Moby Waller's  Instablog

Moby Waller
Send Message
Moby Waller is a former CBOE Market Maker floor trader and off the floor London-based European Index Options Trader. He now works with and is a Research Analyst and Portfolio Manager for's ETF TRADR (, which provides... More
My company:
My blog:
BigTrends Blog
  • Has AAPL Reached A Long-Term Peak? 0 comments
    Oct 5, 2012 8:40 AM | about stocks: MSFT, T, VZ, AAPL

    What Every Apple Investor Should Know

    "In a recent piece I made the case that Apple's maps fiasco wouldn't hurt its stock. I was wrong. Since the map flap, Apple's stock (NASDAQ:AAPL) has not only slipped, but underperformed the S&P 500 (SPX) (NYSEARCA:SPY) and the Nasdaq composite (COMP).

    Turns out 'Mapgate', while likely a blip in Apple's history, stirred a much bigger conversation that points to vulnerabilities and concerns every Apple investor should, in the least, ponder: Apple may finally have just struck that point that all fast-growing companies hit-where its phones and operating system are so good they can't really technologically leapfrog themselves in a meaningful way.

    When that happens, as Apple just learned (and Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT), years earlier), customers are unwilling to accept inferior function over form; it's almost like a violation of an intangible trust.

    All of that smacks of a rapidly maturing smartphone market, in which price eventually starts to matter, raising questions about a vulnerability not yet seen: The prospect that Apple could lose pricing power, especially its ability to wring out a premium subsidy from wireless carriers like Verizon (NYSE:VZ) and AT&T (NYSE:T)? Right now, carriers subsidize more than half the cost of an iPhone.

    "People realize there is only so much you can do to incrementally make improvements," says Walter Piecyk, the BTIG analyst and longtime Apple bull who caused a stir last April when he had the nerve to downgrade Apple. As a result, he told me yesterday, "the phones are technologically closer than they used to be."

    The real line in the sand, many watchers believe, is if and when Verizon says it won't pay a premium subsidy for the iPhone.
    Piecyk warned of as much in his April downgrade, when he wrote:

    "Wireless operators have been happy to subsidize smartphones to new and existing customers in order to provide a lift to the average monthly bill of their customer base, a metric which had been falling for the past three decades."

    But that happened at the expense of their own profitability. Verizon recently started trying to counter the cost of subsidies (and perhaps providing a preview of what may come next) by taking it out of the hide of customers by shifting to a-la carte data plans and a $30 upgrade fee on discounted smartphones.

    The next step, a growing chorus of watchers believe, will come at the expense of phone makers, starting with the premium subsidy Apple gets for the iPhone.

    And if that happens, will Apple be forced to lower the price of the iPhone? Or will it expect consumers to pay a bigger share? And if so, will they?

    Asked about the carrier issue on Apple's July earnings call, CEO Tim Cook seemed unconcerned.

    "From the carrier's perspective I think it's also important to remember that the total subsidy that they pay is fairly small relative to the monthly payments that they collect over a 24-month contract period," he said. "And I think many would tell you, they certainly told me, that iPhone has several advantages for them over other smartphones. The churn rates are much less. You see carriers now focusing on shared data plans and I think an iPhone customer is likely more-is more likely to have a tablet or an iPad, and so I think they really value these customers quite a bit."

    And for Apple's sake, and the sake of investors counting on the stock to continue to move higher-and stay at new heights-they had better continue to do so.

    Lost in the euphoria over Apple by many casual investors is this: For all of the talk about how the iPhones feed the Apple ecosystem, the iPhone drives Apple's sales and profits, generating roughly half of sales and, according to analysts, as much of two-thirds of operating profits, if not more.

    In other words, as goes the pricing of the iPhone, so goes Apple.

    Oh, and yes: The iPad mini is expected to be rolled out soon with a smaller screen and lower price. If nothing else it's expected lower price will be proof that Apple can't sustain a premium price in an increasingly competitive space.

    Which gets to the moral of this story, and the one thing investors should never forget: As great as Apple may be, it's still merely mortal.

    P.S.: When it comes to Apple's stock, the next six months could be critical. When its first quarter is reported in early January investors should get a better handle on how well the iPhone 5 did (or didn't.) The iPad mini will have been rolled out, and we'll see whether it generated considerably more new customers or cannibalized its existing base. And there should start to be chatter about the iPhone 5s, or an equivalent new model, and whether it has enough new technology to spark widespread customer interest, even among the fanboys.

    Also keep an eye on talk about mid-level employee defections - another sign of a maturing company.

    Finally, be leery of Apple splitting its stock. That would be an indication that the company is running low on its operating arsenal to keep its shares elevated. It doesn't mean Piper Jaffray's Gene Munster won't be right - and Apple's shares won't hit $1,000, on the next wave of iPhone 5 news. But if and when they do the ultimate question arises: Can they stay there?
    You can't help but love the drama (unless, of course, you're an investor!)"

    Courtesy of Herb Greenberg,

    [Moby Waller from Taking a look at the AAPL Daily Chart below, you can see that it has backed off the $700 recently -- however, it previously backed off after reaching above $600, only to resume another uptrend. Note that the slope of the rally from late-2011 to April 2012 has lowered during the most recent rally. The second chart shows a couple of key Fibonacci Retracement levels should AAPL pull back further or go into a wide trading range: 616 is a 50% retracement of the May low to the recent September high -- while more dramatic 50% retracements of the late-2011 low to the April high and September high would be 503 and 534.]

    AAPL Daily Chart with Bollinger Bands, Acceleration Bands, Exponential Moving Averages & Percent R

    (click to enlarge)

    AAPL Daily Chart with Fibonacci Retracement From Key Highs & Lows

    (click to enlarge)

    Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

    Stocks: MSFT, T, VZ, AAPL
Back To Moby Waller's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »

Latest Comments

Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.