Seeking Alpha
Seeking Alpha Portfolio App for iPad
Finance
(1)
Market Currents

Though it pulled Prop. 2 after David Einhorn scored an injunction, Apple (AAPL -0.5%) is still...

  • Wednesday, February 27, 12:41 PM ET
    Though it pulled Prop. 2 after David Einhorn scored an injunction, Apple (AAPL -0.5%) is still committed to requiring shareholder approval for issuing preferred stock, the company states at its shareholder meeting. Also, CalPERS says it would have voted for Prop. 2 if it had the chance. A proposal granting shareholders an advisory vote on exec. compensation has been approved, while one requiring execs to keep 33% of their stock until retirement has been shot down. Doug Kass might be disappointed to learn no stock split has been announced (or perhaps not). (live blog)
Track new comments on this story

This news story has 18 comments:

  • ugh. nothing will come out of this meeting. I'm not sure if Cook and management understand that they stock's price is absolutely tied to the perception and coolness of the company. I am incredibly disappointed in the lack of concern they are showing about their reputation.
    27 Feb, 01:10 PM Reply Like
  • I agree 100%. As the stock price continues to slide the coolness factor wears off. People who would have never considered anything but an AAPL product start looking for alternatives. They start to equate the stock price with product quality. No number crunching can explain it but it's happening. As far as today's BOD meeting, anybody who expected a major announcement that would move the needle should have known better. In short, if you don't like the way Cook is running the show, sell your shares.
    27 Feb, 01:35 PM Reply Like
  • pfbsurf, this has been a shareholders' meeting. It is pro forma. It precisely followed the agenda. There are no "one more thing" surprises here.

    No damage was done in spite of Einhorn.

    Hopefully, you will get your surprises at the upcoming Apple events!
    27 Feb, 02:37 PM Reply Like
  • I do agree that today may not have been the right time to present new products or even offer a dividend, but I am underwhelmed by Cook again. Which is too bad because I do think he's a bright guy, but between the last earnings call and today, he has been less than impressive.

    They have to understand that the level of scrutiny that they are under is important and that the "negative" news has gnawed away at the most important asset they have - their reputation.

    Hopefully (up to my eyeballs in AAPL btw) today's action is the last sign that the stock is truly at a rock bottom valuation... I'm ok with a flat to slightly down day...
    27 Feb, 03:38 PM Reply Like
  • Apple has definitely lost the cool factor. Have you noticed its recent ad camaigns vis-a-vie its competition? While Android feature ads with young people having fun with copycat devices, Apple's ads tout its microphone that turns down ambient noise. They feature old people and kids playing Banjo. Tim Cook is the Captain of the Titanic.
    28 Feb, 06:39 AM Reply Like
  • many people expect apple announce something to support the stock price today including me. When nothing happen the stock tank.
    27 Feb, 01:11 PM Reply Like
  • Same crap, different Apple meeting...when are we going to hear news that actually affects shareholders in a positive way? No reason for the stock to be at these levels, yet Cook doesn't want to do anything about it.
    27 Feb, 01:14 PM Reply Like
  • Apple doesn't announce stuff at a shareholder meeting. Why would you expect that?

    Shareholder approval of what would have been the element of proposition 2 that got edited out will simply be approved at the next shareholders meeting. Who could not possibly have figured that out? Essentially all of the institutional shareholders are in favor of it, and it enhances shareholder rights, as it should.

    Apple management is managing the company for the LONG TERM, not for short term changes in momentary share price. This is great for long term investors, and bad for anyone hoping for a quick buck based on whatever they want to do to make a quick buck.

    Apple is being managed for "investors" not for "traders." If you're a trader, you might or might not make money on Apple in the short term; good luck in your various schemes. Don't expect Apple management to run the company to enhance your short-term schemes.

    If you want a rah-rah manipulating CEO, go play with salesforce.com. You'll get the full load of every possible manipulation to increase share price. Go trade CRM and stay away from APPL.
    27 Feb, 01:19 PM Reply Like
  • For every other company, this might be a reasonable answer. But not for Apple. They aren't making pharmaceuticals or industrial valves. They make expensive consumer products.

    My initial point, and one that recently just dawned on me, is that there is a very dangerous negative feedback loop going on here - Plummeting stock price - no news from company (other than sales are going well!) - public perception declines... And in the end, ALL Apple has is public perception.


