Understanding the OEX Put/Call Strategy

Dec. 08, 2008 9:44 AM ETDIA, IVV, SPY, QQQ1 Comment1 Like
Michael Stokes profile picture
Michael Stokes
178 Followers

This post is a follow-up to an S&P 500 swing trading strategy that I shared last week: the OEX Put/Call Strategy. (Warning: this post will get geeky. You’ve been warned.)

I’ve been running some numbers to understand just what it is that that makes this strategy so predictive. The strategy is a little difficult to wrap the head around, but I’m excited about it because (a) it’s worked so well, and (b) it’s using a data source unrelated to anything else I’m looking at on the State of the Market report.

A reminder, strategy results (red) and its inverse (green) versus the S&P 500 (blue) from 1985, frictionless with NO return on cash:

click to enlarge

20081205012
[logarithmically-scaled]

The strategy is buying when a shorter (i.e. faster) moving average of the ratio of the S&P 500 over the OEX put/call ratio is below a longer (i.e. slower) moving average.

Thinking about that for a moment, the strategy is bullish when either the numerator of the fraction (the S&P 500) is falling or the denominator (the OEX put/call ratio) is rising, even though both of these would be (in traditional thinking) bearish.

Taking that logic a step further, the graph below of the S&P 500 (red, right axis) versus the OEX put/call ratio (blue, left axis) shows that the put/call ratio is much more volatile than the S&P 500. Because of that, the strategy is really driven not by the S&P 500 falling, but by the put/call ratio rising.

click to enlarge

2008120801

Confirming this is the fact that about 88% of the time that the strategy has been long, the 21-day EMA of just the put/call ratio has been above the 42-day EMA.

So what this strategy is really measuring is an increasing put/call ratio in a market that might be oversold, might be neutral, and even might be a bit overbought…just not too overbought.

Put another way, the strategy is taking a contrarian position against the put/call ratio. A high put/call ratio would indicate that a large number of investors are betting on (or hedging against) the market falling. This strategy is buying into that bearishness except when the market is very overbought and due a pullback.

This all of course goes very much against conventional wisdom, but like most things in the stock market, conventional wisdom is usually not all that wise.

One last note: Because of how frequently this strategy changes positions, I’ve decided to count it as an intermediate-term indicator on the State of the Market report. I’m still in search of good unique long-term indicators to add to the report.

This article was written by

Michael Stokes profile picture
178 Followers
Michael Stokes is the developer of a number of swing trading strategies (http://marketsci.wordpress.com/my-strategies/), all of which are independently-audited and available via subscription or managed account. For 2006 and 2007, the first two years his strategies were available to the general public, he was the #1 ranked market timer for risk-adjusted performance by Theta Research. His thoughts on wrangling these unruly markets can be found on the MarketSci Blog (http://marketsci.wordpress.com/).
Follow

Recommended For You

Comments (1)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.