How Will The Internet Change Financial Advisor Fee Schedules?

by: Jack Waymire

Summary

How much disclosure on your website is necessary?

What statement should advisors make about their fees on their websites?

Is your competition willing to disclose more information on their websites?

The focus of this article is information that resides on financial advisor websites.

The new challenge for financial advisors is what information do they disclose to investors on their websites and what information is deliberately withheld from investors.

Multiple Websites

At the risk of stating the obvious, you should assume investors are going to visit five or more financial advisor websites before they determine whom they want to contact.

They have access to hundreds of advisor websites by entering a few geo-specific keywords. Their only limitation is the amount of time they want to spend researching financial advisors.

Top 10 Questions

There is an easy way to determine what information should be disclosed on financial advisor websites. What are the top 10 questions investors ask advisors when they interview you?

Near the top of the list are the questions: "What will your advice and services cost me?" Or, "How are you compensated?" Or, "What is your compensation amount?"

Four Choices

Disclosure, also known as transparency, is epitomized by the information that is disclosed about financial advisor fees and combined expenses - including fees charged by third parties.

There are four distinct website strategies that impact the disclosure of fees:

  1. Provide no information about fees
  2. Provide educational content about fees
  3. Provide limited information about fees
  4. Provide comprehensive information about fees

The "No Information" Alternative

You can disclose no information on your website that describes how you are compensated or how much you receive.

Your argument is your fees vary by client so you cannot describe the cost of your services until you have more input from a prospective client.

This statement belongs on your website if you choose not to disclose expenses.

Very few advisors disclose they may also be compensated with commissions - investment or insurance.

This argument is logical, but it may not fly if your competitors are disclosing their fees and other expenses on their websites.

The "Educational Content" Option

A more popular strategy is to educate investors about how you are paid without actually telling them what you receive.

For example, you might make one or more of the following statements:

"I am compensated with an asset-based fee (% of assets)."

"I am compensated with a fee just like you compensate other professionals (CPAs, attorneys) for their specialized knowledge, advice, and services."

"I am compensated with a fixed or hourly fee for my planning advice and services."

"I am compensated quarterly in arrears so there are no advance payments."

The "Limited Information" Option

Another strategy is to disclose your fee, like the Robos and Virtual Advisors, but do not disclose the fees of third party service providers.

In this case you may or may not disclose your full fee schedule. For example:

  • 100 bps on the first $1,000,000
  • 75 bps on the next $2,000,000
  • 50 bps on the next $2,000,000
  • 35 bps on amounts over $5,000,000

Instead, you may communicate that your fee schedule starts at 100 bps and declines to 35 basis based on the asset amount that is invested with you.

You may also disclose a minimum fee without disclosing an actual fee schedule. For example, your minimum annual fee is $5,000, the equivalent of 100 bps on $500,000 of assets.

The "Comprehensive" Alternative

The comprehensive alternative is to practice full disclosure for all of the expenses that will be deducted from investors' assets.

You may decide to use case studies on your website to describe expenses for various scenarios. For example:

  • The fee for your advice and services
  • The fee charged by the money manager (ETF, mutual fund)
  • The fee charged by a custodian (if applicable)

Very few advisors practice this level of transparency for good reason. Their services vary by client; consequently their fees vary by client. For example, a client who wants active management will pay a higher fee than a client who wants passive management.

What about the Competition?

Whichever disclosure strategy you select, it should be based on what key competitors are doing in your primary markets.

Which strategy are they using to withhold information, educate investors about financial expenses, or provide partial/full disclosure for their expenses?

Fee Compression

Based on a 2016 Paladin survey, 71% of financial advisors are concerned about the potential for fee compression. They believe the Robos and Virtual Advisors are creating increased awareness about what advisors charge for their advice and services.

Transparency does not create fee compression. However, it will create the need for better value propositions that justify fees and differentiate advisors.

Investors' Best Interests

There is a good chance you are a financial fiduciary (RIA or IAR). You are obligated to always put investor interests first.

It is hard to rationalize how withholding key information about expenses is in the investors' best interest.

It stands to reason, withholding expense information is in the advisor's best interest so it can be communicated during a sales call.

Withholding this information on websites will be increasingly risky when some financial advisors disclose the information and some choose not to.

Lead Generation

Even if you are using the services of a lead generation company you may be impacted by how investors use the internet to determine whom they meet with.

For example, a lead generation company sends you a referral. It is your responsibility to follow up to convince the referral to meet with you. Follow-up may be by telephone or email.

The lead generation company also sends information about you to investors. The introduction includes a link to your website. What if the prospect visits your website, but does not have a good experience?

When you call the prospect to schedule an appointment the investor does not take or return your call.

The problem is your website and you may not even know it is having a negative impact on your ability to convert leads into meetings.

Credibility & Trust

The role of website transparency is to create credibility and trust. Trust is the key to convincing investors to give up their anonymity and initiate contact with you.

Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.