Williams-Sonoma, Inc. (NYSE:WSM) Q3 2016 Earnings Conference Call November 17, 2016 5:00 PM ET
Beth Potillo-Miller - SVP, Finance and Corporate Treasure
Laura Alber - President & CEO
Julie Whalen - CFO
Matt Lasser - UBS
Matt Fassler - Goldman Sachs
Christopher Horvers - JPMorgan
Greg Melick - Evercore
Peter Benedict - Robert W. Baird & Company
Brad Thomas - KeyBanc Capital Markets
Dan Binder - Jefferies
Budd Bugatch - Raymond James & Associates
Welcome to the Williams-Sonoma Third Quarter 2016 Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions]. I would now like to turn the call over to Ms. Beth Potillo-Miller, Senior Vice President, Finance and Corporate Treasure, to discuss non-GAAP financial measures and forward-looking statements. Please go ahead.
Thank you Catherine. Good afternoon. This call should be considered in conjunction with the press release that we issued earlier today. Our discussion will contain non-GAAP results and guidance, including non-GAAP EPS and operating margin which excludes the impact of unusual business events. A reconciliation of the non-GAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures and our explanation of why the non-GAAP financial measures may be useful are discussed in our press release.
During the first and third quarters of 2016, we incurred severance-related organization charges due to the reduction of headcount, primarily in our corporate functions totaling approximately $13 million or $0.09 per diluted share and $1 million or $0.01 per diluted share, respectively. These charges were recorded as SG&A expense within the unallocated segment. The remainder of the discussion today will reference third quarter results and full-year guidance related to EPS and operating margin on a non-GAAP basis, excluding this unusual item.
This call also contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 which address the financial condition, results of operations, business initiatives, trends, guidance, growth plans and prospects of the Company in 2016 and beyond and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from such forward-looking statements. Please refer to the Company's current press releases and SEC filings, including the most recent 10-K and 10-Q for more information on these risks and uncertainties.
The Company undertakes no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements to reflect events or circumstances that may arise after the date of this call. I would now like to turn the conference call over to Laura Alber, our President and Chief Executive Officer, to discuss our third quarter 2016 results.
Good afternoon, thank you all for joining us today. On the call with me today are Julie Whalen, our Chief Financial Officer; and John Strain, our Chief Digital and Technology Officer. In the third quarter, we delivered revenue growth of 1.1% and earnings per share of $0.79. Growth was fueled by strong year-over-year revenue increases at West Elm, our newer businesses Rejuvenation and Mark and Graham and our international company owned businesses. Comp brand revenues in Williams-Sonoma were essentially flat, up 0.1% with the Pottery Barn brand declining 4.5%.
Although the current environment is less certain, we remain focused on what we can control and we're confident that the ongoing progress on our strategic initiative will improve service for our customers and will drive long term, sustainable, profitable growth for our shareholders. As we look to the balance of the year we believe that the customer is resilient and will spend money on the holidays, especially for their home and with brands they love. And we're entirely focused on delivering a better experience for our customers this holiday season.
We continue to make great progress on our customer-centric initiative which include supply chain and inventory improvement, innovative products at the best value, marketing strategies to increase new customer acquisition and enhancements of the retail experience. The improvements resulting from these initiatives are the reason that even with sales not as strong as we'd like, we delivered Q3 earnings at the higher end of our guidance. And we delivered this earnings performance without cutting investments in our future growth strategies and most importantly these initiatives improved service to our customers.
In our supply chain, we made significant progress in our home delivery experience in the third quarter with measurable improvements in pieces for delivery. This was driven by better positioning of inventory resulting in fewer out of market shipments and improved order completeness. Additionally, we're working hard in our upholstery manufacturing operations to ensure multi-unit orders are shipping together. As a result, we significantly reduced at delivery occurrences, resulting in more customers receiving complete orders in one delivery.
These types of improvements are particularly important as they simultaneously provide a better customer experience while also reducing freight costs. Our new southeastern distribution center in Georgia is now approximately 75% full and is shipping approximately 60% of our southeastern volume. Average delivery time to customers in this region have improved three to five days. As inventory levels continue to ramp up in this facility and the fulfillment percentage grows, we should realize further improvements in delivery time and service, as well as reduced out of market shipments and freight costs.
As we enter the 2016 holiday season we expect shopping will occur late in the quarter and we have prepared for the season with investments in process improvements and employee training in our distribution centers and believe we're well positioned for improved holiday fulfillment performance relative to last year. In our Memphis and Olive Branch operations we have invested considerable time and effort in SKU rationalization and reengineering of our picking process flows and technologies over the past year. These enhancements and efficiencies will help drive faster order fulfillment in our DCs for this holiday season, as well as improve efficiencies and the overall customer experience by reducing the shipment for multiple cartons to the customer's home to fulfill a complete order.
We're spending more time investing in improved training for our seasonal and full-time associates, while simultaneously revamping our talent sourcing approach to provide candidates with more flexible options to make us the employer of choice.
This is particularly important as the labor markets become more competitive in various areas of the country where our distribution sites are located. We have strategically built our staffing plan to get ahead of the hiring ramp and also to optimize our staffing to accommodate the later Christmas e-commerce order curve as we expect to see this year.
In retail, as I mentioned to you on our last call, we're taking a very aggressive approach to our retail and real estate strategies to improve the experience in our stores. We're underway with extensive analysis of our stores, reviewing locations in looking at ways to optimize our fleet. As a result of our analysis we have identified stores that may close upon natural lease expiration. And at the same time we're also investing in store remodels and are seeing good results.
