Seeking Alpha

WhisperNumber

View as an RSS Feed
View WhisperNumber's Comments BY TICKER:
Latest  |  Highest rated
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    Adding to the discussion doesn't mean you have the right to come on here and spout 'personal truths', opinions, or random thoughts without backing up those 'thoughts' with fact, data, study, or evidence of such (or in this case anything). You are frustrated with my responses because that is the level of discussion you created - I just gave you back what you gave me, and that was very little.
    You started this 'discussion' with "newsflash etc etc...." and made a generic statement about AMZN reacting to the market - if that was the case, AMZN would mirror the DOW. Obviously that is not true (as AMZN has provided much better returns than the average market). Now, in some instances, AMZN (and other stocks) are influenced by the market - but that does not in anyway discount the idea that AMZN can also be influenced by other factors as well. You made a poor attempt at discounting the data presented in the article. Why? To make yourself feel better? To seem more important than others? Perhaps there was no purpose, and that's my point. If you have no purpose other than to disrupt, then don't post a comment.
    Feb 4 10:30 AM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    Please tell me you are not saying the price of AMZN is not influenced by anything else. That be silly.
    Feb 4 08:47 AM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    You should write an article, title it "Every Stock Will Fall This Week, Month, Year"
    Feb 4 08:14 AM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Pullback A Potential Opportunity? [View article]
    Don't worry Bill, that guy goes around telling every author they're either wrong or misleading readers. Did the same to our AMZN article but refused to offer any supporting facts to his accusations. Ask him how his long position in AMZN is going...
    Feb 3 08:22 PM | 1 Like Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    How's that long AMZN position you took?
    Feb 3 08:19 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    All well and good, but it still does not allow you to run around spouting misleading or inaccurate information (based on your 'gut feel') about any information. You still have yet to support your initial statements with any factual information or evidence.
    Feb 2 04:32 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    Great supporting facts you have (fyi, 'opinion' does not constitute fact)

    First, did you read the article?
    Second, love the use of 'nearly always' and 'almost always' misses the whisper (the data for each stock written about is in the article! Some miss at a high rate, some beat at a high rate, some are 50/50, and others are everything in between. But again, the data is in articles!)
    Third, have you ever read any of the educational articles on our site or even bothered to read about how we have collected data over the past 15 years?
    Fourth, considering the outlook provided in the article has been dead on so far obviously doesn't matter - if you didn't say it, or write it, obviously it can't be true, right?

    The only one guessing here and making assumptions is you.

    Watch what I do here:

    'investingIinvestor', I say you have a poor record all in all. You are wrong more often than your statements are right! Why do you continue to repeat the same mistakes? How many SA readers have been mislead (sp) by you? What kind of game is this? I honestly am confused as to why you blame others for your behavior. Honestly, your game is sick.

    There's a reason why you only have 18 followers...think about it...
    Feb 1 02:14 PM | 1 Like Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    Look at what I do here:

    Gumby, I say you have a poor record all in all. You are wrong more often than your statements are right! Why do you continue to repeat the same mistakes? How many SA readers have been mislead (sp) by you? What kind of game is this? I honestly am confused as to why you blame others for your behavior. Honestly, your game is sick.

    Now, does that make sense? How would you respond?
    Jan 31 01:01 PM | 2 Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    That's for someone else to analyze, we don't do that.
    Jan 31 12:50 PM | 3 Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Amazon Sees Shadow, 30 More Days Of Weakness [View article]
    Huh? What 'record' are you referring to? What 'predictions' are you referring to? What 'same mistakes' are you referring to? Who do we blame and where is that stated? Please be specific instead of spouting general nonsense.
    Jan 31 12:50 PM | 4 Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Facebook Tops Whisper, Why The Stock Could Drop [View article]
    Not short term...what's your time frame?
    Jan 30 05:57 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • Facebook Tops Whisper, Why The Stock Could Drop [View article]
    Not today...whats your timeframe?
    Jan 30 02:01 PM | 1 Like Like |Link to Comment
  • Facebook Tops Whisper, Why The Stock Could Drop [View article]
    Intra day price moves - no after hours/pre-market data.
    Jan 30 01:09 PM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
  • What The Buy Side Expects From PotashCorp [View article]
    The author and I should agree on one thing - one correct example of a company supposedly reacting to guidance does not a trend make. If it were valid there would be many studies indicating such. I could have said Potash will fall because the temperature increased in Sweden. That doesn't mean its a valid analytical signal, just coincidence.

    Now, does Potash always (or a majority of the time) trade lower on guidance? Possibly, we don't track that data. But as a whole, there is no statistical evidence that stocks consistently move higher or lower on forward guidance.
    Jan 30 12:43 PM | 1 Like Like |Link to Comment
  • Facebook Tops Whisper, Why The Stock Could Drop [View article]
    Until investors and traders start ignoring analysts and penalizing the mainstream financial media for using them as their go to source, we're all out of luck (and money).
    Jan 30 11:37 AM | Likes Like |Link to Comment
COMMENTS STATS
255 Comments
80 Likes