently Chinese shadow finance system is a very expensive accident waiting to happen.

    The Chinese authorizes need to urgently bring their shadow finance system under their regulatory remit whereby up to $6 trillion dollars sits in Off Balance Sheet vehicles and loans. We all know how this ended in Europe.

    There is also growing pressure to properly regulate offshore finance.

    This is a development worth watching. Personally I am very skeptical whether any headway will be made here, particularly when some critics would suggest that the US and UK are arguably the worlds largest offshore centers (The City & Wall Street/Delaware recycling money from warmer climes).

    Some of the latest G20 proposals made the right noises but they also talked about leaving Trusts out of any new offshore financial rules. That's like bringing in Prohibition but excluding Guinness!

    The current system whereby large technology and finance companies structure their corporate tax to reduce their liability to peanuts will probably be changed somewhat.

    However it is important to note that Corporation Tax worldwide is on a long-term down trend and I expect this to continue, especially in the US. Even Sweden's company tax rate is below Americas (the highest in the Developed World).

    Finally, one of the unintended consequences of all this new regulation is to make it so expensive to comply that the financial world has seen waves of consolidation with banks, hedge funds and finance companies all merging to becoming bigger, making the banks especially - and ironically - truly too big to fail.

    10 banks dominate the American financial system and a lesser number in Europe and Asia. There is no credible plan for allowing an institution the size of Citi (quarter of a million employees) or HSBC (7,000 offices) to fail - they would have to be bailed out in all circumstances. Traders know this and have learned that if your going to fail - "fail big"!

    And that is exactly why finance needs to be tightly regulated worldwide.

    The last 5 years have made some reasonable progress but plenty more still needs to be done in the years ahead.

    Sep 18 8:53 AM | Link | Comment!
  • Deep Breaths For The Next US Debt Stand-Off

    Last week I wrote that the rest of 2013 would be dominated by 3 crises - Syria, Emerging Markets and the return of the Eurozone crisis.

    Unfortunately it looks like next month we may have to add a fourth crisis to that list.

    This week the US Treasury secretary Jack Lew fired a shot at Congress warning them the US would run out of money to pay its debts, if it did not increase the National Debt limit above its current limit of nearly $17 Trillion.

    All of this happening in an economy showing solid recovery and whose recent growth figures keep being revised upwards.

    So while the US may be a private sector success story, but it is a public sector disaster.

    The forthcoming US debt and budgetary crisis is part of a multiyear (decade?) paralysis between Democrats and Republicans which has been, and feels, endless.

    This legislative paralysis is mirrored across much of the country, where for years politicians have ensures re-election by promising elaborate public pension sector pensions and benefits - which will fall due long after politicians retire!

    This reckoning is starting to happen now, as we saw in Detroit, with many other cities and states lined up behind it.

    At the front of this queue is Illinois (which contains Chicago, the largest US city after New York and Los Angeles). Illinois spectacularly owes two and half times more in pensions that it has in its pension pot. There is not a snowballs chance in hell this can be paid. Its firemen, nurses and teachers face massive pension cuts in the years ahead.

    The key point here is that the current US debt ceiling discussions do not contain any acknowledgment or provision for these enormous unfunded state and city pension liabilities (never mind solution). The federal government will, in all likelihood, suffer the bill.

    As I have written elsewhere, the US is far from alone here. In fact, it in a better state that most of the G20 economies. In Ireland (where I live) the government has unfunded public sector pension liabilities equal to 4 times the country's GDP! None of this is included in its already dire National Debt figures (of approx. 130% of GDP).

    The US debt ceiling crisis will be played out against a background of imminent monetary tightening by the Federal Reserve. This will increase interest rates and while it was always going to happen sooner or later, higher rate expectations are already being reflected in higher US mortgage rates. This will slow down the rebound in the real estate market.

    Though it is highly likely this game of financial chicken will be avoided, the first half of next month could very well be a repeat of August 2011, with its heart stopping moments of brinkmanship, as the world's richest country teetered on the point of an unprecedented and unnecessary self-inflicted default.

