Dan Plettner's  Instablog

Dan Plettner
Send Message
Dan Plettner invests and licenses his own real time trading data to Covestor Ltd. Dan previously licensed his written content to DealFlow Media, for the Closed-End Fund Alert. Dan focuses his qualitative investigative research methods on Closed-End Funds and other underfollowed securities. His... More
My company:
Dan Plettner Covestor Profile Page
My blog:
Dan Plettner Closed-End Fund Blog
  • Grading my out-of-consensus DWS RREEF Funds Call: Second Liquidation Vote Prevails 0 comments
    Jan 29, 2010 3:56 PM | about stocks: SRO, SRQ

    At the close of business on August 20th, DWS RREEF Real Estate II (SRO) traded at $0.75 per share, a 20.21% discount to the fund’s Net Asset Value (“NAV”). A first effort to liquidate the Fund had failed and the market discount reflected great doubt that a second effort could have different results.

    On the morning of August 21st, my article predicting a successful second vote was published here at Seeking Alpha. On that day, the discount narrowed slightly to a 17.53%. Last week, my prediction proved accurate, lending to a converged discount and market closing price of $1.20, approximately 60% higher than prices August 20th.

    Reader comments were not consistently in agreement with my call. One reader demonstrated doubt as to where 5 million additional liquidation votes may come from. My responses dated August 21st noted “DWS did not really employ a significant solicitation strategy for either fund last time” and “they are committed now… it is in all shareholders best interest to adjourn a meeting to solicit additional votes.” It was necessary to adjourn the meeting and my anticipation of soliciting for additional votes also proved accurate.

    Accuracy and reasoned color of my prediction had even broader implications. In my piece, I wrote:

    In the case of SRO, voting polled more than 2-to-1 in favor of liquidation. The writing is clearly on the wall, and everybody can now read it. Those who desired reassigning advisory fees to liquidation were never foolish; they were acting in their own unique interests. All shareholders will now recognize that SRO's contracts will never be reassigned. Even the uniquely motivated shareholders who wanted to redirect assets under management fees to certain related private companies are not so foolish to vote against liquidation this time.

    In demonstration of rational reasoning, the voting block which previously had publicly opposed liquidation on both funds, and which represented a large voting block on sister fund DWS RREEF Real Estate(SRQ) entered into a cooperation and voting agreement, and SRQ too achieved a liquidation vote.

    I have had little doubt to the accuracy of my prediction and the greatest risk to timely liquidation in my perception has been lawsuits naming the Fund Companies themselves as defendant.  Today's announcements of liquidation voting results included some relevant text:

    “The Fund also announced that it has been removed as a defendant in a previously disclosed class action lawsuit filed in the Southern District of New York, on behalf of certain Fund stockholders, alleging various securities law disclosure violations. Accordingly, the lawsuit is not currently expected to delay or otherwise affect the Fund’s liquidation and dissolution. The Fund's investment adviser, sub-adviser, and certain Fund officers are still named as defendants in the lawsuit.”

    I have no idea whether my direct words toward attorneys who brought cases against the Fund companies themselves made any impact on the removal. Yes, I did contribute my perceptions.

    The takeaway from the entire SRO and SRQ liquidation scenario is not who was right or who was wrong. Rather, the takeaway is that Closed-End Funds can present extraordinary market inefficiencies. My highest conviction holding for 2010 is a Closed-End Fund, AWP.  My thesis on AWP was recently disclosed on a limited basis here at Seeking Alpha.

    Disclosure: Long SRO, SRQ, and AWP
    Stocks: SRO, SRQ
Back To Dan Plettner's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • Closed Long Position in CFP today. Short CRF and CLM.
    Apr 9, 2010
  • For inverse reasons of wanting to own AWP (attractive valuation and probability of dividend increases), I have not wanted to own AOD or AGD
    Feb 5, 2010
  • Ignore everything around you and maybe you too can be on Bloomberg TV: http://tinyurl.com/lzwy6j
    Jul 7, 2009
More »
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.