In Pottery Barn we continue to drive year-over-year improvement -- improved results in our remodels in Corte Madera in South Coast Plaza and we have three other store refreshes opened in early November, including Mission Viejo, Columbus, Ohio and Broomfield, Colorado. We'll also continue to open stores in select markets such as national Tennessee and Wichita, Kansas, both of which are exceeding our expectations.
In Williams-Sonoma we're pleased with our Ponce City store in Atlanta, Georgia which opened last year and our recently remodeled stores in South Coast Plaza in San Diego, California. In Q3 we rolled out four stores in the new Williams-Sonoma format in San Luis Obispo and San Mateo, California; Toronto, Canada; and in Troy, Michigan. All including Williams-Sonoma Home products.
We also added home products to another 6 stores in Q3 bringing our total installations to 36. In these locations we're seeing positive growth in sales, driven by conversion and average transaction size, validating that the strategy is working. All of these stores are performing above our expectations. Importantly, when we add home installations to our stores we not only see increased sales in these stores, but we also see an increase in online sales of WS Home product in the surrounding areas. And in West Elm, we're seeing excellent results in our new stores including our relocated Empire store in Brooklyn, New York and we now have a total of 98 West Elm stores. We will continue to update you on the progress we're making across our retail fleet.
In marketing, we continue to shift our investments from catalog to digital to acquire new customers cost efficiently. A key reason we have been a leader in online sales is our almost 60 years of experience building and nurturing our house file of customers who shopped with us in our stores, over the phone and on our websites. We continue to capitalize on that heritage as we enhance our house file with more information about our customer, allowing us to deliver even more relevant messaging in email, on our sites, on mobile and social platforms and through direct mail. Expansion of our digital identity capabilities has allowed us to understand our customers' behavior across devices and our channels as well as across our brands. The leverage of our house style is an expansive range of product offerings across differentiated brands are areas of significant competitive advantage.
We've identified even more creative and cost-efficient programs to market across our brands. For example, in Q3 we went to market with a premier shopping event, our first over cross brand marketing initiative. The event was a success and we learned that our customers appreciated the cross brand offerings as a way to introduce them to different products and anesthetics, while still delivering on the same great value and quality standards. We're not only able to generate our own demand, but we also acquired significant new to brand customers.
Following this cross-brand success we've also recently introduced The Key, our first cross brand loyalty program. The Key is designed to showcase our brands and reward our customers for shopping across our portfolio. Over the next 24 months we'll continue to expand The Key with elevated technology, services and experiences, including integration with Weston hotels and other new businesses we may develop. In addition to providing value and fun to our customers, The Key will improve our ability to deliver a more relevant experience across all of our brands.
In addition to the progress we have made on our corporate-wide strategic initiatives, we believe we're well poised for this holiday season. We've been working on our personalization capabilities, insight visibility and have made many improvements to our customer experience. All the supply chain progress we have made this year have prepared us to efficiently fulfill peak volumes in whatever channel our customers want to shop. We have great talent and a focus on outstanding customer service in our stores and we have early positive reads on our holiday products across our brands.
I would also like to take a moment to discuss our community engagement this holiday season. 2016 will mark our 12th year of partnership with St. Jude's Children's Research Hospital, on the Thanksgiving campaign. Over the past 11 years we have raised more than $34 million for research in the care of children and families facing childhood cancer and other life-threatening diseases. This year we're especially excited about the give-back program from each of our brands that are specifically designed for this campaign.
In addition to St. Jude, each of our brands have product offerings and programs that support other organizations that are meaningful to them and the communities they serve. In summary, while the environment is challenging we're prepared and believe we're well-positioned to service our customers by delivering the inspiration and the value they expect.
Now I'd like to discuss the key results within our brand portfolio, beginning with the Pottery Barn brands. Across the Pottery Barn brands, including Pottery Barn Kids and Teen, comp brand revenues declined 4.5%, with Pottery Barn declining 4.6%, Kids 1% and PBT down 10.9%. As you know, we have been very focused on reestablishing growth across the Pottery Barn brands. Last quarter I spoke to you about the Pottery Barn brand diagnostic work that we began in July with a third-party agency. This work included extensive customer research and showed that for our brand loyalists, Pottery Barn is a loved brand that is known for its comfortable style and high-quality products.
For others, less familiar with Pottery Barn, we're perceived as expensive, too predictable and not for them. We see clear opportunity to broaden our customer base without alienating our current brand loyalists by adding more diversity of aesthetics and scale and increasing value through more accessible price points. And we're very aligned around our brand positioning and opportunity to be the most inspiring American home design resource.
We're beginning to see the results of these initiatives with sequential process in the Pottery Barn brand through the third quarter, across several categories including our new furniture collections and textiles. In the coming seasons you'll see the methodical rollout of our product strategies across all four categories. We're also encouraged by our early holiday reads with an especially strong response to our holiday decorating and seasonal bedding offerings. In our stores we're increasing the density of gifting and easy entry decorating items that also fuel new customer acquisition.
We've improved the assortment of key gift items, making it easy for our guest to solve their gifting needs. Our holiday newness also includes a collaboration with renowned Indian fashion designer, Sabyasachi. The collection features an elegant -- an eclectic array of colorful, globally inspired textiles and decor. We have received great press in the international media and we believe collaborations of this nature will help us attract new customers and expand our global reach.
