Seeking Alpha

Erik McCurdy's  Instablog

Erik McCurdy
Send Message
Erik is the senior market technician for Prometheus Market Insight and has been performing chart analysis since 1995. The software program that he developed to monitor long-term stock market trends has correctly identified 92% of the cyclical turning points in the S&P 500 index since 1940.... More
My company:
Prometheus Market Insight
My blog:
Prometheus Market Insight
  • Addressing The Structural Deficiencies Of Our Economy 1 comment
    Nov 20, 2012 6:52 PM

    There has been a great deal of talk about the "fiscal cliff" recently. However, like most mainstream conversations during the last few years, the discussion fails to get to the core of the problem facing our economy. The primary impediment to the initiation of the next structural growth cycle is our massive amount of private and public debt. Unfortunately, we have entered the realm of "excessive" debt, as defined by Reinhart and Rogoff in their excellent book This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, and we will not have a solid foundation for the next long-term economic growth cycle until this mountain of debt is addressed in a meaningful way.



    (click to enlarge)

    The deleveraging process has begun, but we have a long way to go before anything resembling a healthy state is achieved. It will take many years to fix this problem. Although the mainstream view acknowledges that the debt issue is something that needs to be addressed, very few understand (or are willing to acknowledge) the magnitude of the problem. Until we collectively recognize both the type and the scale of this challenge, structural economic health will remain elusive and it will continue to await us many years in the future. In his latest weekly commentary, fund manager John Hussman discussed the excessive debt problem, along with our options moving forward.

    The holes [in the proverbial debt dam] seem only loosely related: non-performing mortgages, widespread unemployment, massive U.S. budget deficits, a "fiscal cliff" sideshow, inadequate European bank capital, European currency strains, a surge of non-performing loans in China, and unexpected economic softness in Asia and global trade more generally. All of this gives the impression that these problems can simply be addressed one-by-one. The truth is that they are all intimately related to a single central issue, which is the utter unwillingness of politicians around the globe to accept and proceed with the inevitable restructuring of bad debt, and their preference to defend the bondholders of a fundamentally rotted financial system.

    But haven't things improved? No doubt, bank balance sheets have been relieved of transparency through changes in accounting rules. Nonperforming loans have been easy to kick down the road thanks to an interminable "amend and pretend" process whereby a month or two of mortgage service is exchanged for extensions that tack delinquent payments onto the back of the loans. Meanwhile, banks have recouped some of their losses through wider interest spreads, by refusing to refinance higher interest mortgages, and by paying lower interest costs as a result of monetary policies that provide zero interest compensation to savers.

    But aside from the appropriate equity wipeout, debt writedown, contract renegotiation and reissuance of General Motors, very little debt restructuring has occurred anywhere else in the economy - certainly not in financial or mortgage debt. Meanwhile, the European banking system faces major capital inadequacies, particularly in Spain, where delinquent loans have surged to record highs. The Federal Reserve just altered its annual stress tests for too-big-to-fail banks to now include the risk of a slowdown in Asia. The U.S. budget deficit remains near a peacetime high, with little prospect of substantial reduction even if the so-called "fiscal cliff" is resolved. The European economy is clearly in a fresh recession. We continue to infer that the U.S. also entered a recession during the third quarter. This will not be helpful to deficit reduction efforts.

    Getting past the "fiscal cliff" is the comparatively easy part. What it requires is for both aisles of the U.S. political system to agree on a mutually acceptable (but likely still intolerably large) federal deficit. Whether this happens before December 31 or after is not terribly meaningful because there is not an irreversible outcome on that date. So whatever might happen automatically would be meaningless shortly thereafter anyway. There will likely be a combination of modest spending cuts, modest high-income tax increases, and limits on deductions for second homes. None of these will have a material impact on the size of the deficit. Despite the bluster, few in Congress really appear to see deficit reduction as important as their core interests, which for Democrats is to preserve spending and for Republicans is to maintain tax cuts. Some inadequate compromise seems probable, there will be a brief episode of joy and celebration by investors that they have been released from their chains, and shortly thereafter the data will remind us that the global economy is in recession, and that the U.S. economy entered a recession during the third quarter - well before Sandy was even on the weather map.

