slickvguy

The Coming Depression: See It Clearly Through Historical Eyes

Standing ovation for this comment!
An essay written by this commenter would be far more valuable than the one in question.
Bravo.


On Feb 23 09:16 AM You're Kidding wrote:

> You say you see cycles in the above chart...
>
> I see nothing in it that would tell me when to get fully invested
> in this market, nor do I see anything in your article that would
> indicate you are willing to make any such predictions.
>
> That would be a smart move on your part and quite revealing as to
> how much practical, useful information you really think these "cycles"
> tell us.
>
> Nothing like having your cake and eating it, too. That's a winner
> if I've ever heard of one.
>
> But there's more! You conclude by saying:
>
> "If I am correct in the assertions made in this article, it raises
> serious doubts about the effectiveness of the Obama plan to fix the
> economic problems of the country."
>
> So let me get this straight. You are saying that these cycles you
> see, going back hundreds of years, portend the future success of
> what the government might do now? You realize, of course, that if
> the government was going to take say, a much different action, that
> your "model" would still raise the same doubts about its success,
> too? In other words, no matter what the government does, or doesn't
> do, it probably won't work, because of what your cycles tell us.
>
>
> Now, I know you haven't thought this through, because any logical
> person would see the complete irrationality of such thinking. So
> please, tell us you were wrong, so we don't have to put your name
> on the "Never Read Another Article From These People" list.
>