Violent Capitalist's  Instablog

Violent Capitalist
Send Message
approaches usually lead him to more volatile parts of the market, smaller caps, and foreign companies that aren't as widely researched.
My blog:
  • Is Seagate Buyout a Steal for Private Equity? 0 comments
    Oct 15, 2010 10:52 AM | about stocks: STX, WDC, MU

    Seagate is cheap. It's a cyclical stock, one that is still mired in uncertainty due to the commodity nature of its business, the struggles with a fast growth competitor in Western Digital, a new CEO, the cyclicality of storage/hardware business, and now valuation since the whispers of a buyout offer. Nevertheless, it does mean that Seagate is worth only $16/share. And especially not to a consortium of private equity firms that can raise money at rates of 6% to buy the company out. If the new CEO (Luczo) is looking for a quick payout, I'd be extremely surprised that an ex-Sr Managing Director of Bear Stearns Technology Group and a tenured history at Seagate since 1993, will make him devoid of the true valuation of a company like Seagate.

    First off, normalized earnings for a Seagate is about $1 billion. I've accounted for the fact that 2010 was stronger than usual and that they currently are not paying any taxes. Some #'s for my valuation:

    D&A = $800mil
    Capex = $625mil
    OCF = $1.8 billion (my definition is NI + D&A)
    FCF = $1.175 billion
    Invested Capital = $3.05billion
    Cash Flow ROIC = 39%

    Cash = $2.5billion
    Debt = $2.5billion

    Market cap at $16 is $8billion. Since net debt is 0, the enterprise value for Seagate is also $8billion. FCF yield on a valuation of $8billion is 14.7%. That is nuts when you can borrow to buyout a firm at 6% interest rates! In my opinion, this yield should be about 10%, or a valuation of $11billion and $22/share. I also highlighted the ROIC #, mostly because its just insane for a hardware company. The thing is about hard drives, is that its now an oligopoly business run by a few dominant firms (Seagate, Western Digital the runaway leaders). This allows for lower capex investments - which is awesome for any LBO-er by the way - and creates this high ROIC #. If you want a comparison, take a look at semiconductor companies where there are a much larger # of firms competing. Routinely, their ROIC #'s come in at around 20-40% lower and they are probably more cyclical, yet have valuation multiples that are generally higher (Micron Technology would be an example of a lower ROIC operation with a similar valuation). It really makes no sense, and is why I bought into Seagate at prices of around $13/share.

    Now the argument may be that the offer price for Seagate is fair because it matches the multiples of Western Digital. That's all fine and mighty - except Western Digital is cheap too. The buyout consortium has simply made them both equally attractive at Seagate's current price of $15/share.

    My advice: hold firm for an offer above $20. At this price, buyout firms will still be able to make a 20-25% annualized return by my estimates.

    Current price: $15
    Conservative fair value: $22, 50% higher from current price
    Strategy: Sell November puts at strike $14 for $.55, a yield of almost 4% in one month, or even buy shares outright for this one!


    Disclosure: Long STX
    Stocks: STX, WDC, MU
Back To Violent Capitalist's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • most suck, some are good, stick to the facts, mean reversion persists in the long run
    Apr 15, 2009
More »

Latest Comments

Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.