Seeking Alpha

J Mintzmyer's  Instablog

J Mintzmyer
Send Message
J Mintzmyer is a CFA candidate (testing Level 2) and investment enthusiast who utilizes Seeking Alpha to provide a free exchange of trading and investment ideas and to provide online visibility for his developing business. J is the Founder and President of Mintzmyer Investments LLC, a financial... More
My company:
Mintzmyer Investments LLC
My blog:
Mintzmyer Investments
  • How Reliable Has J Mintzmyer Been? Pt 4 0 comments
    Apr 8, 2012 7:47 PM | about stocks: BBY, DRYS, DCIX

    In January, I began my official Seeking Alpha "accountability audit" with a look back on my articles with a 6-month review. I include all of my articles and related recommendations and assume a $1000 investment in each position at the publishing date of each article. This is the fourth part of my "audit" which will include three positions that I have held for 6 months or longer.

    My Article Recommendation Results (in order of article from 14 September-9 October):

    I only included Focus stocks and all stocks included in list articles. I strongly frown upon the Seeking Alpha users who produce dime-a-dozen list articles and then cherry pick their winners, so I will stand by my lists and accept the total return. I will include comparisons of $1000 investment into each stock listed.

    Best Buy: $43 loss on BBY vs. gain of $176 in the S&P 500. Still long BBY.

    Diana Containerships: $382 return on DCIX vs. $236 total gain on S&P 500. Still long DCIX.

    Dry Ships: $446 return on DRYS vs. $210 total gain on S&P 500. Still long DRYS.

    My Total 6-mo Return (Articles from 15 Aug-25 Aug):

    $785 gain vs. S&P 500 gain of $622. Relative to $3000 "invested" à 26.17% gain in 6 months compared to S&P 500 gain of 20.73% // out performance of 5.44% in 6 months.

    Staying Honest:

    In this issue, I "defeated" the S&P 500; however, BBY was a huge miss in terms of stock performance. I believe that BBY offers the best upside in relation to these three picks, and I recently doubled my holdings. I have lost to the S&P 500 in earlier issues, primarily due to the weak shipping market, so it's nice to finally see some of these holdings making a comeback of sorts.

    I did not write many articles last fall so it will likely be a month or longer before I post another update on those positions.

    I currently recommend a buy on BBY, DCIX, and DRYS, but I have already covered all three of these in previous target updates. Therefore, in six months from now, I will have no further price updates since BBY (10 Feb), DCIX (24 Feb), and DRYS (23 Jan) are already being tracked.

    I will have $1000 long in GPS, CHN, IFN, GF, NM, DCIX and $1000 short in AMZN at February 24 closing prices.

    I will have $1000 long in EXM, BBY, HPQ, PRGN, ISH, NMM, ESEA, NAT, and EXC at Feb 10 closing prices.

    I will also have $1000 long in ARO, GME, DRYS, SBLK, MSFT, NOK and $1000 short in QLIK at Jan 23 closing prices.

    Disclosure: I am long BBY, DRYS, DCIX.

    Additional disclosure: I am long all of the recommended holdings.

Back To J Mintzmyer's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


  • $PLUG is such a disgusting sham stock- I'm blown away by the collective price support in the market. Just wait for the results...
    3 days ago
  • Just did some basic research on Campbell's $CPB due to curiosity. Wow, what a horrendously managed wreck the past decade!
    3 days ago
  • $15 puts expiring worthless on $BCOR. Lost a decent amount here. Wondering if the GCR report was garbage...?
    3 days ago
More »

Latest Comments

Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.