Seeking Alpha

Vash Patel's  Instablog

Vash Patel
Send Message
I am currently a student working on obtaining a Master's degree in Biomedical Sciences, and I have completed a Bachelor's in Biotechnology. While my background in biotechnology gives me a great perspective into high growth companies, I prefer to focus on equities that are undervalued no matter... More
My company:
Axis Org
View Vash Patel's Instablogs on:
  • Better In The Long Term: Dividend Superstars Or SPY?

    I was looking over a list of companies that have gone at least 25 years with a consistent growth in dividends and I was surprised by how many underperformed the S&P500 even with the dividends factored in. Just a quick experiment, I decided to make a spreadsheet of the 91 companies with their returns if one had invested $1,000 in each one 20 years ago.

    As it turns out, a full 25% of the companies underperformed against the S&P500 after factoring in their dividends. Another 6.5% of the companies outperformed the S&P500 by less than 0.5% annualized. The remaining companies all returned between 8% and 18% annually. The median returns for all dividend superstars were 9.5% annually. Over 75% of the annual returns lie between 6.40% and 12.80%

    I don't see any patterns in the dataset but I thought I'd provide the spreadsheet for others who may want to add in P/E values and other valuations to find other patterns. Without further ado, here it is:



    TickerNameYears of Div GrowthDiv YieldPriceClosing BalanceAnnualized Return
    TDSTelephone & Data Systems381.92%25.57$705.00-1.80%
    PBIPitney Bowes3010.94%13.71$1,713.172.90%
    NCNACCO Industries271.54%65.02$1,850.003.30%
    DBDDiebold, Inc.593.85%29.9$2,483.964.90%
    CTBICommunity Trust Bancorp323.67%34.34$2,963.145.80%
    MSEXMiddlesex Water Co.403.78%19.85$3,019.845.90%
    CWTCalifornia Water Services Group453.21%19.94$3,047.506.00%
    EDConsolidated Edison384.34%56.62$3,080.006.10%
    NWNNorthwest Natural Gas573.97%45.87$3,155.076.20%
    VVCVectren Corporation534.39%32.38$3,268.886.40%
    LEGLeggett & Platt413.84%30.24$3,293.606.40%
    UVVUniversal Corp413.60%55.57$3,253.106.40%
    WGLWGL Holdings363.97%42.34$3,294.466.40%
    UBSIUnited Bankshares394.75%26.12$3,324.586.50%
    MGEEMGE Energy372.96%53.34$3,526.446.80%
    GPCGenuine Parts562.81%70.54$3,726.037.10%
    CTWSConnecticut Water Services433.24%29.95$3,696.437.10%
    RPMRPM International382.82%31.89$3,839.987.30%
    STRQuestar Corp332.87%23.69$3,824.327.30%
    MOAltria Group435.06%34.78$3,913.347.40%
    ORIOld Republic International Corp316.02%11.8$3,908.117.40%
    BMSBemis Co.292.79%37.25$4,148.337.70%
    LANCLancaster Colony Corp.502.08%73.13$4,185.017.80%
    BKHBlack Hills Corp433.70%41.05$4,214.927.80%
    CINFCincinnati Financial523.65%44.71$4,282.877.90%
    KOCoca-Cola Co.502.74%37.21$4,252.977.90%
    CTASCintas Corporation301.48%43.38$4,355.818.00%
    SWKStanley Black & Decker, Inc.452.53%77.48$4,400.088.10%
    PPGPPG Industries401.70%139.11$4,470.008.10%
    NFGNational Fuel Gas Co.422.50%58.35$4,565.458.30%
    NUENucor Corporation393.10%47.47$4,672.728.40%
    AWRAmerican States Water582.73%51.96$4,800.248.50%