In Pottery Barn Kids, although we have had a slightly negative revenue comp, we saw improved trends across key categories. Furniture was an area of strength, driven by excellent customer response to our new furniture introductions and finishes. Our seasonal business is the highlight in the third quarter with record Halloween and back-to-school results. These strengths were offset by continued softness in the textile category. We plan to strengthen this category through increased collaborations and the evolution of our core aesthetic.
During the third quarter we launched our holiday collection and we believe we have a very compelling lineup for the season. We're encouraged by our early holiday reads across key gifting categories, we're expanding on the success of our Star Wars collection to include new categories with additional playroom and seasonal items. We've delivered new and innovative gifts for children of all ages, represent a unique design and lasting quality that Pottery Barn Kids stands for and we will be the destination for kid friendly holiday decorating, from stockings to ornaments, tabletop and decor.
Lastly, we introduced our first fair trade certified product, a holiday hand-felted collection from Nepal and we're committed to supporting the artists in our vendor community more robustly in 2017. In Pottery Barn Kids, collaborations that celebrate inspirational talent in the design community are a key component of our product strategy. We're thrilled to announce our collaboration with Italian designer and mother of two, Margherita Missoni which will launch in mid-January. The collection thoughtfully mixes vibrant colors, inviting textures and playful prints and captures Margherita's joyful and imaginative design aesthetic.
Now I'd like to talk about Pottery Barn Teen. Pottery Barn Teen results were disappointing. After a strong start to back-to-school and a successful dorm season we saw softening in our core furniture and textile businesses. Demand was sequentially better than in Q2, but inventory issues impacted our net comp more severely in Q3 than in Q2. Areas that we remain focused on are innovation and product categories, increased value proposition, improved inventory accuracy and enhanced marketing strategies to raise brand awareness. We have specific strategies each quarter across all of these initiatives. We've also made leadership changes in both merchandising and inventory over the last six months and the team is highly focused on delivering upon these key strategies.
Our expanded dorm offering was a highlight of the quarter, driven by quality textiles and runaway hits in easy decorating ideas. We believe that dorm represents a major opportunity for future growth and we plan to significantly increase this business. In the fourth quarter we're highlighting our offering of innovative high-quality gifts.
Here we've expanded upon our successful occasional seating category with new beanbags, media chairs and sectionals. We recently launched our Gifts That Give Back shop, where we have partnered with many of our collaborators to donate a portion of sales proceeds to the charity of their choice. Our collaborations remain an important strategy and continue to perform well. We have several more in the pipelines for 2017 that we believe will bring new customers into the brand.
Our upcoming spring collection will highlight many important product initiatives and the work of our new leadership team. We'll introduce new furniture collections and finishes, increase value in textiles and compelling decorating solutions at a great price. We're excited to offer our customers new ways to update their teen's rooms and solve their decorating needs.
I would now like to talk about Williams-Sonoma. In the third quarter, Williams-Sonoma comp brand revenues were essentially flat, up 0.1% on top of 1.2% in 2015. We continue to execute against our growth strategies, delivering high-quality products, acquiring new customers and transforming our retail and customer experience.
Our product strategy is centered around four primary efforts. A strong core of business built on the best brands in the industry, the expansion and growth of our branded Williams-Sonoma line, exclusive product offerings from our key branded partners and accelerated growth of Williams-Sonoma Home. Our core business remains healthy including cookware, bakeware and cutlery. We did experience some softness in electrics but our early read on new product launches are strong as we enter Q4.
Our own Williams-Sonoma branded merchandise has been proven to be incremental. Offering well-designed and affordable product has expanded the reach of our business and continues to be a sizable opportunity. During Q4 we will continue to launch new Williams-Sonoma products as key elements of our assortment strategy.
Our new customer acquisition efforts are focused not only in our stores and online but also outside of our four walls. Registry remains a success and we saw increases in registry creation, particularly from our store. All Williams-Sonoma stores have launched a new series of themed classes that include a product to take home. This series will run through the upcoming months for an exciting lineup of classes.
In addition, Williams-Sonoma is promoting its successful Cookbook Club series with a celebrity chef lineup for fall including, Alton Brown, Mario Batali and Ina Garten. Last month, Williams-Sonoma launched it Cookbook Club e-gift card just in time for the holiday season. Williams-Sonoma also announced several key sweepstakes, teaming up with American girl, Pop Sugar and Clean Plates to present the ultimate American Girl Party sweepstakes.
Williams-Sonoma also present a holiday London Calling Sweepstakes in partnership with Fortnum & Mason that will include a trip for two to London, an exclusive tour of the original Fortnum & Mason store and a Fortnum & Mason prize package. During the third quarter we participated in two phenomenal food festivals, Portland Feast and National Food and Wine Festival. This type of participation enables deeper relationships with both our professional and domestic cooking communities.
Also in Q3 we relaunched our Williams-Sonoma credit card program with a great new partner ADS. The launch has been a huge success. With ADS, we've been able to offer customers improved benefits that will result in greater customer engagement. The program offers enhanced loyalty rewards for our customers as well as a new private-label Williams-Sonoma credit card, in addition to our existing co-branded credit card. We're seeing great response to our card and the average transaction size on initial card purchases has increased.
