Seeking Alpha

InvestBaboo » Comments » COP

  • 10 Upcoming Catalysts for ATP Oil and Gas [View article]
    Very good and compelling answers! The charts however confirm a Sell signal on the daily charts as of today. A reversal generally takes several days to take place so ATPG may have a little ways to go down and could present a better buying opportunity. The charts do reverse and if they do I will let the readers know.
    Jun 19 13:37 pm |Rating: 0 0 |Link to Comment
  • 10 Upcoming Catalysts for ATP Oil and Gas [View article]
    Devon:

    This is one of the best researched articles I have read on SeekingAlpha. Furthermore, you have replied to every post where a question was asked without taking offence.

    I spotted ATPG when it registered a Buy signal on the chart in early May. I am a chart reader first and do fundamental analysis next. I searched SeekingAlpha and came across your article and loved the story. The charts said YES and your fundamental analysis said YES. Another enticing factor was that this was once a fifty dollar stock (!) and it stands to reason that if someone paid fifty bucks for it once they will remember it and support the stock once it starts showing upwards momentum.

    I would really like to double down or triple down on ATPG however a couple of things bother me. Perhaps, you can answer?

    #1 Throughout your article and in the posts thereafter you seemed to firmly believe that they would not dilute. It was so strongly against their interests given the CEO and CFO's significant stake in the company. BUT THEY DID IT! Instead of reevaluating your position and checking facts againt you have forgiven them too easily. If the story is this good and if the stock price potential is so high would you not think that they would leave no stone unturned to not dilute? In fact, you firmly believed that they had other ways to get the money they needed. How come they still diluted? Is there something you do not know and the big money knows that caused management to do this?

    #2 On June 15, 2009 the ATPG daily charts registerd a Sell signal. Ever since then this equity has headed south. Weekly charts are perhaps a day or two away from registering a sell signal. A Sell on the weekly charts if it happens almost certainly means this stock is headed down to the $5 range. What I am saying here is irrespective of the fundamentals you detail big money is running from the stock fast and furiously.

    #3 I fell for a similar stock on SeekingAlpha - a company named LDK Solar which was touted by many authors on SeekingAlpha as $120 stock that was misunderstood and was stuck in the $40 range. Same kind of analysis that you provided accompanies these articles to rationalize why this was a $120-plus stock. This company was one of the largest producers of polysilicon on the planet, had many many delivery agreements, was building a new generation plant that would give them even lower cost and so on and on. Almost every day the company issued press releases touting yet another delivery agreement with yet another brand name company. They did have to acquire a lot of debt to bring their new plant online much like ATPG but the authors were confident the company could easily handle the debt load. For some mysterious reason the stock was going down every day. Instead of going to $120 in 6 months the stock went to single digits! What went wrong? Well, it turns out that the company lied about their new plant and when it would come online. They lied about Polysilicon price points which went south quite drastically. Instead of upbeat quarter they announced massively disappointing earnings and they stock got hammered. And when they went ahead and did a surprising dilution event (much like ATPG) the backers who balked at first found it easy to forgive the company and came up with rationale that justifed the diluation. Much like ATPG! And most importantly -- the Street had no faith in the management and that was one of the reasons why they did not trust anything the managemeng said and eventually the Street was proven right. So if things are this good and the management is telling the Street all the information you seemed to have acquired from them yet the stock is headed south -- is this because the Street distrusts the management?

    Your perspective much appreciated.
    Jun 18 18:14 pm |Rating: 0 0 |Link to Comment
  • ATP Oil & Gas: Value After a Stock and Commodity Collapse [View article]
    Wow, Devon! What an excellent analysis?!

    I picked ATPG for my Slumdog Millionaire portfolio. I picked ATPG at a price of $4.32. I missed the buy on this one at at around the 3.5 level just because I wasn't watching it on my radar screen. Since then it has broken through 3 major resistance levels and looks solid on the Daily charts. Weekly charts are still to show a buy but if it keeps the momentum up that is just a matter of time. 52 week high appears to be in the 48 plus range and that is my target for this stock in the Slumdog Millionaire portfolio.

    The point -- using charts and technical analysis -- I saved myself a whole deal of extensive research work like you did and yet got in at a very good price. But I do feel even better about my position thanks to your thorugh research and analysis. Keep up the good work!
    Apr 26 14:06 pm |Rating: 0 -1 |Link to Comment
  • E*TRADE Financial: It Was Good to Be Long  [View article]
    ETFC is a 3-bagger stock by the end of this year.
    Sep 24 17:30 pm |Rating: 0 0 |Link to Comment
  • Barron's Banks on $100 Oil [View article]
    On a per capita basis an American consumes 52 barrels of oil a year -- the highest in the world. Indians consume 1 barrel per person per year and China 2 barrels per person per year.

    If the U.S. consumer on the average cuts his consumption by 2% that is equal to 1 (appx) barrel of oil per person per year. That frees up about 250 million barrels of oil per year.

    It is the math above that pundits forecast when talking about China and India's demand increase. When the U.S. consumer cuts his consumption the Saudis will choke in their sleep. $100/barrel oil is not optimistic talk -- it is a reality that will happen.
    Jun 24 19:15 pm |Rating: 0 0 |Link to Comment
More on COP by InvestBaboo
Comments by Ticker
InvestBaboo's
Comments Stats
209 comments
Rating: -51 (348 - 399 )