    We don't need huge announcements, we need a better communicator.
    27 Feb, 01:28 PM Reply Like
  • ... or we need a public that is better informed. The management culture that drove the share price from 2007-2012 is still in place, what has changed is exactly this public perception but not the consumer perception rather I agree with Daniel the "traders", consumers just don't make the same demands as traders, hence, Apple has no problem selling devices.

    I'm long AAPL and say BRAVO! Announcements will come but the culture has not been to make announcements at shareholder meetings, I'm good with that.
    27 Feb, 01:36 PM Reply Like
  • The public is being informed, every day on CNBC.

    This is silly and shortsighted. If you think they have a monopoly on cool, they don't. At one point,it was extremely cool to have a blackberry phone.

    Cook is an arrogant billionaire, without the mystique of a Steve Jobs. The earnings conference call was a disaster, the shareholder meeting is a dud.

    "Traders" aren't the ones getting hammered here - that is a ludicrous statement - they have been out of the stock - the buy and hold (read "loyal" shareholders) have been punished by the market and are being left out of the conversation entirely by the small clique of 9 and 10 figure managers at Apple.
    27 Feb, 01:59 PM Reply Like
  • Berylrb.... Agree, initially disappointed but now, IMO, Tim did the right thing. He knows what is in the lab. You gotta believe in him and his team. That's the bottom line. I still have faith. Long aapl.
    27 Feb, 06:40 PM Reply Like
  • Apple presents TC the clown and sideshow Einhorn with special guest Kass and his whispering mountain gnome. Not liking this show at all.
    27 Feb, 01:21 PM Reply Like
  • Should Doug Kass be investigated for posting the stock split rumor that he obviously profited from?
    27 Feb, 01:25 PM Reply Like
  • I think ol' dougie should get a visit from the SEC. Pathetic attempt to manipulate a stock although it doesn't look like it worked out all that well. He was hoping the stock would get slammed after no announcement.
    27 Feb, 01:47 PM Reply Like
  • Anything that you hear or read from pundits, negative or positive, about Apple's future, should be taken with a grain of salt, if not with indignation.
    I'm convinced that Apple's culture and management are well versed in ignoring their day to day stock price because they are accustomed to placing the appropriate emphasis on the mid to long term goals of the company.
    Long AAPL.
    27 Feb, 01:43 PM Reply Like
  • Holding on for the next big item and or an increase in the dividend.
    27 Feb, 07:46 PM Reply Like
  • @pbsurf

    You're wrong that all Apple has is the public perception. They have a company, a going concern, that continues to make about $220 million in free cash flow every single day. CNBC, commentators, hedge fund manipulators hoping to make a quick hit can do what they want and say what they want, but the product continue to be made, the buyers continue to buy, and the company continues to make more profit than any company ever has in the history to the world. Apple does not need Wall Street to finance its operations or to tell it what to do or where to go. Apple is NOT going to be part of anyone's quick-hit financial engineering scheme.

    You need to read more Warren Buffett and stay away the idiotic media commentators. When "public perception" differs from the the underlying reality of what is going on with a company, that leads to opportunity. Where is the contrarian in you?

    In physics and engineering, we learn about the "signal to noise" ratio. In today's investment world, there is an incredibly large amount of noise, and only a small amount of signal. People over-react every hour to some little piece of noise somewhere, and trade based on it.

    Do you really think the traders have all home on Apple and that long-term Apple investors are the only ones left? You couldn't be more wrong on this. The average trading day sees more than 20 million Apple shares trade, almost $10 billion exchanging hands each day just in Apple shares, not to mention the enormous size derivatives trading in Apple. Most long-term investors are sitting on the sidelines watching all this; not that many are buying or selling on any given day. The buying and selling (the "market") is made up almost entirely of traders. In the markets, you can have an opinion, but you have to trade to vote. If you don't vote (buy or sell shares), your opinion doesn't affect share prices (unless you gather media attention, write articles, etc.).

    The traders run the market in the short term; and the short term happens every day. If you're going to act as a long-term investor, you need to get a good sense of what you believe the intrinsic value of the shares are and will be in the future, and you need to be right, versus the market perception today. It is a completley different mentality. If you don't think the market is somehow mis-pricing a security today (high or low), and aren't willing to buy or sell or hold based on your perception of the mis-pricing, you can't really call yourself an investor. You should just buy some mutual fund or market index and be the tiny boat afloat on the giant ocean, and rise or fall based on others actions with no real opinion of your own.
    28 Feb, 11:53 AM Reply Like
Other date
DJIA (DIA) S&P 500 (SPY)