It was interesting the muted market reaction to July 2013 New Home Sales Were Really Bad. It seems like everyone and their brother is blaming it on climbing mortgage rates. Please prove this to me.
Pundits like to put a face on every data point - whether they have proof or do not have proof. You hear it daily, "the market went up because ....." I would love to be the source of these one line reasons.
Here is what one can prove:
- New home sales are likely one of the worst data series pumped out by US Census. A data point is revised up one month, and the same data point is revised down the next month.
- This data series is not produced from hard data - up one month, down the next. It is a survey.
- The growth in this series peaked early in 2013, and has been on a gentle "less good" trend since (red line is 3 month moving average on Figure 1).
Figure 1 - Year-over-Year Growth for New Home Sales (blue line), 3 month rolling average of Growth for New Home Sales (red line)
Ok - mortgage rates increasing are not a positive dynamic. But in perspective, the increase is not significant.
Figure 2 - 30 Year Conventional Mortgage Rate
So here are all the possibilities of dynamics which could be effecting new home sales - please add to this list:
- increasing mortgage rates;
- existing homes provide better pricing points;
- it is just noise in the data - we will know the "truth" in a few months;
- the economy is cooling;
- income is not keeping up with spending and inflation - or the recent improvements in home prices;
The Econintersect economic forecast for August 2013 again declined, and sees the economy barely expanding. The concern is that consumers are spending a historically high amount of their income, and several non-financial indicators are struggling or flat.
The ECRI WLI growth index value has been weakly in positive territory for over four months - but in a noticeable improvement trend. The index is indicating the economy six month from today will be slightly better than it is today.Current ECRI WLI Growth Index
Initial unemployment claims rose from 320,000 (reported last week) to 336,000 this week. Historically, claims exceeding 400,000 per week usually occur when employment gains are less than the workforce growth, resulting in an increasing unemployment rate.
The real gauge - the 4 week moving average - improved from 332,000 (reported last week) to 330,500. Because of the noise (week-to-week movements from abnormal events AND the backward revisions to previous weeks releases), the 4-week average remains the reliable gauge.Weekly Initial Unemployment Claims - 4 Week Average - Seasonally Adjusted - 2011 (red line), 2012 (green line), 2013 (blue line)
Bankruptcies this Week: Cengage Learning, Personal Communications Devices, OnCure Holdings, Florida Gaming
Data released this week which contained economically intuitive components (forward looking) were:
- Rail movements growth trend is currently accelerating.
- There are some forward looking trends in the CFNAI which improved.
All other data released this week either does not have enough historical correlation to the economy to be considered intuitive, or is simply a coincident indicator to the economy.Weekly Economic Release Scorecard:
- It Rained Today - Blame It on Obamacare
- Two 200% Rallies Have Taken Place Off This Line
- Automobile Still King of the American Commute
- Margin Debt at Worrisome Levels
- Infographic of the Day: Interesting Facts on Lightning
- Thoughts on Macroeconomic Theory and Practice
- 60% of Porn Websites Are Hosted in the United States
- Investing.com Weekly Wrap-Up 23 August 2013
- Markets Sell Off During Last Minute
- What We Read Today 23 August 2013
- Markets Remarkable Recovery On Terrible Home Sales Data
- 16 August 2013: ECRI's WLI Growth Again Declines Marginally
- Manning Trial: Behind the Scenes
- Markets Open Up, Correct To Yesterday's Close
- July 2013 New Home Sales Were Really Bad
- Growth in Spending per Beneficiary in the Fee-for-Service Portion of Medicare Has Slowed
- All Chart Gaps are Not Created Equal
- Summer Fun for Precious Metals Investors
- The Worst Jobs Report in Four Months Does One Thing
- UK Car Sales Show Signs of Recovery After Downturn
- Investing.com: Technical Analysis 22 August 2013
- Melissa's Revenge: Yahoo! Traffic Topped Google in July
- Infographic of the Day: Most Earth-like Exoplanet Discovery Explained
- Virtual Fallibility
- San Francisco Has the Most Active Start-Up Scene
- Industrial Production Confirmed Economic Slowdown In July As Stocks Bubbled
- What We Read Today 22 August 2013
- Averages Close Higher After NASDAQ Reopening
- Rail Week Ending 17 August 2013: Continued Improvement in Growth Rate
- Markets Slide Mostly Sideways, FOMC Could Crash The Party
- Kansas City Fed: Manufacturing Activity Stronger Growth in August 2013
- July 2013 Coincident Indicator Review: Philly Fed USA Coincident Index Continues to Show Economic Growth
- How Metadata is Mega-dangerous
- Markets Open Up Melt Higher On Moderate Volume
- July 2013 Leading Economic Index Growth Slightly Above Expectations
- Household Income Down by 4.4% Overall Post Recession
- 17 August 2013 Unemployment Claims 4 Week Average Improvement Continues
- Stratfor: Unprecedented Demographic Problem Takes Shape in China
- China: PMI Surges
- Democratic Imperialism
- Europe: Revival for Economy and Markets
- Can New Consoles Revive the Ailing Gaming Industry?
