Why Caterpillar And Joy Global Aren't Worth Buying

| About: Joy Global (JOY)
This article is now exclusive for PRO subscribers.


The struggle of the mining sector has hurt Joy Global and Caterpillar.

Heavy exposure to coal is a headwind for both the companies.

Losing railway contract will hurt Caterpillar.

Russia-Ukraine conflict can hurt Caterpillar in the foreseeable future..

The present scenario for the mining sector doesn't look good as mining equipment makers are suffering from poor demand for mining equipments. This explains why Joy Global (NYSE:JOY) shares have underperformed this year, losing close to 5%. Joy Global's problems are shared by bigger peer Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT), which is facing additional problems apart from macroeconomic issues.

Joy Global: Going downhill but staying positive

Looking ahead, there seems to be no respite in sight for Joy Global. The company received poor bookings for equipment across all geographies, except South America and China. In addition, Joy also saw a 25% decline in underground mining machinery orders.

However, Joy saw an increase in underground service bookings as a result of higher component and rebuild activity in regions such as North America and Eurasia. The company expects demand to be weak across the year, but on the other hand, it expects an increase in demand toward the end of the fiscal year. Joy is facing challenges in the global mining business due to oversupply and lower commodity pricing. With global economic growth expected to rise 3.5% this year, Joy Global is expecting an increase in demand for commodities and favorable manufacturing conditions.

In addition, Joy is expecting good business in China, which is one of the largest markets in the world for mining equipment. Though some commodities might face weakness in demand, but the stable growth rate and industrialization and urbanization of China gives Joy room for growth. Further, the growth in electricity production in China gives Joy Global more reasons to be optimistic about the mining business in China.

But the bottom line is that Joy Global is facing many challenges. Despite an improvement in macroeconomic factors, commodity prices are under pressure. Mining players are cautious about investing in new projects as lower pricing would lead to losses. To fight this situation, Joy Global is undertaking a restructuring program and expects growth in the business in this stiff situation also.

Moving on to the service business, Joy Global expects an improvement in this segment as service orders increased 4% year-over-year. The performance of the service segment is critical due to weak commodity pricing. Joy is investing in service centers globally that will support its installed fleet and provide world-class technical expertise to customers, and bring in more service revenue. It has high expectations from its newly-built service center at Peru, which is expected to support the fast-growing copper market.

Moreover, an increase in power demand and natural gas prices remaining stable should also lead to better demand in the service business. Also, Joy Global expects an improvement in its business in China after the reduction of the commodity prices in the country.

Joy Global also plans to invest in oil projects as it sees opportunity in oil field mining. Further, the seaborne thermal coal market is expected to increase by 3% in regions such as China, India, and the Pacific nations, leading to more catalysts for the business.

However, the big problem for Joy Global is its heavy exposure to the coal business. Coal accounted for nearly 62% of Joy's total sales, highest amongst its rivals like Caterpillar. Even though coal still accounts for more electricity generation than natural gas, the gap is narrowing. Due to the reduced dependence on coal, coal miners are looking to exports in order to drive growth, but it isn't as easy as it sounds. Many people have protested against the Gateway Pacific Terminal, a proposed coal export terminal at Cherry Point, near Bellingham, Washington, because of its negative social and environmental impact.

Caterpillar's Troubles

Caterpillar, on the other hand, also has problems. Last month, the company lost a major contract in Illinois to manufacture locomotives for high-speed trains. Caterpillar lost the contract to Siemens AG (SI) and Cummins (NYSE:CMI), who were given a $226 million contract to produce 32 diesel locomotive engines capable of running at a speed of 125 miles per hour.

In addition, Siemens also has the right to provide 225 extra locomotives, which could rake in a total of $1.5 billion for the company. This has dented Caterpillar's hopes of dominating the railway segment and the company is clearly not happy about it. The company even claimed that Siemens' locomotive will fall short of the 125 miles per hour speed requirement unless it was travelling downhill.

This is a major setback for the company and things could get worse. The Russia-Ukraine conflict can prove to be another big blow for Caterpillar if Russia decides to retaliate against U.S. sanctions. Caterpillar has laid up the groundwork in Russia for years and has invested over $1 billion since 2000. If Russia decides to retaliate, it could hamper $38.2 billion worth of trade between the two countries and mining, banking, and manufacturing sectors will suffer the most.


Both Joy Global and Caterpillar are in a soup. Although Joy Global expects a rebound in its business in the future; still, high dependence on coal and weak commodity pricing will negatively affect its performance. Caterpillar, on the other hand, can face a big setback due to its Russian ties, which makes an investment risky. So, investors should consider staying away from these two stocks.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.