Seeking Alpha

Sean Bellamy Mc...'s  Instablog

Sean Bellamy McNulty
Send Message
Sean is a FOREX Trader at CIBC World Markets on Bay Street. In terms of education, Sean has a Bachelor of Commerce Degree with a Major in Finance and Minor in Economics from the Sauder School of Business at the University of British Columbia, and while earning his degree he participated in... More
My book:
The Campaign for the Rational Mind
  • Is The USDJPY Head And Shoulders Pattern Legit? 0 comments
    Feb 16, 2013 1:07 AM | about stocks: FXY

    The USDJPY (NYSEARCA:FXY) has been the talk of the town as of late. Soros pulled in over $1bn in profits, Kyle Bass has been all over it from the beginning, I'm sure it's making up for a lot of the losses on Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) in the hedge fund world. I've managed to make a bit of money in the trade a few weeks ago, but have largely missed the move thus far. The question is how more run does this trade have?

    The chart for the USDJPY recently formed a head and shoulders chart pattern, which is thought to be a bearish sign.

    (click to enlarge)

    I'm not a technical trader, but in my view it is worth being aware of technicals, as they become self-fulfilling prophecies. There are enough technicians on trading floors around the world that if an obvious technical level or pattern shows up in a chart, whether there is any fundamental reason or not for a price level, the technicians money flowing into the position causes the technical indicator to ring true. This turns into a self-reinforcing feedback loop, which is why there are so many technical traders around the world today.

    With an average holding period of 5 days, I'm mainly trade slightly longer term swings in currencies that brings more fundamentals into play, as they will ultimately drive longer term trends. Of these indicators, I use both macroeconomic data as well as market based data. Of the market based indicators, I've found the FX Options market price action being some of the most informative. The FX Option markets is dominated by hedge funds, investment banks and other professional traders, so it is often a good indicator of where the "smart money" is at.

    The FX Option Market's Take on USDJPY

    In the FX Option market, I look at option volatility prices and risk reversal prices.

    The option volatility prices is an indicator of demand, thus the higher the option volatility, the higher the price of the options. Given my trading time frame, I keep an eye on the 1 month option volatility. The higher the volatility, the more interest in options 1 month out, the more potential for a move either to the upside or downside.

    The risk reversal prices are the price of calls versus puts at a given level of delta. Without getting too deep into derivatives, essentially what this indicator shows is whether call options or put options are being bought up in greater quantity. Mathematically, it is the price of a call option at 25 delta minus the price of put option at 25 delta. Therefore, if the number is positive, calls are more expensive than puts, if it is negative, puts are more expensive than calls.

    Between the option volatility and the risk reversal prices, you get a clear picture of what the pros are setting up for.

    Below is a chart with the 1 month USDJPY price (blue shaded section), the 1 month option volatility (yellow line), the 3 month option volatility (red line) and the 1 month risk reversal (purple line):

    (click to enlarge)

    As you can see option volatility has been increasing steadily over the past month, indicating more options being bought and sold, and in the past week, the amount of puts being purchased as increased dramatically. This could be driven by traders protecting gains with the purchase of puts, or speculation that the currency will fall. Either way, the smart money, consistent with the head and shoulders pattern, is setup also setting up for a fall in the USDJPY (a strengthening of the Yen).

    On the 6 month chart this becomes even more apparent, with option volatility growing exponentially and risk reversals hitting their lowest point in the past 6 months:

    (click to enlarge)

    Finally, on the 1 year chart, the risk reversals price is shown to be touching levels not seen since last September, but at the same time it is worth noting that they haven't touched levels seen in the summer of 2011, which was the last time the USDJPY rallied to the mid 80s range and subsequently sold off back to the mid 70s range.

    (click to enlarge)

    The Bank of Japan

    The Bank of Japan (BOJ) has seen its assets grow substantially along with the rise in the USDJPY, but this isn't a new trend. Below is a 20 year chart, a 1 year chart and a 6 month chart of the BOJ Balance Sheet Assets (blue shaded region) with the USDJPY exchange rate (yellow line).