    The long term outlook for the American economy is by far the strongest of major economies, primarily due to its demography structure, entrepreneurial population and access to endless cheap energy and food supplies.

    Needless to say Obama and Congress should put aside politician point scoring on this vital issue and increase the debt ceiling - while also agreeing a credible long term solution to curtail public spending.

    Unfortunately the possibility of this looks remote.

    No doubt a last ditch debt ceiling solution will be found in Washington by the end of October. Hopefully it won't derail the US economy recovery.

    The world economy is depending on it.

    Sep 13 8:14 AM | Link | Comment!
  • 3 Crises That Will Dominate The Rest Of 2013

    As the northern hemisphere summer draws to a close, three new emerging global crises threaten to dominate the rest of the year.

    1) In the Middle East Bashar Assad's likely use of chemical weapons on his own citizens is very likely to draw a military response from the West. Despite talk of a surgical strike and limited intervention, time and again over hundreds of years the Middle East has shown itself to be a quagmire, capable of embroiling even its most reluctant invader.

    The Syrian morass pitches the United States against Russia and Iran. This local war easily could become a proxy for indirect military conflict between larger global powers, as happened so often during The Cold War. Western countries have a firm habit of becoming deeply embroiled in local Middle Eastern conflicts. The markets are aware of this and the price of oil (and other commodities) has started to respond accordingly.

    2) While the markets may be clear about the impact of a Syrian strike, they are pretty much clueless as to where the ongoing rout in emerging markets will end up. Currencies of many important developing markets are in free fall as the market responds to the forthcoming "tapering" of money printing in the United States and with it the return of higher U.S. interest rates.

    As the U.S. dollar becomes more attractive to investors, the flood of money exiting major emerging markets is threatening to become a deluge and may cause massive currency depreciation in emerging market economies, which now make up half the world economy (including India, Turkey, Thailand, Indonesia, South Africa and Brazil).

    The real fear here is that the Federal Reserve is embarking on its new course of monetary action without really understanding the impact it will have on the global economy, including in the United States. If major economies such as India and Brazil suffer a substantial economic meltdown they will be forced to defend their currencies by dumping U.S. dollars and buying up Indian rupees, Brazilian real's and South African rand's.

    They will do this by selling the huge amount of U.S. debt they own, forcing up the price of U.S. Treasury bills and threatening to snuff out America's solid economic recovery. The United States no longer lives in a global economic vacuum.

    For the BRIC countries themselves the days of easy credit caused by rock bottom Western interest rates are over and we all know what that did to peripheral European economies once the tap was turned off of their decade long debt binge.

    3) That brings to the third crisis, the Eurozone, where last week the German finance minister admitted what many have long already known: That Greece will need a third bailout soon. Nothing will happen until Prime Minister Angela Merkel is safely re-elected in short order, but following this, depending on the extent of global turbulence from emerging markets, we can expect to see Greece request another haircut of its debt, to bring it down to a level they have some hope of repaying (perhaps 120% of GDP).

    The crucial difference is that money written off will be, for the first time, cash provided by Germany a couple of years ago to bail the country out. This will be the first time the German taxpayer has taken a direct hit for keeping the Eurozone together. Many Germans will have realized that the money they "lent" to Greece over the last three years would never be re-paid. These loans being written off will be confirmation that their money is gone and will be hard for many Germans to take.

    Even though I write this from a beautiful Mallorca beach where the Mediterranean resorts are full and the tourist towns heaving, large parts of the Eurozone's peripheral economy are unreformed and only tentatively emerging from two years of recession. If the third Greek bailout is not carefully managed, it could lead to a wider crisis across the Eurozone (particularly in Cyprus or Italy), and which will likely take place against military action in Syria and a tense period in the global economic environment.

    It is going to be an interesting final few months to the year.

    Sep 02 9:04 AM | Link | Comment!
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »
Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.