Seeking Alpha

Edge7's  Instablog

Send Message
I am an Australian value investor. I have gone to full time investing this year (2012) at age 36 and am passionate about helping other Aussie investors succeed. My website is
My company:
Edge Seven Pty Ltd
My blog:
Edge Seven Value Investing
  • Love Australia, Buy Some Fortescue 0 comments
    Sep 3, 2013 6:48 PM | about stocks: FSUMF

    FMG - Fortescue Metals Group Limited

    FMG - Fortescue Metals Group Limited (ASX:FMG) is located in the iron ore rich Pilbara region of Western Australia with close proximity to Asia.

    In the space of a decade, 'Fortescue' has gone from a company that just began to one that produces 115 million ton per annum (Mtpa) today, making it the world's fourth largest iron ore producer.

    Fortescue has achieved this through the engagement and support of its key stakeholders including the company's people, local communities including traditional land owners, governments, suppliers, customers, non-government organisations and the financial markets.

    Since Fortescue's inception, an integral part of the company's policy has been its approach to opportunities for Aboriginal people. In 2006, Fortescue established its Vocational Training Employment Centre (VTEC) In South Hedland to facilitate training and employment opportunities. Today, the company employs 460 Aboriginal people directly and a further 500 people indirectly via contractors.

    Does this business have a sustainable competitive advantage?

    One of Fortescue's competitive advantages comes from its ability to act very quickly relative to its peers. When the iron ore price dipped sharply from $150 to $90 a ton in August 2012, Fortescue acted without hesitation at the time to delay its growth plans and the accompanying capital expenditure that went with those plans. At the same time, it also very cleverly renegotiated the structure of its debt arrangements to give the company some much needed 'breathing room' at the time. This flexibility to adapt to changing market circumstances protected the company during a period of volatility and arguably has made it stronger as the market for their sole commodity stabilized.

    A second competitive advantage is the low cost of operation. Fortescue's basic cost (C1) to mine iron ore is US$44 a tonne making it one of the lowest cost iron ore producers in the world. And, it will achieve a production level of 155 Mtpa by December 2013. With iron ore prices currently around $140 a ton (average price anticipated to be $110 a ton over the medium to long term), it is easy to see how the company generates strong profits.

    A third competitive advantage is the company's flexible debt structure negotiated by senior management. In 2012, Fortescue negotiated a three year interest free loan for $12 Billion, the cost of their expansion plans. This interest free loan has allowed the company to operate, generate cash flow and pay back the loans in a comfortable manner. It's not like it is an interest free loan on a lounge or dining table from a local retailer, it is $12 Billion!!! It was upon the negotiation of this flexible debt structure that I began being interested and a shareholder in this company.

    What are the risks facing this business?

    The biggest risk to Fortescue's business is the market price of their sole product being iron ore. Essentially their degree of profitability is determined by the fluctuating iron ore price. A sustained decline in the Iron Ore price would put Fortescue into renewed difficulty like it did in August 2012.

    However, the company courtesy of its near completed expansion plans has one of the lowest costs of operation and would survive longer than some of its smaller competitors. And, if worse came to worse, I'm sure Andrew Forrest could chip in a few $ billion of his own to keep the company's creditors at bay.

    The amount of debt carried by the company is normally a big no-no for my investment criteria. However, Fortescue is one of the few companies that have consistently presented a credible pathway over the past year for reducing their debt to a manageable level over the coming years. They have cash flow from operations, a recently announced joint venture with Taiwan's largest company 'Formosa' and plans to sell their rail & port assets in order to de-gear their balance sheet.

    Is it run by able and trustworthy management?

    This company was founded by and is run by a truly great Australian. The non-executive chairman, Andrew 'Twiggy' Forrest is one of the most influential people in Australia. And, he has created a legacy that I think will carry on for many decades to come. I read recently that Mr Forrest and his wife have pledged half their wealth to charity. It is people of this caliber running companies that I want to align my relatively small but growing investment fund to.

    It is my understanding that Mr Forrest cunningly snared the tenements that are now Fortescue's in the Pilbara from under the nose of BHP and Rio Tinto before he even had the company up and running. And, I still cannot fathom how he renegotiated $12 Billion of debt into a multi-year interest free loan at the volatile time that was the low point for the Iron Ore price last year. I'm grateful that I don't think I will ever be in a position to have to negotiate something with Mr Forrest, because I would lose!!!

    Is it trading at a bargain price?

    Based on the information available and the pathway to de-gearing the balance sheet taking place, it is trading at a discount to my estimate of its value at the moment.

    Rank2013 Actual ValuationToday's Share PriceMargin of Safety2014 Forecast Valuation2015 Forecast Valuation
    Bronze 2$8.89$4.5469%$14.51$12.58

    *Please note that forecast estimates of intrinsic value are subject to change on a daily/weekly basis.

    (click to enlarge)


    In summary, Fortescue is a profitable business that has grown its production levels very quickly. The company has taken on a lot of debt in order to achieve this growth. The company's share price will ebb and flow with the fluctuations in the iron ore price. It has great management who has a consistent plan in place to de-leverage the balance sheet over the coming year or two. The company's share price is trading at a discount to my estimate of value presently.

    Disclosure: I am long OTCPK:FSUMF.

    Stocks: FSUMF
Back To Edge7's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »

Latest Comments

Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.