At retail we remain committed to improving our customer experience through elevated service, new store management tools and reengineered processes. And as I mentioned earlier, our new store formats are working. Being a part of the community is deeply rooted in our culture and for the 6th straight year, Williams-Sonoma held its annual fundraising campaign benefiting No Kid Hungry. Through the efforts of our employees, our vendor community and our partners at No Kid Hungry, we were able to raise $1.5 million, more than double last year's contributions.
The Williams-Sonoma team has worked all year long to prepare for the holidays. We're entering Q4 well-positioned with our inventory and early indications are that we're off to a solid start. We have implemented new in-store strategies that we believe will provide a great customer experience. We have a strong seasonal lineup of gifts, with many of our favorites returning as well as some innovative new items and we're ready to execute online, in-store anytime our customers want to shop.
Now I'd like to provide an update on West Elm. In the third quarter West Elm delivered double-digit growth, with comp brand revenues increasing 12% compared to last year's 15.7%. The brand continues to experience gains across core segments, but was particularly strong in both furniture and lighting. In the third quarter, West Elm successfully opened 10 new locations across the United States and many of these store sites were carefully selected as part of the brand's commitment to honor and preserve historical buildings in neighborhoods, including a 1930s era post office arena, a 19th century coffee warehouse in Brooklyn and a mid-century building in the historic center of Savannah, Georgia.
In each location we also continue to broaden our partnerships with both the makers and designers through our West Elm local program, garnering big interest from both customers and communities. Great experiential retail continues to be central to our overall customer engagement strategy and is a competitive advantage for the West Elm brand.
In addition to relocating the brand's Brooklyn, New York store, West Elm moved their headquarters to the historic Empire stores building in Dumbo, New York. The new Brooklyn store and office further solidified West Elm's commitment to the neighborhood it has called home since its inception in 2002. Over the past two years, West Elm has expanded its scope from home furnishings to design that impacts everyday life at home, work and away.
In June 2015 the brand entered the $25 billion commercial furnishings market with West Elm workspace. This past September we announced our entry into the hospitality industry, with West Elm hotel. In partnership with hotel operator DDK, West Elm hotels create a unique venue to fully experience the brand and provides a rich opportunity to help change the future of hospitality.
We believe there's a growing desire among modern travelers to have a more immersive and rewarding experience in the places they are visiting. West Elm hotels will offer a differentiated experience by being wholly focused on the unique character of each location and its surrounding community. West Elm will drive the design and brand experience of each location and will lead brand marketing. DDK will lead property development with local developers and will be our exclusive operator. Neither West Elm nor Williams-Sonoma Inc. will have any real estate investments in West Elm hotels.
The first hotels are expected to open in late 2018. Importantly, these types of initiatives provide innovative ways for customers to experience our brand offerings outside of visiting a traditional retail store. Because of our online competitive advantage, we're uniquely poised to convert these innovative brand experiences into sales.
In September, West Elm also announced Sonos as its home sound system partner in all West Elm stores and online. West Elm is now the exclusive home retailer where customers can experience and purchase Sonos speakers and components as they consider other Home Furnishings decisions. Participating stores will provide sound as part of West Elm style in-service program and select locations will feature dedicated Sonos listening lab.
Additionally, West Elm announced product collaboration with Whole Foods Market, an exclusive holiday collection to benefit Whole Planet Foundation, a nonprofit organization that alleviates poverty around the globe. In partnership Guatemalan textile group, the new denim project, West Elm and Whole Foods Market introduced a 12-piece, limited time collection of kitchen and tabletop items crafted from premium upcycled denim. By delivering deeper and more meaningful customer experiences in all aspects of their lives at home, work and now while they travel, we believe West Elm is well-positioned to maintain its momentum on it journey to becoming a $2 billion brand.
Now I'd like to discuss our newer brands, Rejuvenation, Mark and Graham and our global businesses. In our Rejuvenation brand we delivered another strong third quarter, with double-digit growth in both the e-commerce and retail channels. Performance in our Rejuvenation stores is exceeding our expectations and we're excited to continue the success as we open our new Lincoln Park, Chicago, store this week.
Successful retail expansion in key markets is an important step in developing this brand and we look forward to sharing the results with you. Also key to the Rejuvenation brand is our focus on domestic manufacturing. In addition to much of our lighting which is manufactured by skilled crafts people at our factory in Portland, we're focused on building new partnerships across the country. Including partnerships with one of the last family-owned glass manufacturers in West Virginia, furniture makers in West Virginia and North Carolina and New York, metal workers in Connecticut and basket makers in Massachusetts. Domestic manufacturing is a key component of Rejuvenation's brand and we're excited about how we're expanding it into new categories.
We're very optimistic about the strong trends we see in Rejuvenation with our product line expansions. Our expansion into new aesthetics and product categories including chandeliers, furniture and functional accessories, continues to drive increased spend with our existing customers and to accelerate the acquisition of new customers.
Now I'd like to talk about Mark and Graham. Mark and Graham's growth in the third quarter came from new fall offerings in personal accessories and category expansions. Revenue was driven by innovative tech gifts and new key fashion handbags. During the quarter we saw success in offering affordable, customizable, luxury across diverse product categories and we're excited going into the holiday season.
We also continue to build momentum in our global business. Growth in the third quarter was driven primarily by strong performance in our company-owned businesses in Australia and the UK, as well as new store openings in our existing franchise and wholesale market. During the third quarter our global partners opened eight new locations, two stores in Mexico, one new store in Saudi Arabia and five additional shop-in-shop locations within John Lewis department stores in the United Kingdom.