- Shadow Labor Supply: Implications for the Unemployment Rate
- Infographic of the Day: Nachos 101
- Tough Choices For Hollande This Autumn
- Consumers Vulnerable as Oil Earnings Flourish
- There are Good Reasons Why Interest Rates Won't Rise
- More Americans Than Ever Want an Outright Smoking Ban
- What Caused the Recession of 1937-38?
- Markets Crash On FOMC Minutes, No Wait It Rises, No Wait It Crashes - Again
- What We Read Today 21 August 2013
- Trucking Tonnage Soft in July 2013
- July 2013 FOMC Meeting Minutes: The Economy Seems Disappointing
- Markets Down, Quiet And Directionless
- Swiss Government Pimping Out 'Sex Boxes'
- July 2013 Existing Home Sales 'Spiked'
- Markets Gap Down At Opening - Investors Await FOMC Minutes
- Nonfinancial Leverage NFCI Deteriorates Marginally w/e 16August 2013
- Creating a History of U.S. Inflation Expectations
- Krugman's Flawed Model of Open Market Operations
- Housing Smoke and Mirrors (15) - 'Re-tuning the HARP'
- New Artifical Heart Transplant Options
- Bhide: The Next Fed Chief Should be "Boring"
- Investing.com: Technical Analysis 20 August 2013
- Inequality Will Crush Growth
- Infographic of the Day: Alpha Centauri Stars and Planet Explained - Our Nearest Neighbors
- Economic Impacts of Changes in Energy Production
- Stiglitz: Ignorance is Hampering Monetary Policy
- The Rise of IPTV is Hurting Cable Companies
- Cramer's Miss on The Corporate - Economic Relationship
- What We Read Today 20 August 2013
- Bears Take Over Closing Market
- Morning Averages Take A Breather At Noon On Falling Volume
- Spying Stepwise: NSA abuse 'Huge' As Agency Revels In Terror Powers
- Are Higher Haircuts Better?
- Markets Open Down Then Rise On Moderate Volume
- CFNAI Super Index Shows Economy Again Improved In July 2013
- Stratfor: European Jihadists - The Continuation of a Historical Trend
- The Only "Crash Talk" Worth Trading
- The Middle Class Squeeze
- Violent Oversold Reaction Continues in Gold Market
- Week Ending 19 August 2013: 1.1 Cent Gasoline Price Fall
- Will a Flying Car Finally 'Make the Grade'?
- The Dramatic Devaluation of American Newspapers
- New Green Automotive Technology for 2014
- Does the Recent Decline in the Unemployment Rate Reflect An Improving Labor Market?
- Bitcoin Bites: Germany recognizes digital currency as 'private money'
- When Should You Pay Attention to the Hindenburg Omen?
- Strong Improvement In Initial Unemployment Claims Gives Fed Excuse To Taper
- The Urbanization Fallacy
- U.S. Business Credit Quality Continues to Improve
- Insider Trading 16 August 2013: Kinder Morgan Director Buying
- The Judgment of Lenox - Box Wines Taste Best
- Spying Trash Cans Raise Privacy Fears
- The Week Ahead: Are Rising Interest Rates a Barrier?
- Terminal Velocity (18) 'Fed Historiography'
- Free Markets: Just What the Doctor Ordered
- Behind Barricades: Cairo Mosque Under Siege, Turned Into Morgue
- Postmortem: Retail Sales
- Get Well Soon...America!!
- Some Sign of Life for Sea Container Counts in July 2013
- States Rally To Break Up Big Banks
- Preliminary August 2013 Michigan Consumer Sentiment Disappoints
- Productivity 2Q2013 (Preliminary): Productivity Up, Costs Up More
- Residential Building Sector Growth Continues in July 2013 and Above Expectations
- German Politicians of Two Main Parties Agree: Low Interest Rates Bad
- Prometheus: Violent Oversold Reaction Continues in Gold Market
- France Misrepresents Its Unemployment Rate as They Appear at Eurostat!
- The American Revolution 2.0 has begun
- August 2013 Philly Fed Business Outlook Continues to Show Expansion
- Correctly Assessing Chinese Leaders and American Presidents
- Redefining Base Money
- As Wages and Hours Stagnate and Lag Inflation, Fed Declares Victory and Goes
Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.