Please Note: Blog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors.

Why People Make Idiotic Economic Forecasts? Because They Don't Invest

These two pieces about Niall Ferguson have been brought to my attention by Barry Ritholtz:

http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/niall-british-empire-is-over-accept-it.html

http://www.businessinsider.com/niall-ferguson-has-been-wrong-on-economics-2012-8

Both show that Niall was completely, utterly wrong in his economic predictions. As far back as since 2004, if not much earlier. What can I say? Anybody can make forecasts in sport and economics not paying any penalty. In sport, it's an absolute truth. In economics, not so absolute. If you don't invest/manage your own money, you can say anything you want. But let's see what would happen if Niall followed his own advice:

2004: Niall thinks China is going to stop buying US debt. Logical conclusion: short Treasuries. Result: huge loss of capital.

2009: Niall predicts collapse of US Treasuries market. Logical conclusion: short Treasuries. Result: huge loss of capital.

2011: Niall predicts double-digit inflation for 2010s. Logical conclusion: short Treasuries, corporate bonds and stocks, buy gold. If anybody acted this way, s/he should be bankrupt by now.

My advice to Niall and anybody else making economic forecasts: put your money where your mouth is. And we'll see how it works.