Siemens May Sell Its Stake In Nokia Siemens Networks For Way Too Little

Feb. 27, 2013 2:23 PM ETNOK, SIEGY18 Comments
Trefis profile picture

With Nokia Siemens Networks (NSN) doing well, one of its parent companies, Siemens (SI), may be looking to reduce its stake in the joint venture or exit it completely. The German engineering company had announced its intentions to sell off some of its non-core businesses in November, and with a six-year old shareholder agreement between Nokia (NOK) and Siemens coming to an end in April, speculations are rife about a possible stake sale in NSN. According to the Financial Times, Siemens could be looking to cut its 50% stake to as much as 20% or even lower. [1] Both companies had previously tried to sell NSN in 2011, but talks with private equity groups didn’t materialize. Now, with the joint venture back on its feet with four consecutive quarters of free cash flows, those talks seem to be back.

See our complete analysis for Nokia stock here

Rumors undervalue NSN …

However, it is not yet clear if Nokia is also interested in these talks considering that it manages NSN’s operations and has more than just a financial interest in the JV. According to our estimates, NSN contributes more than a third of Nokia’s fair value which means that Nokia’s half of the joint venture is worth a little over $6 billion, excluding cash. However, rumors put NSN’s enterprise value at only about 5 billion Euros ($6.6 billion). If true, Nokia will be able to realize only about half of what we believe is NSN’s fair value if it chooses to sell all of its stake in NSN.

It may be true that Nokia’s core handset business has been wilting under the constant assault of Apple (AAPL) and Samsung’s (OTCPK:SSNLF) smartphones, and it is uncertain how long the Lumia Windows Phones will be able to sustain demand in this highly competitive market. But considering that NSN has been performing well of late, executing on its LTE plans and consistently generating cash, we do not think it is likely that Nokia will look to sell its stake in NSN at such a low valuation. Moreover, with about $14 billion in reserves, Nokia doesn’t seem to be in dire need of cash in the near term. It could however be possible that Nokia is looking to buy out a portion of Siemens’ stake at a low valuation, which could be a good move by the Finns.

NSN’s turnaround

Over the past year, Nokia Siemens Networks has shown signs of turning the corner as a result of an ongoing restructuring that has not only helped operating margins improve, but also restored focus on its wireless business. As a result, NSN has fast emerged as the leader in the ongoing 4G LTE transition around the world and is taking share away from competitors. As of Q3 2012, NSN had succeeded in increasing its market share to about 20% share of the wireless infrastructure industry, only 2% behind #2 player, Huawei. [2] It now expects to reclaim its #2 spot behind Ericsson (ERIC) by the end of 2013.

Apart from revenue share gains, NSN is also benefiting from a streamlining of operations and the ongoing job cuts. By the end of 2013, NSN aims to cut around 17,000 jobs and achieve a total of 1 billion euros in savings as part of the restructuring initiative announced in late 2011. Simultaneously, NSN has been selling off non-core assets and increasing focus on wireless broadband which has strong long-term growth trends as opposed to the relatively stagnant landline market. As a result of the reshuffle, NSN has performed really well in 2012, returning to operating profitability in the last two quarters of the year. As a result, we estimate NSN’s EBITDA margins in 2012 to have doubled over the previous year. This is a big positive sign that the company’s cost-cutting initiatives are taking hold. The division has also generated positive cash flows for four straight quarters now, and we expect this to sustain in the coming quarters as well.


  1. Siemens accelerates Nokia joint venture exit, Financial Times, February 24th, 2012
  2. Nokia Siemens gains market share in telecom equipment: Dell’Oro, November 13th, 2012

Disclosure: No positions

This article was written by

Trefis profile picture
Led by MIT engineers and Wall Street analysts, helps you understand how a company's products, that you touch, read, or hear about everyday, impact its stock price. Surprisingly, the founders of Trefis discovered that along with most other people they just did not understand even the seemingly familiar companies around them: Apple, Google, Coca Cola, Walmart, GE, Ford, Gap, and others. This might include you though you may have invested money in these companies, or may have been working with one of them for years as an employee, or have consulted with them as an expert for a long time. Disagree? Consider these questions: •What % of Apple's stock price is iPhones? (Q: Is it 5%, 25%, or 50%?) •What % of Dell's stock price is Dell Notebooks? •If Bing took half the market share from Google Search, what % upside could there be for Microsoft’s stock? On Trefis you will get answers to questions like above. You can play with assumptions, or try scenarios, as-well-as ask questions to other users and experts. The platform uses extensive data to show in a single snapshot what drives the value of a company's business. Trefis makes the same content, data, and tools that are currently available only to professional investors today, accessible to everyone. Importantly, it makes the extensive data/tools easy to use and understand, allowing investors to leverage the platform in their decision making much more efficiently than anything else available. Trefis is currently used by hundreds of thousands of investors, company employees, and business professionals.

Recommended For You

Comments (18)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.