We're on track to end the year with over 70 franchise and wholesale points of sale. While we seek opportunities to continue the growth of our existing partnerships, we maintain our focus to improve our operations to support new partners and market expansion in the upcoming year. In summary, despite a challenging retail environment we're optimistic about the future because of our strong portfolio of brands and customers, our strong and profitable e-commerce business generating over 50% of our revenue, our growth opportunities, our financial discipline and our very experienced team.
We're completely focused on exceeding our customers' needs and our investments in supply chain are key to both our current and future success. We'll continue to optimize all aspects of our business that we can control by executing against our strategic initiatives and we're confident that this will allow us to continue to deliver long term shareholder value, regardless of the short term uncertainty. I look forward to updating you again next quarter on our progress. I will now turn the call over to Julie Whalen to discuss our Q3 results in more detail and the guidance for the remainder of the year.
Thank you, Laura and good afternoon everyone. Our third quarter results once again reflect our ability to execute against our long term strategic growth and operational initiatives. And we're pleased that despite a challenging retail environment the continued success of these initiatives has allowed us to generate year-over-year positive revenue growth, improved gross margins and almost flat operating margin and earnings per share at the high end of our guidance range.
For the third quarter, net revenues increased 1.1% to $1.245 billion, with comparable brand revenues declining 0.4% compared to 4.5% growth last year. Revenue growth was driven by West Elm, our newer businesses and our international company owned businesses, all of which experienced double-digit year-over-year revenue growth. This strong revenue growth was partially offset by the top line softness we're seeing, particularly across the Pottery Barn brands which we believe have been most impacted by the overall softening of the retail environment.
During the quarter, we did however see improved trends across the brands and in Pottery Barn in particular we saw sequential improvement across several key categories. And as a result we believe this is why in October our Home Furnishings brand outperformed the home furnishings industry. In our e-commerce channel, net revenues grew 3.3% to $649 million driven by the continued growth in West Elm, Williams-Sonoma and Rejuvenation. E-commerce net revenues represented 52.1% of total Company net revenues, 110 basis point increase over last year.
Our retail channel net revenues decreased 1.2% to $597 million in the third quarter. Strong growth across West Elm, our international company owned businesses and Rejuvenation was offset by the declines we saw in the Pottery Barn brands. Gross margins for the third quarter improved 20 basis points year over year to 36.8% versus 36.6% last year despite occupancy cost deleverage of 60 basis points to $168 million versus $159 million last year.
We saw substantial improvements in our selling margins. Our focus in our supply chain initiatives has generated reduced shipping and fulfillment related costs and our direct sourcing advantage continues to drive material cost reductions, allowing us provide value to our customers and still maintain merchandise margins that are only slightly down to last year, despite continued pressure from a promotional retail environment.
SG&A for the third quarter was 27.9% versus 27.6% last year. The 30 basis points of deleverage was primarily associated with higher advertising costs from our decision to incrementally invest in e-marketing as a result of our increased focus on new customer acquisition, as well as general expense deleverage. These increases were partially offset by lower employment costs as a result of our 2016 corporate reduction in force.
Operating margin for the third quarter was 8.9% versus 9% last year. By channel, the operating margin in the e-commerce channel was 23.1% versus 21.9% last year. The 120 basis point improvement was primarily associated with higher gross margins resulting from improved year-over-year shipping and fulfillment related costs as a result of our focus on all of our supply chain and inventory initiatives.
This was partially offset by an increase in SG&A, primarily driven by higher advertising costs from the incremental e-marketing investments in new customer acquisition. We're pleased that this e-commerce operating margin puts us relatively back in line with the highest third quarter e-commerce operating margin we have seen.
The operating margin in the retail channel was 7.9% during the third quarter versus 8.1% last year. The 20 basis point decline in the retail operating margin was primarily associated with lower gross margins from occupancy deleverage, partially offset by SG&A leverage from strong financial discipline across advertising, general expenses and employment. This retail operating margin also reflects substantial sequential improvement from the second quarter, as last quarter our retail margins were impacted by our decision to more aggressively liquidate less productive SKUs and aged inventory to our retail outlets as part of our supply chain and inventory initiatives.
Corporate unallocated expenses as a percentage of net revenues were 6.9% versus 6.2% in 2015. The 70 basis point deleverage was driven by occupancy and general expenses, partially offset by lower employment costs as a result of our 2016 corporate reduction in force. We're pleased that despite lower revenues and planned incremental investments in digital marketing, we were able to minimize the margin and earnings impact with our supply chain efficiencies and our overall expense discipline, resulting in diluted earnings-per-share for the third quarter of $0.79 versus $0.77 last year.
On the balance sheet we ended the quarter with a cash balance of $75 million. As a reminder, given the seasonality of our business our cash levels reached their lowest point at this time of the year as we fund our business ahead of the holiday selling season. Year-to-date, we have invested $127 million in our business with an additional $49 million this quarter alone. And we have returned over $216 million to our shareholders, of which $72 million was in the third quarter, consisting of $39 million in stock repurchases and $33 million in dividends.
Merchandise inventories on the balance sheet decreased 3.5% to $1.064 billion at the end of the third quarter. Which includes the decrease in inventory on hand and available-for-sale of 6.3%. This decrease once again reflects our commitment to bring inventory growth below sales growth. Our inventory initiatives continue to drive these reduced inventory levels, as well as improved efficiencies in our supply chain.