    (click to enlarge)

    (click to enlarge)

    (click to enlarge)

    Most interestingly is that in a long term sense, the BOJ has had assets at this level before back in March of 2006. As aggressive as the recent buying may seem, by all appearances the BOJ has a long way to go before they are in completely uncharted waters. Therefore, I don't see them as being gun shy at this point.

    What I find most compelling about the BOJ story is that they are not targeting an FX exchange rate, as the BOJ Governor Masaaki Shirakawa pointed out this past Thursday, but rather an inflation rate. Without commenting on the wisdom of this move, this makes the USDJPY extreme exchange rate move a largely moot point in the BOJ's eyes, as they are dedicated to the 2% inflation target. Not only does this rhetoric make this politically possible on the world stage, but it suggests that until the inflation rate in Japan reaches the 2% number, the USDJPY has plenty of room to move.

    The Retail Traders

    The last indicator, and one of my favorites, is retailer trader positions, what I call my "Pauly Michaels Indicator". The sad fact is that 80% of retail FOREX traders lose money, therefore being on the other side of their trade is often a wise move. OANDA, my broker and a first class operator, publishes their book in real time allowing you to see the sentiment in the retail market.

    Below are charts from OANDA's historical position ratios. I've broken out 1 year, 1 month and 1 week charts, with the blue indicating a net long position, orange indicating a net short, and the black line being the USDJPY exchange rate.

    (click to enlarge)
    (click to enlarge)
    (click to enlarge)

    These three charts demonstrate the power of this tool. Looking at the 1 year chart (the top chart), you see all through 2012 retail traders were extremely bullish on the Yen as it trended down to 75. Then, during its recent rally, the one I presume they were all been waiting for, rather than profiting from the massive upswing that they had been waiting for all year, the retail traders go net short, missing out on the move from 83 to 94, while Soros picked up his 1 billion. That is what separates the pros from the amateurs.

    Looking at the USDJPY trade now, I find it concerning that the retail side of the trade has moved to a net long position, but encouraging that it is not nearly the ratio is was throughout 2012. Also, in with retail traders selling off their position in the past week, I see this as a good sign as now being potentially a good time for an entry point.

    The Bottom Line and the Trade

    I`ve been long the USDJPY since February 13th, and am essentially at break even in the position thus far. After conducting this analysis, I`m slightly more concerned for the downside, especially seeing as how the FX Option market has moved, but at the same time find it encouraging the retail traders have sold off this past week.

    The overriding factor is the BOJ`s inflation target. As long as that is the BOJ`s main focus, I don`t see USDJPY at 94 being the top end for the move, despite the technicals and the positioning in the retail and FX options markets. The fact that the BOJ has had their balance sheet at this level of assets before is also encouraging, as they`ll be much less hesitant to expand it further given this historical context. Of course, there is a point where the BOJ will be hesitant in expanding the balance sheet further, but we haven`t hit that yet.

    In conclusion, depending on the open Sunday afternoon (the open of the FOREX market in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada), I may exit my USDJPY position, as this head and shoulders may be legit. With retail traders becoming more bullish, and the smart money largely going negative, this doesn't appear to be the best entry point. That being said, long term, I don't see 94 being the top end, and will likely buy back in when conditions are more favorable.

    Disclosure: I am short FXY. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

    Themes: short-ideas Stocks: FXY
Back To Sean Bellamy McNulty's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers

StockTalks

  • Packed theater in Toronto for Hunger Games last night, next HG movie to be packed as well given the cliffhanger ending $LGF
    Nov 25, 2013
  • The Final Weekly Newsletter from McNulty Capital Management http://eepurl.com/CkD79
    Jul 15, 2013
  • Weekly Newsletter from McNulty Capital Management http://eepurl.com/B1kaD
    Jul 8, 2013
More »

Latest Comments


Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.