Exxon's High Valuation Is Hard to Comprehend [View article]
Interesting analysis. In the long-run, Exxon is way overvalued as their reserves are questionable, particularly with recent changes in oil reserve accounting. In the short- to medium-term, however, reserves can be overlooked as oil prices increase. The stock is a staple in many managers' portfolios, so the volatility is relatively low. With limited new investment, the discounted cashflow value of this decreases, yet with low oil prices in the short-run, there is upside when prices recover. Agree with you that valuing this stock is very tough.
Some very relevant points, and overall agree with your analysis. Timing, however, is the key here. Your scenario could take a while as the whole "old system" is bent on survival. That said, can't be too wrong going long physical gold for the long-term (5 years+).
Who knows when Peak Oil will hit, but I would review all of the IOC's production rates over the past 5 years. Not a good picture, though I do agree that the significant recent investment by the IOC's will show through in a short-term spike in supply.
Exxon's High Valuation Is Hard to Comprehend [View article]
Gold as a Truly Last Resort [View article]
The Case Against Peak Oil [View article]