Take a look at those charts again. The huge drop in the ETF price before March means that the market has already adjusted the CURRENT ETF holdings.
Individual REITS or newly formed REITS also reflect today's market so there is no meaningful difference.
If there was, you would see traders shorting the existing ETFs and buying the new REITS i.e., the prices of the existing REITS would continue to fall, not rise.
However, the existing ETF prices have been rising since March.
On Jun 04 10:41 AM Charlie P wrote:
> When you buy into a REIT ETF are you buying into what the ETF has > invested ie. what they purchased at the higher REIT prices of the > past not the lower prices that prevail today. Thus my assumption > is that one would be better off buying individual REITS at their > current low prices or a newly formed REIT ETF that is buying into > the present market.
Why REIT ETFs Are Recovering [View article]
Individual REITS or newly formed REITS also reflect today's market so there is no meaningful difference.
If there was, you would see traders shorting the existing ETFs and buying the new REITS i.e., the prices of the existing REITS would continue to fall, not rise.
However, the existing ETF prices have been rising since March.
On Jun 04 10:41 AM Charlie P wrote:
> When you buy into a REIT ETF are you buying into what the ETF has
> invested ie. what they purchased at the higher REIT prices of the
> past not the lower prices that prevail today. Thus my assumption
> is that one would be better off buying individual REITS at their
> current low prices or a newly formed REIT ETF that is buying into
> the present market.