Although inventory is down, primarily from reduced and less productive SKUs and aged inventory, we continue to have opportunity to improve our in stock positions. With fewer under stocks in key categories which has been driving back orders higher than we would like, particularly at Pottery Barn and Pottery Barn Teen. Our new inventory optimization tool will allow us to improve accuracy in our inventory purchases for our core products and in 2017 we should be able to measure our success.
I would now like to discuss our fourth quarter and FY16 guidance. For the fourth quarter we expect net revenues to be in the range of $1.570 billion to $1.650 billion, with comparable brand revenue growth in the range of negative 1% to 4%. We expect our fourth quarter operating margin to be slightly below last year and we're guiding earnings-per-share to be in the range of $1.45 to $1.55.
For the full year we're tightening our full-year guidance ranges by lowering the high end of the ranges to reflect our most recent third quarter results and our fourth quarter guidance. As a result, our full-year revenue guidance is expected to grow in the range of 2% to 3% to a range of $5.070 billion to $5.150 billion, with comparable brand revenue growth of 1% to 2%. We expect our operating margin to be in the range of 9.4% to 9.6% and our diluted earnings-per-share to be in the range of $3.35 to $3.45 per share. All other financial guidance within the press release remains unchanged from the previous guidance.
It is important to note that this guidance reflects our best estimate less than three weeks into our largest quarter and at a time when there is uncertainty. The recent presidential election and the unpredictable impact on the consumer and the retail environment have made providing future guidance difficult at this time. The guidance we're providing today does not contemplate any further changes, better or worse, in the retail landscape or consumer sentiment.
From a capital allocation perspective there are no changes to our plan. Given our strong operating cash flow we plan to continue to invest in the business, support our growth and operational initiatives in the range of $200 million to $220 million. We also plan to continue to return capital to our shareholders in the form of share repurchases and dividends. We have approximately $447 million remaining and available for share repurchases which as we said at the beginning of the year, we intend to repurchase over the next three years. We're also committed to continuing to pay dividends.
In summary, we believe we're well-positioned to deliver for our customers and our shareholders. Our well-known brands, our multi-channel model, our opportunities for growth and the success of all of our initiatives to date, as well as our solid balance sheet and strong financial discipline, give us confidence in our ability to deliver great customer service and long term sustainable growth for our shareholders
I would now like to open the call for questions, but before I do, I would like wish all of you happy holidays.
[Operator Instructions]. We will go to Matt Lasser with UBS.
On the Pottery Barn business, can you describe a little bit more by category where you saw the weakness and how you think the competitive landscape is playing into that? And let me just add a quick follow-up, it sounds like you're going after new customer acquisitions. What's been the outcome thus far, have you been able to be successful with that? Thank you.
By category, that really doesn't tell the story as much as it does when you look at what's selling and where we have fatigue. And we're really pleased to see that what we thought would sell is selling. That sounds like a very simplistic thing, but it's a good indication that we're on the right track.
And you can see with a brand the size of Pottery Barn that there's a lot of differences of aesthetic and styles that people relate to. There's some core aesthetic, there's emerging aesthetics and so we're very cognizant of keeping our current and loyal customers who love the brand top of mind and not changing what they come to the brand for. But at the same time we have an opportunity to attract new customers and we're doing that very carefully by looking at what they're buying and building other things in the future that are in the same aesthetic with what they've already purchased.
We also know that there's opportunity to design into lower price points. Price points where we used to be when we started the brand. And so it's a natural place to go to look at things that are smaller in scale, they're still great quality, but that are cheaper than some of the bestsellers that we've gotten accustomed to selling.
Also just in terms of our stores and the whole experience we know that new customers are usually attracted to the brands by lower price points. You don't often wake up in the morning and the first and you go to a brand by a bed. You might go in and buy a candle or a decorative item and so the holiday season in particular is a very important time of year to bring new customers in through smaller ticket items. And if you go to our stores and I hope you do, you'll see that we have a lot of great gifts.
We have a beautiful plaid collection and a paisley collection and we have -- not just the textiles we have a lot of scent in home decor in those categories. That are both beautiful but are also positioned to attract new customers.
We will take our next question from Matt Fassler with Goldman Sachs.
My primary question relates to operating margin any fourth quarter. Last year if I'm not mistaken your operating margin was around 14%. And so far this year your margin has been down very mildly, coming anywhere from 1 to 21 basis points, kind of in the middle there in the third quarter.
In the fourth quarter your revenue guidance isn't really worse than what you noted in Q3 and what you experienced in Q3 in terms of comparable brand revenue, but it seems like you imply the EBIT margin decline is greater. So if you could just talk about what's leaving that to happen which line item is more stubborn, whether it's fixed cost or whether it's promotional pressure to get those sales, what's factoring into your thought process there? Thank you so much.
A couple of things, first of all when we gave guidance last time from the implied Q4 perspective, it was already applied that margins would be down for the fourth quarter. But to walk you kind of through it, if there is an impact to the revenue guidance depending on where you believe will come out on that range and obviously it causes you to deleverage occupancy and some of the fixed cost more so.
But really, a couple of things that are play, is the incremental investments in e-marketing and we also are investing in supply chain labor to better serve our customers this holiday season. As you recall, you have to really attract, train and retain some of the best in this holiday season in order to serve the customer. And they're getting more and more competitive to get those people, so we're going for it and so there's a little bit of an investment there.