    Ultimately, three outcomes would improve the global economy more durably. The first would be a process of debt restructuring that might be highly disruptive over the intermediate-term, but would exert the costs of bad debt on the holders of that debt rather than the general public. My expectation is that a large portion of the European banking system will be restructured in the next few years - meaning receivership, a wipeout of equity value, a writedown of liabilities to bondholders, and an eventual recapitalization as the restructured entities are sold back to private ownership. It isn't clear that Spain or Italy will be forced to default, as long as Germany, Finland, and other relatively strong countries depart from the euro and allow the ECB to monetize as it pleases. Greece is a basket case in that it seems likely to default again regardless of whether the euro remains intact. In the U.S., efforts to create standardized, marketable mechanisms to restructure mortgage debt (e.g. debt-equity swaps such as marketable property appreciation rights in return for principal reductions) remain long overdue.

    It would also be advisable for the next Treasury Secretary to significantly extend the maturity of U.S. debt, because we are now too far along to resolve the U.S. debt burden through fiscal austerity alone, and some level of inflation will have to be tolerated in the back-half of this decade (and possibly beyond) to reduce the real burden. This can't be done if the debt is so short-term that the interest rate can be quickly reset to reflect inflation.

    A second beneficial outcome would be a realignment of the prices of financial assets to more adequately reflect risk, to provide an incentive to save, and to raise the bar on rates of return - so that investments with strong prospective returns are funded while those with low prospective returns are not. Probably nothing in the past 15 years has been as damaging to the interests of the global economy as the constant distortion of the financial markets by central banks, which has encouraged bubble after bubble, elevating speculation over the thoughtful allocation of scarce capital toward productive uses.

    Finally, we need innovation in new industries that have large employment effects. During periods of economic weakness, a common belief seems to emerge that the government can simply "get the economy moving again" through appropriately large spending packages - as if the economy is nothing but a single consumer purchasing a single good, and all that is required is to boost demand back to the prior level. In fact, however, recessions are periods where the mix of goods and services demanded becomes out of line with the mix of goods and services that the economy had previously produced. While fiscal subsidies can help to ease the transition by supporting normal cyclical consumption demand, the sources of mismatched supply - the objects of excessive optimism and misallocation such as dot-com ventures, speculative housing, various financial services, obsolete products, brick-and-mortar stores - generally don't come back. What brings economies back to long-term growth is the introduction of desirable new products and services that previously did not exist. This has been true throughout history, where the introduction of new products and industries - cars, radio, television, airlines, telecommunications, restaurant chains, electronics, appliances, computers, software, biotechnology, the internet, medical devices, and a succession of other innovations have been the hallmarks of long-term economic growth. Fiscal policies are part of the environment, but their effect should not be overstated.

    No stimulus package or tinkering with tax rates will produce growth in an economy as distorted by misguided monetary policy and unrestructured debt as our global economy has become. What is required is to restructure the burden of past errors, stop the recklessness and distortion of monetary policy, and allow the financial markets to adjust and clear, without safety nets, so that they both allocate capital toward productive investments and are allowed to punish misallocation. Then - deficit or no deficit - refrain from bleeding the patient, and do everything possible to encourage (private) and fully-fund (public) research, development, innovation, investment, and education.

    In my view, we are likely to experience some difficult disruptions in the global economy in the transition from an unsustainable economic environment to a sustainable one. Underneath the veneer of a relatively stable U.S. economy is the fact that government deficits presently support about 10% of that activity, the Fed has pushed the monetary base to the largest fraction of GDP in history, and financial assets have been driven to some of the lowest prospective returns ever observed. Absent unsustainable levels of government "stimulus," the present configuration of U.S. economic activity and asset pricing is also unsustainable. These policies have bought time, but we have done nothing with it, because somehow everyone has become convinced that the house of paper is real even though we all watched it being built.

    Themes: Economy
Back To Erik McCurdy's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (1)
Track new comments
  • SeekingTruth
    , contributor
    Comments (1329) | Send Message
    This good article is a mere introduction and hint of the the greater problems we face.
    We continue to complicate and confuse the causes with the effects, and the symptoms with the disease.
    The source and root of our worst problems are not entirely directly financially based but are nonetheless inextricably linked to our huge and unacceptable financial problems.
    We need a new and better approach to the fundamentals.
    This means a new US Constitution keeping the best of the old and improving on its omissions , deficiencies, and unacceptably vague approaches to some vital issues.


    Abolishing (preferred) or amending the Electoral College and initiating public financing of elections are a start and a mere beginning of this process.


    Is this a practical and achievable idea and goal?


    Possibly not, but if we don't do it relatively soon the misplaced and ill gotten concentration of power in a few hands is going to force us over a higher cliff than we are now facing financially.


    The signs are everywhere.
    20 Nov 2012, 08:04 PM Reply Like
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »

Latest Comments

Posts by Themes
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.