    TNCTennant Co.411.52%47.31$4,746.588.50%
    PNYPiedmont Natural Gas343.73%32.18$4,776.578.50%
    EMREmerson Electric562.82%58.1$4,999.658.80%
    FULH.B. Fuller Co.430.82%41.62$5,030.978.80%
    APDAir Products & Chemicals302.88%88.78$5,010.218.80%
    CBChubb Corp471.96%83.65$5,165.729.00%
    ADPAutomatic Data Processing382.88%60.45$5,280.689.10%
    DOVDover Corp.571.96%71.61$5,522.359.30%
    NDSNNordson Corp490.86%70.14$5,638.529.50%
    SJWSJW Corp452.64%27.66$5,698.109.50%
    SYYSysco Corp423.52%31.78$5,685.049.50%
    HCPHCP Inc.274.44%47.26$5,679.479.50%
    FRTFederal Realty Investment Trust452.67%109.18$5,942.059.80%
    BRCBrady Corp272.13%35.72$6,170.9410.00%
    MKCMcCormick & Co.262.12%64.09$6,155.6510.00%
    ABMABM Industries452.66%22.56$6,527.3810.30%
    WMTWal-Mart Stores382.23%71.39$6,573.0010.30%
    CBSHCommerce Bankshares442.32%38.77$6,613.9210.40%
    PGProcter & Gamble562.94%76.56$6,776.7810.50%
    SIALSigma-Aldrich Corporation371.12%76.85$6,887.0210.60%
    XOMExxon Mobil302.57%88.67$7,015.3610.70%
    HRLHormel Foods461.90%35.84$7,355.8811.00%
    PNRPentair Inc.361.74%52.98$7,417.1511.00%
    VALValspar Corp311.46%62.94$7,327.7511.00%
    CLXClorox Co.353.16%81.04$7,655.3811.20%
    ITWIllinois Tool Works492.39%63.55$7,747.3811.30%
    VFCV.F. Corporation402.28%152.32$7,807.8211.30%
    WEYSWeyco Group312.95%23.07$7,879.7711.40%
    CLCClarcor Inc.481.05%51.33$8,053.1811.50%
    JNJJohnson & Johnson503.22%75.66$8,663.9611.90%
    BCRC.R. Bard, Inc.410.79%101.45$8,781.2212.00%
    CSLCarlisle Co.361.18%67.67$9,067.2512.20%
    WAGWalgreen Company372.65%41.48$9,272.5012.30%
    SCLStepan Co.451.04%61.46$9,578.8612.50%
    PHParker Hannifin Corp.531.79%96.33$9,650.1812.60%
    SHWSherwin Williams341.21%165.45$10,087.7912.80%
    EGNEnergen Corp301.22%47.63$10,222.9912.90%
    BENFranklin Resources310.81%142.55$10,512.7313.10%
    MDTMedtronic, Inc.352.21%46.99$10,632.1813.20%
    FDOFamily Dollar Stores361.87%55.49$11,156.1413.40%
    BDXBecton Dickinson412.24%88.47$11,456.4213.60%
    RLIRLI Corp361.84%69.44$11,508.4513.60%
    MSAMine Safety Applications412.41%46.5$12,002.0313.90%
    ECLEcolab Inc.271.23%74.67$14,473.9615.00%
    EVEaton Vance322.02%39.51$21,406.5417.40%
    TROWT. Rowe Price261.83%74.21$23,352.2417.90%
    Average    $6,574.659.58%
    Div Stocks(Total Returns)   $507,293.54557.47%
    SPY(Total Returns)   $313,950.00345.00%

    If you'd like the excel spreadsheet to work with, send me a message and I can send it to you. Also, leave me a comment if you see anything interesting that you'd like to point out!

    Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

    Feb 14 1:47 AM | Link | 4 Comments
  • Apple Isn't Equipped To Compete In The Smartphone And Tablet Market

    It seems everyone is a bull on Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) these days and rightfully so. Apple, as of July of 2011, has more cash lying around than the US government. What's not to love? Everyone from analysts to iPhone users love the stock and it's hard to find a bear amongst the noise. Well, I'm here to tell you I'm a bear on Apple in the long term.

