Seeking Alpha

working at ford » Comments » Single Comment |

  • Will the U.S. Fight the German Car Invasion? [View article]
    Better check your info. VW lead all automakers in recalls by percentage in 2007 and had some trouble in 2008.


    On Jan 06 08:45 PM billddrummer wrote:

    > To oilcan,
    >
    > Didn't Michael Douglas say that in "Wall Street"?
    >
    > But aside from that, MB may have lost its luster after absorbing,
    > then disposing of, Chrysler. Several billion dollars were lost which
    > could have been used to improve quality and maintain engineering
    > prowess.
    >
    > Come to think of it, wasn't that the original purpose of the initial
    > loan money the US government allocated to the auto industry? To
    > provide funds for new product R & D to improve fuel economy?

    >
    >
    > Let's not look at the past, when the car makers used their own money
    > for R & D. To suggest a loan for R & D to the GM of 1955
    > would have been scoffed at.
    >
    > But when competition gets more intense, it seems that these companies
    > run to the government for protection. Now, I'm not saying that there
    > isn't government assistance in other countries for its capital-intensive
    > industries. But the idea of government 'participating' (meddling)
    > in the capital budget plans of GM and Ford suggests that the companies
    > themselves aren't up to the task.
    >
    > As Americans, we expect self-reliance from industries as well as
    > individuals. The state of the US auto industry has humbled the country,
    > and by extension, its people.
    >
    > And far from shying away from competition, we should be welcoming
    > it. Competition makes everyone better. Having the US government
    > place its thumb on the scale makes it harder for other nations to
    > compete. But in the process, they will make the necessary adjustments
    > to become more competitive as time goes on.
    >
    > It looks less and less likely that the US industries insulated by
    > the government will make the same progress.
    >
    > I for one welcome additional entrants into the auto manufacturing
    > marketplace. Excess capacity aside, those companies that make cars
    > people want to buy will survive. Those companies that don't, won't.

    >
    >
    > I tend to think BMW and VW will survive. They are the most profitable
    > auto companies in the world, and make some of the best products,
    > with worldwide appeal.
    >
    > Bring on the Germans!
    Jan 07 01:41 am |Rating: 0 0
All Comments by working at ford »
Comments by Ticker
working at ford's
Comments Stats
62 comments
Rating: -40 (76 - 116 )