Also we believe it's going to be a promotional environment and probably more promotional than it has been. We have seen that the customer is shopping later and later and there's a lot of retailers that haven't had very good results; they've got a lot of extra inventory and they've got of get rid of it a very short time period. So we're also accounting on a little bit of some promotional pressure. Also though we still have the supply chain benefits rolling through, they have less of an impact when it's on our largest quarter and so we don't have as much of an ability to offset as we have in the past. So I think those are some of the biggest put and takes there.
We will take our next question from Christopher Horvers with JPMorgan.
One follow-up on Matt's questions, talking about the confidence in your sales outlook, you said a few things that perked my interest. So comps deteriorated sequentially from Q2 to 3Q despite an easier compare, but yet you are implying that at the midpoint it's going to be better. You mentioned that October for the home furnishings brands which I would assume includes Pottery Barn, outperformed the industry.
What was the industry performance in October? Are you benchmarking against the census retail sales data? And then related to that you did mention the election, do you have a high income customer base that tends to sit on the coast, so it is our interpretation that November is off to a choppier start given what's gone on in the world? Thank you.
Chris, I will take that, that's Julie. As far as October, the data that just came out showed that it was down I think -1.7% and that's that NIICS-442 I believe it is home furnishings industry. And so we specifically called that out in the script because I think a couple things, we typically as you know don't give color throughout the quarter. But because we're working on a specific initiative at Pottery Barn and we saw that these trends sequentially improved, so much so that we saw the results of the home furnishings industry relative to our home furnishings brand and the fact that we outperformed, give us a lot of confidence in the long term for our Pottery Barn brands. We thought it was important to tell you that.
Secondly, I think you're picking up on the clues that we're saying about the timing of when we're giving guidance. Obviously there is a -- we believe every retailer is going through whether they're discussing it or not, there's a little bit of a time period where there are cautious consumers as result of the election and so it's a difficult time to set guidance. With that said, we also have a little bit of an easier compare year over year.
When you look at Q4 last year we were at 0.8% versus last Q3 was a 4.5%. So it's a different hurdle to get over. The way we set the guidance which I'm sure you guys can do your own math and figure out, is basically at the low-end of the negative 1 and holding it relatively close to where our 1 year trend is for Q3. And at the high end at 4%, it's is holding it relatively close, slight improvement to the two-year trend relative to Q3. And we think at this time that is the right guidance to provide.
We will take our next question from Greg Melick with Evercore ISI.
I had a quick follow-up on that one and my real question was about inventory. Did I get that right Julie that your sales in October were better than negative 1.7% or better than positive 1.7%?
The industry, my recollection is a negative 1.7% so I'm saying that we outperformed the industry in October.
Better than that in the home furnishing brands?
But I really wanted to talk about with inventory. Looks like you're down a little over 3% year over year. I remember from last quarter you talked about not having enough opening price point items or maybe not marketing to that enough, could you help us give us an update on where we're with that in the context of inventory being less now than it was last year? Are you where you want to be? Is it the right inventory, is it not enough? Have we shifted to that--
We're never going to be where we want to be because inventory is one of the most difficult thing retailers do. We've made a lot of improvements and we still see tons of opportunity in the future. What we've done is we've reduced our overstock substantially versus last year and that's allowed us to better serve our customers because we can more quickly, efficiently get to what they've purchased versus carrying and storing a bunch of things that aren't selling and that's been really positive.
We've also, as you know regionalized at the same time which on the one hand makes things more complicated for inventory management and the other hand it's better for your customer. So we're balancing that and then at the same time within each brand there's different strategies and so what I talked about in terms of lower price points is not really an inventory in stock opportunity it's more of mix of what you're carrying. And so it's really important in all these home furnishings businesses to have a great combination of considered purchase and also traffic drivers and things that allow customers to have a piece of the brand without spending $2000.
In terms of the cash and carry that you see in our stores and the lower ticket, we're in a pretty good stock position going into the holidays. There are some pockets of things as there always will be, it’s a high-class problem of where you have oversold and you shape the inventory. I guess the good news, bad news is that we have quite a few pockets of those in Pottery Barn.
The big opportunity for us to better predict those items in the future and these have been things they've chasing since the beginning of Q3. So we expect to be able to get them in at the very least at the end of Q4, if not the very beginning of Q1. And then once you're in stock, these cycles on these best-sellers last longer than they do in apparel. So we should see our in stock go up next year as we get -- as we catch up with these best-sellers.
So just to make sure I got it right the down 3% inventory, you're comfortable with where you are now with that. But we might see that actually go up a little bit as we get ready for Q1? So the down 3% in inventory --
You can look at a total number, but really the quality of the inventory is by brand there's a lot of things going into that. What we've said is that we're going to grow inventory flow in the sales. Who knows how low you can go and be in stock at the same time. But it's not about taking inventory down; it's also about being in stock.
We will take our next question from Peter Benedict with Robert Baird.
I have a question on the fleet optimization efforts that Laura had mentioned. And you give us a sense of maybe what really is working in some of the remodels and what potentially could be the pace of remodel effort as you look into next year?
Sure. Like anything else we're measured about looking at ROI. So in each of our brands I've mentioned [indiscernible]. So particularly in the brands with the more mature fleet, Williams-Sonoma, Pottery Barn. And so you saw in Williams-Sonoma bring in a new look at Ponce, a new look at South Coast Plaza, last year those worked and that's what all new stores are getting. And then we're doing selective remodels, so I mentioned earlier in my script where we're really reading the results of those remodels to make sure we get our investment back.
