Tim Ayles'  Instablog

Tim Ayles
Send Message
We strive to build highly disciplined, sensible client portfolios. Portfolios that are focused on investing in businesses with solid free cash flows and solid dividend payouts. We buy businesses, not stocks. Tim is a Registered Investment Advisor.
My company:
Napa Wealth Management, Incorporated
  • Saving the Banks - Conspiracy Style 2 comments
    Aug 27, 2009 10:41 PM

    I realize this may sound like a nut job conspiracy theory, but I am just thinking out loud and wanting to document when this was thought of.

    Maybe, just maybe, the fed is inflating the banks through stock market gains. Stay with me before writing me off as a quack.

    On August 26th, Kate Berry from American Banker wrote an article titled "Postponing the Day of Reckoning" In it she stated:

    Banks also "are allowing borrowers to be delinquent for longer and longer periods of time before initiating foreclosures"

    This absolutely jives with what I see on the street. I have two close friends who haven't paid their mortgage in 10 and 13 months. Yet, they don't hear anything from their lenders.

    Is this because the banks don't want to book these non-paying loans as losses? The article continues:

    Tom Booker, a senior vice president in the default information unit at First American Corp. in Santa Ana, Calif., concurred. "There are borrowers who are six or eight months in default; they may have exhausted their workout options; but they're put on a forbearance plan because it's an interim to a final resolution, which is foreclosure," he said. "Banks don't want to take the losses now."

    Darrell Duffie, a finance professor at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business, said accounting rules give banks plenty of leeway to determine when to take losses.

    "Banks are believed to be carrying a lot of loans at accounting levels well above their true market value," he said. "But once a property goes into foreclosure, their options have disappeared."

    So the banks aren't realizing the losses, and they're doing nothing about it. People live in their homes for free, the bank loses thousands of dollars per client in interest income, but they are saved because they don't have to write off hundreds of thousands per non-payer in losses. Thus they preserve their capital ratios and allow them to live another day. Brilliant! (tongue in cheek) And scary!!!!!

    So here is a conspiracy scenario:

    1. Banks make bad loans and are crushed when the market tanks.

    2. Fed Prints money and gives to banks to keep them afloat.

    3. Banks don't write down loan losses, so their capital is not hurt, but lose interest income from borrowers not paying their mortgage.

    4. Banks need to earn an income to stay in business and "earn" their way out of these massive loan losses.

    5. Banks trading units "invest" in securities and the market and the market ramps non stop, thus offsetting lost revenue from loans with trading revenue.

    6. Banks eventually sell and leave investors holding the bag, thus getting their money anyway from the masses whom they lent money.

    I know - sounds crazy. But today I just read this from the UK Telegraph:

    Mr. Steinbruck said the markets are awash with liquidity again, but little is going into the real economy. "The banks evidently prefer to put their money into securities rather then granting new loans because they can get a higher return. After two years of financial crises the gambler mentality is gaining the upper hand again."

    The German authorities are deeply frustrated that so few banks have resorted to the resuce scheme to rebuild their capital base. Critics say the Bundestag imposed such stringent conditions that the lenders have opted instead to rein in lending.


    Does this not sound similar to what could be happening here? I know it's a black helicopter/conspiracy theory, but it seems the Feds and US are desperate to do something to change the reality they currently face. What better way to save the financial system than by bailing out the banks and not forcing them to write off bad loans after 180 days like GAAP requires. Instead, let them gamble in securities, and maybe even stocks? It will be interesting to see how well the trading units of the big banks do in the next few quarters.

    If this "highly unlikely" scenario is true, the banks will sell, have the cash they need to write off the massive loans, but will have sucked the money out of unsuspecting investors pockets. In the end - they will have won. They will have gotten the US investor, pensions, and retirement accounts to bailout their bad loans, and we can't get mad at the government because it didnt commit more taxpayer money to bailout more losses. Instead, asset price increases, and then selling those assets to investors, bailed them out. Or better put - investors "bailed" them out.

    Unlikely........ but interesting to ponder, no?

    I have wondered how my friends can live payment free for over a year. This theory could be a reason, even though it seems unlikely.

    In either event - remain cautious, and keep an eye on those bank trading profits.


Back To Tim Ayles' Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (2)
Track new comments
  • Tom Au, CFA
    , contributor
    Comments (6879) | Send Message
    Banks are not to be trusted. We were taught that at an early age.
    28 Aug 2009, 11:03 AM Reply Like
  • Don/Pseudonym
    , contributor
    Comments (3) | Send Message
    Looks good. I was with a few friends the other day and it was amazing as each one could count 5 people that they know that stopped paying their mortgage months ago. One got a letter from the bank after not paying for 6 months and was afraid he was getting kicked out. Turns out it was a warning that if he didn't take action in the next 6 months they would take action against him. He laughed. Some have bought their new cars etc. knowing that they are not going to be able to finance anything for the next few years and quit paying their mortgage.
    3 Sep 2009, 02:38 PM Reply Like
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »

Latest Comments

Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.