    With Steve Jobs at the helm, Apple has completely revolutionized every facet of technology. Jobs was a visionary to say the least and his business savvy was something you don't see even in the best of Fortune 500 companies. One of the biggest things that fueled Apple's growth was its unbelievable level of corporate secrecy about upcoming products. In fact, one of the reasons I don't see Facebook (NASDAQ:FB) becoming the next tech high flyer is because they simply can't replicate Apple's secrecy. That said, I think we're nearing the end of Apple's astronomical growth cycle and here's why.

    For one thing, iPhones have saturated the market to their upper limits, in my opinion. The only way to continue making money from them is with newer versions. This has worked so far, but how long will it continue? The differences between the newer generations of the iPhone are getting smaller and smaller. Things such as a higher resolution screen are sold to consumers as major upgrades, when in fact, improvements over time are an industry standard.

    Apple has had an advantage to Google's (NASDAQ:GOOG) Android thus far in that they had to develop iOS for one type of phone with very specific hardware. This allows them to optimize it to work smoothly without beefing up the power of the hardware. Android, on the other hand, is developed to work on a million different devices, each with their own hardware capabilities and limitations. This leads to a less smooth experience and longer timeframes for software updates (since phonemakers have to wait for Google to release the update and then modify it to work properly on their devices).

    Now, with Android taking up over 50% of the smartphone market, Apple's advantage is dissolving before our eyes. Hardware makers like HTC are rolling out software updates faster and faster as more and more Android devices become available and they're getting much smoother. Finally, Android provides one key advantage that Apple is missing out on: choice. With Android, consumers have the liberty of choosing a handset starting as low as $49.

    The iPad is more of the same story. It's the bestselling tablet in the world because it's very smooth and user-friendly, but how long before Android tablets catch up? It's going to get difficult to compete in a landscape where tablets like Asus's Transformer series will likely start to gain traction because of their versatility. What's more, Apple has provided consumers with the perfect time to switch to Android if it decides to change the dock connector for upcoming products. Consumers that may have held back making the switch because of the slew of Apple compatible products they own will have no reason to stick around anymore.

    We also have the rumored 7 inch tablet. This sounds like a company reaching for one last breath before finally giving out. I may be burned at the stake for saying this but it seems as though the creative juices are finally running out at Apple. The 7 inch tablet is the middle ground between the iPhone and the iPad. Those who already have the iPhone AND the iPad are unlikely to go out and get a 7 inch tablet because there simply is not any good reason to do so. The only thing that I can see happening is the 7 inch tab cutting into sales of the iPad and iPhone. This is not going to help the company grow.

    Unless Apple comes up with something drastically different in its upcoming models of iPads and iPhones, it's likely that consumers will start to get bored and move to Android. If you have friends that have made the switch already, you know what I'm talking about. Android allows users much more freedom over the device they spent hundreds of dollars on.

    I don't see Apple's price crossing above $750. In fact, I doubt it willreach $750. I would not be surprised at all to start seeing the price decline gradually as Apple loses ground to Android. The decline may be delayed with the release of iPhone 5 and a 7 inch tablet but that's a temporary fix. With RIM's (RIMM) BlackBerry 10 OS set to debut in January of 2013 competition over the smartphone/tablet market is only heating up. Apple did well in an environment devoid of any other device of similar capacity and had a great run. Now that they have laid the groundwork for the other guys, they're not keeping up with the times. While Android is becoming more powerful and less restrictive, Apple is sticking to its guns with complete control over its app market and mandatory software updates.

    Feel free to add your two cents in the comments or strike up a conversation with me about Apple , Google , RIM or anything investing related on twitter!

    Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

    Tags: AAPL, GOOG, BBRY
    Aug 14 2:23 PM | Link | 8 Comments
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • Western Digital To Benefit From Expansion Of Enterprise Data $WDC
    Dec 10, 2014
  • Get invested long-term in big data by buying $SNDK:
    Dec 3, 2013
  • Huge losses on $CLF in my virtual portfolio. Luckily the rest of the portfolio more than covered the losses. 20% return in the last 6 mnths
    Mar 28, 2013
More »

Latest Comments

Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.