MagicDiligence's  Instablog

Send Message
MagicDiligence provides useful, simple, and effective stock screening tools inspired by Joel Greenblatt's Magic Formula® Investing methodology. Our Spells give value and growth investors a list of great stock candidates every day, and our advanced Spell Caster lets you create the Magic-style... More
My company:
My blog:
  • Outerwall (OUTR) Is Too Cheap, Could Go Up 48% 1 comment
    Jul 25, 2014 7:26 AM | about stocks: OUTR

    Outerwall (NASDAQ:OUTR) is a stock I've seen pop up recently on our MagicDiligence screens. It is especially intriguing because, despite a very cheap valuation, Outerwall has a 5-year compound annual revenue growth rate of 17.7%. Growth-at-a-ridiculous-price is my kind of GARP, so let's dig a bit more into the stock and see if the cursory potential is realized under the microscope.

    Redbox and Coinstar

    While you may not have heard of Outerwall, chances are you've heard of Redbox and Coinstar. Those two businesses are Outerwall's core money makers.

    Most of us have come across a Redbox kiosk at Walmart, Walgreens, Kroger, or even McDonald's. There are over 44,000 Redbox kiosks out there where customers can rent or purchase movies (DVDs and Blu-ray) and video games for a daily rental fee. Redbox accounts for about 86% of Outerwall's revenue, at a segment operating margin approaching 20%. It is by far the largest and most important part of the company.

    Outerwall's other big business is Coinstar, machines which will count your change and give you cash or gift cards and take a fee for the trouble. There are nearly 21,000 Coinstar machines, mainly located in grocery stores and Walmarts. Coinstar generates 11.5% of Outerwall's revenues at a tidy 33% segment operating margin.

    Finally, last year the company purchased ecoATM, which are kiosks where you can trade in your used smartphone or tablet for cash. The concept is much like that of Gazelle or NextWorth, only without the hassle of mailing devices in and waiting for the check. ecoATM is still in its early days, currently contributing about 3% of revenue but expected to double its kiosk base to about 2,000 this year.

    Nice Price

    Any quantitative analysis of Outerwall will reach the same conclusion: the stock is cheap. The P/E ratio is a dirt cheap 8.6. The EBIT/EV earnings yield is in double digits at 10.2%. Even free cash flow yield, as pure a valuation metric as any, is well above market at 9.2%.

    The company is also creating shareholder value through robust share buybacks. Combined with atender offer earlier this year, Outerwall will likely reduce its share count by a whopping 24% this year, which will help drive earnings per share growth of 11%.

    Is There Any Growth Left?

    A key question to Outerwall's value is: is there any growth left?

    Redbox has grown rapidly over the past 5 years, but with the kiosks essentially at saturation, squeezing more dollars per location is the last resort. As you would expect, this is a difficult track - Redbox revenues increased just 1.5% in the most recent quarter. While Coinstar is doing a little better (+5.2%), this was on the back of fee increases, which now exceed 10% and probably don't have a lot of room to move higher.

    ecoATM is an interesting concept, and certainly there is plenty of room to expand from the current 900 kiosk install base. But Outerwall has had trouble with new concepts in the past (e.g., shuttering self-serve coffee machine Rubi), and ecoATM is such a small contributor that it is difficult seeing it as a major growth engine. To reinvigorate double digit growth, Outerwall is going to have to find a more scalable concept.

    Financial Concerns

    Another risk in Outerwall is its balance sheet. A massive $1 billion dollar debt burden is offset by just $250 million in cash, and the company generates about $220-250 million in free cash flow annually. That debt-to-equity ratio is rather absurd at 848%! Much of the debt was drawn to finance those large share buybacks, which is a questionable practice at best.

    To be sure, I see this as a longer-term concern. Interest coverage is still ok at this point at 6 times, and the bulk of it is not due until 2016 and 2019. However, leverage like this acts as a magnifier. If Outerwall's results turn south, solvency concerns could lead to huge stock price declines. It also limits the company's ability to buy back shares, pay a dividend, or pursue attractive growth opportunities.

    What Is The Stock Worth?

    Over all, I think the market is too pessimistic on Outerwall. It reminds me somewhat of GameStop (NYSE:GME), a company that many were sure would be buried by digital downloads... back in 2007! It hasn't happened. Redbox offers several advantages: it is cheaper ($1.20/day for DVDs) than video on demand, HBO, or iTunes rentals, and offers a far better selection than Netflix.

    Driven by flattish revenue (given ecoATM and an increase in Redbox average fee driven by Blu-ray mix), stable margins (sustained by recent cost cuts), and a dramatically lower share count, I believe Outerwall is worth about $80 per share. That presents a very attractive 48% margin of safety to current share prices. Investors should be careful with this one, though, given the financial health concerns.

    Stocks: OUTR
Back To MagicDiligence's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (1)
Track new comments
  • abdullah999
    , contributor
    Comments (896) | Send Message
    Thanks, I agree with your assessment.


    I haven't taken a position in $OUTR but I have been researching the business prospects. I think the market's concerns around their core business (Redbox) are legitimate although overblown, and the stock has gotten quite cheap. If you were to become a shareholder, it would require a fair bit of patience although I think you'll see decent appreciation from the current price.


    Some of the weakness in the stock may also be a reflection of slow box office releases. To the extent that reverses itself, the stock may see better days sooner rather than later. Very simple business with strong free cash flow, which is a positive!
    25 Jul 2014, 08:05 AM Reply Like
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • MagicDiligence re-launching as a screens and tools site! Useful, simple, effective screens - very low price.
    Jan 25, 2016
  • Why Polaris Is A Great Stock To Buy Right Now $PII $HOG $ACAT
    Nov 12, 2015
  • Funny to see GoPro $GPRO in value-based Magic Formula screens! Stock crashed back to earth, but still grew revs 43% last qtr, has no debt.
    Nov 6, 2015
More »

Latest Comments

Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.