ETFs vs. Mutual Funds: The Long and Short (Term) Of It

Includes: DIA, GLD, QQQ, SPY
by: Dhinesh Ganapathiappan

Exchange-traded funds, commonly known as ETFs, are gaining an increasing amount of popularity among investors as an alternative to traditional mutual funds. ETFs have the advantage that they trade directly on major stock exchanges like common stocks. This guarantees a high level of liquidity to move in and out of ETFs at will. The drawback of ETFs is that they generally track an index or industry of stocks, and are not actively managed like a mutual fund. This lack of rebalancing makes ETFs better investments in the short-run, but mutual funds remain a smarter option for a longer time horizon.

The most common ETFs directly track the major stock market indexes like the Dow Jones Industrial Average, Nasdaq, or S&P 500. Arguably the most popular ETF is the Nasdaq-100 (QQQQ) which tracks the 100 largest stocks trading on the Nasdaq. The average daily volume on the Q’s is usually over 120 million shares. The Dow Jones Industrial Average can be tracked with the Diamonds (NYSEARCA:DIA) ETF and the S&P 500 by the S&P Depository Receipts (NYSEARCA:SPY).

Recently a fancier group of ETFs were released that provide twice the performance of major indexes. For example, the Ultra Dow30 (NYSEARCA:DDM) offered through the ProShares family of funds will theoretically increase 2% in value when the Dow increases by 1%. This type of leverage is a boon for confident investors in times of high margin interest rates.

Another advantage of ETFs is that if you feel a particular index or industry is due for a decline, you can short-sell the issue and profit if the ETF falls. ProShares also has a line of UltraShort index and sector funds that can be viewed here.

Not all ETFs track stock market indexes though – some follow the price of commodities like crude oil (NYSEARCA:USO), gold (NYSEARCA:GLD), and silver (NYSEARCA:SLV), while others track individual sectors like energy (NYSEARCA:XLE), semiconductors (NYSEARCA:SMH), and real estate (NYSEARCA:ICF). These funds should be researched thoroughly before investing because they can involve serious pitfalls. The U.S. Oil Fund (USO) is supposed to follow the price of West Texas Intermediate Crude Oil, but is currently trading about $10 a share lower than the price of the actual commodity due to high costs incurred while trading oil futures contracts.

While ETF’s are great instruments for generating returns and achieving diversification in the short-term, mutual fund investing can pay off over longer periods of time. The fee structure for ETFs and Mutual Funds vary slightly. For ETFs, the fees involved are stock commissions and an expense ratio which is usually around 1% and factored into the share price.

Mutual funds have a more complicated and varied fee structure. Some funds charge a “load fee” which serves as a percentage commission for each purchase you make, a flat transaction fee, an expense ratio, and a redemption fee if you liquidate your position within a certain timeframe.

There are many mutual funds that offer no-load and no-transaction fees, and if you hold the fund longer than the redemption period you can avoid all fees except the expense ratio. Another consideration when investing in mutual funds is that most impose a minimum investment that must be met.

The active management of mutual funds serves to usually provide superior returns that outperform the market averages. Some things to consider when choosing mutual funds are the fees and expenses charged by the fund, analyzing the consistency of past returns, and what the current top holdings of the fund are.

With so many ETF and mutual fund options available, researching various funds and finding what fits your portfolio best is vital. Financial institutions have large incentives for throwing out whatever new type of ETF they can think of to feed investor appetite. Retirement accounts that aren’t actively managed should be invested in a basket of mutual funds, and ETFs used primarily for shorter-term diversification.

About this article:

Want to share your opinion on this article? Add a comment.
Disagree with this article? .
To report a factual error in this article, click here