Seeking Alpha

Timeline Strategy Consulting » Comments » AIB

  • Preview from Europe: Stocks Shrug Off Yet More Dire Data [View article]
    Author's quote: "Note that the NASDAQ is now back positive for the year to date with Google".

    Roger, the gains are not measured from the year's low, they are measured year-to-date. That means from closing price on 31-Dec.

    That was 85.35 for AAPL and 307.65 for GOOG.

    So today, with another bit of gain, AAPL is at 20.4% YTD and GOOG is 23.4% YTD.

    In any case, it's sloppy writing to not check your math, and I refuse to read further. If the entire pretext of the article is someone's opinion based upon their observation of numbers, and those numbers turn out to be incorrect, why should I believe anything the author says?

    Sloppy, sloppy, sloppy. There's enough rubbish about investing on the internet. Why should I waste time reading something that's verifiably wrong?

    On Feb 09 11:51 AM Roger Knights wrote:

    > "Apple is not +26%. If it were, it would trade at about $108."<br/>
    >
    > Its low was 79 and change, and its close on Friday was 99.75 or so.
    > Rounding off to 80 &amp; 100 for simplicity, a 20-point rise from
    > 80 to 100 is 25%. So I figure 26% is within the ballpark.
    Feb 09 13:20 pm |Rating: 0 0 |Link to Comment
  • Preview from Europe: Stocks Shrug Off Yet More Dire Data [View article]
    Google is not +54%.

    If it were, it would trade at about $460.

    Apple is not +26%.

    If it were, it would trade at about $108.

    They are both up in fact 20%, give or take a few.

    Why should I read further into your article, which is opinion-based, when you have facts incorrect into the first 50 words? You should try harder.
    Feb 09 11:18 am |Rating: 0 0 |Link to Comment
More on AIB by Timeline Strategy Consulting
Comments by Ticker
AA, AAPL, AAUKY.PK, ABI, ABT, ABX, ACGL, ADP, ADRD, AGN, AIB, AIG, AKS, ALU, AMD, AMGN, AMLN, AMX, AMZN, ANST, APC, ARBA, ARE, ATVI, AXELF.PK, AZO, BA, BAC, BAM, BAX, BBI, BBY, BCR, BCS, BECN, BEZ, BGP, BMY, BNI, BRK.A, BRK.B, BRL, BSX, C, CAH, CAR, CAT, CBG, CBS, CCI,
Timeline Strategy Consulting's
Comments Stats
194 comments
Rating: 259 (358 - 99 )