U.S. New Home Sales Market Hits A Potential Top In Q4 2015

Includes: ITB, IYR, PKB, XHB
by: Ironman at Political Calculations

Did you catch the headline in the Wall Street Journal yesterday about new home sales? In case you missed it, here it is, along with our excerpt of the first, second and final paragraphs from the story:

U.S. New-Home Sales Rise in December

Caps best year for new home sales since 2007

WASHINGTON - The market for newly built U.S. homes entered 2016 on a solid footing, after December's sales capped their best year since 2007.

Purchases of new single-family homes increased by 10.8% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 544,000 in December, the Commerce Department said Wednesday, beating the 502,000 estimated by economists The Wall Street Journal surveyed.


U.S. home builders continue to report high levels of confidence. The National Association of Home Builders' sentiment index stayed at 60 in January, unchanged on the month at a high level, the group said last week.

Elsewhere in the story, we find that both the median and average sales prices of new homes fell. Our first chart below shows what that means in the context of new home sales since January 2000:

Keeping in mind that the data for each of the final three months of 2015 is still preliminary and may be subject to revision in the upcoming months, what we see is that for 2015 as a whole, median new home sales prices were essentially flat compared to previous years while average new home sales prices slightly fell below the level where they started the year.

In itself, that's a positive development for U.S. consumers. But is it really one for U.S. home builders?

That depends upon the quantity of new homes sold. And while the data certainly indicates that the quantity of sales has risen, what really matters to U.S. home builders and the U.S. economy is the product of both the price and quantity of new homes sold, which we have calculated as the real market capitalization of the new home sales market, in which we've adjusted the average new home sales prices to account for the effect of inflation over time to be in terms of constant December 2015 U.S. dollars, then multiplied the result by the number of new homes sold in each month from January 2000 through December 2015 to get the raw aggregate value of all the sales recorded in each month. We then accounted for the effects of seasonality in the data by calculating the trailing 12-month average of the market capitalization for U.S. new home sales.

What we find then is a market that was rising steadily in the first half of 2015, rising from $12.75 billion in January 2015 to $14.21 billion in July 2015, that then stalled out and went flat in the remaining second half of 2015, barely rising to peak at an inflation-adjusted $14.48 billion in November 2015, which coincidentally is the same figure we calculate for December 2015 as well.

Once again, the data for the last three months of 2015 is still preliminary and will be subject to revision over the next few months.

To put the market capitalization data in better context, here is what it looks like over all the data we have, which spans the last 40 years:

What these results suggest is that new home sales have stalled out in the second half of 2015, to the point where they contributed very little growth to the nation's GDP in the final quarter of that year. And quite potentially, the new home sales market in the U.S. has topped, coincidentally at or near the inflation-adjusted levels where the industry has previously topped or plateaued in the years preceding the housing bubble.

We'll have to see just how long the sentiments of the National Association of Home Builders stay elevated at their current high level.