Doug Wright's  Instablog

Doug Wright
Send Message
With his experience and study of the markets, Doug Wright has created unique strategies for a variety of investors looking for risk protection as well as good returns. Doug realizes that one strategy does not fit all, and his intent is to provide self-directed investors a guide in assembling a... More
My company:
The Focused ETF Investor
My blog:
  • The Hot Hand Vs. Passive Investing 1 comment
    Feb 1, 2012 11:30 PM

    Do individual investors chase hot managers of funds? It
    would appear so. Is there a tendency to jump ship when an
    investment or manager lags? That also appears to be the case.
    Let's look at Morningstar Domestic Stock Manager of the
    Decade, Bruce Berkowitz, and his fund, the Fairholme fund.

    The Fairholme Fund(MUTF:FAIRX) recorded a 14% annualized return
    from inception through the end of December 2010. The fund in
    2011, however, landed at the bottom of the barrel in the
    large value category , losing -32.4%! Since the fund has
    run into heavy headwinds, investors have fled in droves
    and the fund has shrunk from over $18 billion to less than
    $11 billion in assets. These investors that sold have locked
    in their losses.

    Lest you would think this is an isolated case, let's look
    at one of the most highly touted managers, Ken Heebner,
    and his fund, CGM Focus(MUTF:CGMFX). According to a recent article
    by Max Magee on Tickerspy(,
    the Wall Street Journal listed CGM Focus as Stock Fund
    of the Decade. Its track record has been incredible this past
    decade. Manager Ken Heebner led this fund to an 18.2% annual
    gain in a decade for which the S & P 500 was in the red, placing
    him tops among all domestic equity fund managers during the
    last decade ending December 2010, besting the S & P 500 index
    and Russell 1000 by 20 percentage points.

    Since it has had such a good return, shouldn't you have put this
    in your portfolio? Not so fast! First of all, with an average
    turnover ratio of 333%, you could have ended up with a huge tax
    liability, as in 2007, when CGM Focus declared a distribution of
    $9.91 a share or 18% of the funds end of year share price.

    Still want to chase these returns? Lest you think you can handle
    this volatile fund, let's see what actual CGM Focus investors
    made. According to Morningstar, most of the fund's investors did
    not make 18.2% compounded, not even close. The average CGM Focus investor earned a negative 11% annually over the past decade! That translates into a total loss of 68.8% for the decade. This kind of return over an entire decade will definitely hamper your investment goals.

    How could this happen? Well, let's take a quote from an interview
    with Mr. Heebner." A huge amount of money came in right when
    the performance of the fund was at a peak," says Mr. Heebner,
    the funds manager since inception. " I don't know what to say
    about that. We don't have any control over what investors do."

    This herd behavior of investors and how they goof things up for
    themselves is a huge lesson and must be recognized and understood in order to be avoided. So what did investors in the CGM Focus fund do in 2011? They bailed out just like the investors in the Fairholme fund. More than $630 million dollars have been pulled out from the fund, leaving
    less than $2 billion in assets. These shareholders must not have been satisfied with a return of -26.3% in 2011.

    Since it is obvious that investing in a hot performing managed fund is a losing game to many an average investor, what is the preferred course of action? Investing exclusively in individual stocks can add significant single company risk to a portfolio, if there are too few holdings. A far better approach would be to consider broad based, low cost, passively managed exchange traded funds(ETF's) for the bulk of a portfolio. As core holdings, this approach takes the hot or cold streak of the manager out of the equation.

    Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

Back To Doug Wright's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (1)
Track new comments
  • Bill Wysor
    , contributor
    Comments (5) | Send Message
    Good article especially with the positive January just recorded and the fact that over the last six months investors have been fleeing stock funds in favor of bond funds at about a 2 to 1 ratio!!
    2 Feb 2012, 11:24 AM Reply Like
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers

Latest Comments

Most Commented
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.