And we're going to continue through the balance of this year and get through holiday and then make an assessment for next year. Same approach for Pottery Barn, except we have a bit of a different test going on. We have the full remodel like we did in Corte Madera and some other locations. But then we also had these mini refreshes and we just tried four more of those to see if we can't give the stores a bit of a paint job and some other new fixturing pieces and have them look really fresh and new without doing a full remodel. So we're really reading results too early to come out and say how many we're going to do next year, but we're very pleased with our initial results.
We will take our next question from Brad Thomas with KeyBanc Capital Markets.
Hoping to ask about international and how that's been affecting profitability of the business? And then -- well, maybe a little bit early and you might not want to give comments on 2017, any puts, takes you might highlight in terms of investments, such as international or supply chain as we think about 2017? Thank you.
Hello Brad it's Julie, to can give you an update on global and where we're. It grew, just so you guys know you'll see in the Q, obviously. It grew 3.5% in total to about $83 million. We did specifically call out though, you'll see in the script, that our company owned our own stores and our own websites did phenomenally well during the quarter. Strong double-digit, so we continue to see that.
And so it's really exciting. From a profitability perspective at the same time the loss that we incur on the company owned stores has come down by half and so we're making considerable progress there, we're profitable in total and have been all year. From a margin perspective profitability, because there was less franchise revenue, you saw less of an impact on the gross margin, but obviously that is accretive to the op, so there was an impact on the bottom.
But the net result you should take from it, it's going very strong and it's improving profitability as we continue to move through the years. Regarding 2017, we're not prepared today to give any future outlook on 2017.
We will take our next question from Dan Binder with Jefferies.
Just wanted to ask you a question on the promotional environment, obviously it's been pretty promotional. I was just curious when you look at what seems to be resonating with customers, are they the same things that were before, how is that changing? And then curious how your friends and family promotion went recently, I saw you had extended it a couple of days?
We haven't seen any pullback in the promotional environment. As Julie said, we think in fact because of some people having more inventory than they like, that it could get more promotional. The customers are smart, they are looking for the best value, but not at the expense of quality. And we have also tested some different shipping offers because we want to see if they're more price-sensitive to shipping versus total price and we haven't come to any conclusion on that yet. But we know that customers are definitely interested in the best price they can get and what we feel great about is that our exclusive design capabilities and direct sourcing advantages allows us to deliver outstanding quality to great value.
If I could just ask a related question, you talked about the merchandise margins only being down slightly. When you look across the brand portfolio is that the case across each brand or is there a big differences is when you look at each brand?
We don't really give it by brand, but I wouldn't say there's much difference across.
We have time for one more question. We will go to Budd Bugatch with Raymond James.
Just if you could give us an update on Braselton, how that's operating and maybe what that impact has been to improve deliveries and where you've seen that?
Yes, Braselton been a great addition to our company. As Laura said in her script that it is about 75% full and it's reducing freight costs and even more importantly it's getting our goods to our customers three to five days quicker. So its been a huge win for our Company.
Our team has done a great job there, so while we have the question I just want to do a shout out to the Atlanta Team, Braselton team, for doing a wonderful job serving our customers there.
When do you think it will be full and what you think it will impact -- how it impact will margins or how will we see it in the financials?
In 2017 we'll expect it will get a little fuller. Obviously we don't want to be at 100%, that's not necessarily the targets you want, you want to have a little bit of capacity room within the DC so shooting for 85% to 90%, something like that. And we're already seeing the benefit, so obviously as we continue to get a little bit more full with having less freight costs and quicker shipping delivery times we will see that benefit continue to grow as we move through 2017.
Thank you, that concludes our question-and-answer session for today. I will now turn the comments back over to Ms. Alber for any additional or closing remarks.
Well I want to say thank you all for your interest and your support and as Julie said, happy holidays.
Thank you. Ladies and again that does conclude today's conference, thank you all again for your participation.
Copyright policy: All transcripts on this site are the copyright of Seeking Alpha. However, we view them as an important resource for bloggers and journalists, and are excited to contribute to the democratization of financial information on the Internet. (Until now investors have had to pay thousands of dollars in subscription fees for transcripts.) So our reproduction policy is as follows: You may quote up to 400 words of any transcript on the condition that you attribute the transcript to Seeking Alpha and either link to the original transcript or to www.SeekingAlpha.com. All other use is prohibited.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HERE IS A TEXTUAL REPRESENTATION OF THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S CONFERENCE CALL, CONFERENCE PRESENTATION OR OTHER AUDIO PRESENTATION, AND WHILE EFFORTS ARE MADE TO PROVIDE AN ACCURATE TRANSCRIPTION, THERE MAY BE MATERIAL ERRORS, OMISSIONS, OR INACCURACIES IN THE REPORTING OF THE SUBSTANCE OF THE AUDIO PRESENTATIONS. IN NO WAY DOES SEEKING ALPHA ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS MADE BASED UPON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THIS WEB SITE OR IN ANY TRANSCRIPT. USERS ARE ADVISED TO REVIEW THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S AUDIO PRESENTATION ITSELF AND THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S SEC FILINGS BEFORE MAKING ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS.
If you have any additional questions about our online transcripts, please contact us at: firstname.lastname@example.org. Thank you!