Tom Szabo

Commodities: Brief Correction or Bursting Bubble?

There are quite a few small "commodity stocks" where the project economics are now underwater. If commodity prices slide far enough, the same thing could happen to some of the majors. Over time, the price of a given commodity (absent a monopoly like diamonds) will be slightly higher than the marginal cost of production. This is a reality that most current (sophisticated) investors recognize by awarding P/E ratios that are subpar to the market as a whole. If we do have confirmed peak production in a particular commodity, the paradigm may very well change but this is not something we will be able to confirm until several years of declining production in spite of higher prices. I agree that if and when the mom and pops buy up this sector, there could be other new paradigms to explain the overvaluations. Investing on that basis, however, is an application of the greater fools theory and not the way any billionaire got to be that way. Instead, if you have enough patience to wait for the type of absolute proof that is required to borrow every last penny you can to buy commodity stocks, you might be rewarded in the years ahead. And I don't think it will be too late if you just chill out now and wait for it. Remember the new paradigm: several years of rising commodity prices in spite of declining annual production. If it happens, that would be true alpha.