Anthony FJ Garner's  Instablog

Anthony FJ Garner
Send Message
Anthony Garner is a British national based in London. He left investment banking in 1992 in favour of a long cherished aim to work for himself and since 1995 has been trading financial markets for his own account, as well as having established, run or acted as consultant to a number of hedge... More
My company:
Malplaquet LLC
My blog:
Anthony FJ Garner
My book:
A Practical Guide to ETF Trading Systems
  • Where Are The Trends? 0 comments
    Apr 24, 2013 6:43 AM

    Where are the Trends?

    In his interesting research paper "Where are the Trends?" Martin Estlander seeks an answer as to why his trend program is in the worst drawdown in its history. Many traditional trend followers are in a similar situation.

    His answer is that the past two years have seen very few strong trends in the aggregate - at least as regards:

    1. His program's portfolio; and

    2. The 6 month trends which he seeks to capture.

    He sets out to show, graphically, the historic frequency of strong 6 month trends since his program's inception in 1992 using the following methodology:

    "Let us take a look at how the opportunities for trend following have been. There are many ways of measuring market trendiness. Here we choose a trend opportunity measure that counts the number of strong trends based on the return over the past six months from the highest high or lowest low to the current price, for each of the instruments. We then add relevant instruments for each market segment. A higher reading means that a larger number of meaningful trends have occurred and a lower reading means a lower number of aggregate number of meaningful trades over the past six months."

    I am not at all certain from this description how "strong trends" were measured for these purposes and so I decided to take a slightly different approach, which seems to have produced very similar results. I took a reasonably balanced portfolio of around 100 futures, some of them going back as far as 1970. I used ratio adjusted prices. For each day of the test, instruments which were at a 6 month highest high or a 6 month lowest low were assigned a score of "1"; else "0". For each day of the test, such scores were added together and the sum was divided by the number of instruments for which data existed on the relevant day. Thus expressing the number of instruments at 6 month highs or lows as a percentage of the total portfolio of instruments as it stood on the relevant day.

    I then smoothed the data in three different ways to produce 3 different but very similar charts.

    My results clearly support Martin Estlander's findings that the large number of strong trends peaked in 2008 (on an annual basis) and hit a historic low in 2012.

    Long term trend following has undoubtedly become more difficult over the past 40 years. I won't speculate further on the well rehearsed and frequently aired reasons for this, nor on the fact that the past two years seem to stand out as a particularly difficult period.

    Some analysts believe that trend following is a dangerous illusion doomed to failure and that trends simply do not exist in a purely random market; or in an "efficient" market.

    My own belief is that markets are neither perfectly efficient nor wholly random in the longer term and that trends will continue to unfold with changing economic circumstances and evolving valuation assumptions. I believe that more frequent stronger and longer trends will once again emerge and that traditional long term trend following will resume its profitability; but methods will need carful adjustment over time to take account of changing market conditions.

    My data and charts can be found at the URL below:

Back To Anthony FJ Garner's Instablog HomePage »

Instablogs are blogs which are instantly set up and networked within the Seeking Alpha community. Instablog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors, in contrast to contributors' articles.

Comments (0)
Track new comments
Be the first to comment
Full index of posts »
Latest Followers


More »
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.